Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Safety - Risk or Certainty?

Posts

Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#1

Safety - Risk or Certainty?

Geoff Whaling

I posted some images to FB of the leading pages of six articles I had published in the UK Woodturning magazine last year (#252 to #257). In one day they generated a reasonable amount of feedback, more than since publication, but that was only within my "Friends" settings. (Unfortunately I can't post all of the images here as they exceed file size requirements.)

The leading article introduce the concept of adding certainty to both the quality of output and the safety of the woodturner, the following articles about identifying the common hazards and sources of risk then setting in place controls to manage hazards and risk. Not a new concept by any means as it is heavily inspired by Pye's and Hogbin's work and compiled / borrowed from very common place industry safety management programs. There is so much readily available & useful information about how to add certainty to being able to enjoy our wood turning craft without injury. However turners seem to either be unaware of them or in denial that injuries do occur.

Stephen Hogbin's & David Pye's works and a particular quote of Stephen Hogbin's have always resonated with me.

“Whatever each of us makes, whether it is thoughtfully or intuitively developed, is an expression of ourselves, our environment, our social mores and a belief system.” – “The Purpose of Making”, by Stephen Hogbin, FWW #13 1978.

Pye’s and Hogbin’s concepts apply to design however their concepts translate in a very meaning full manner into safety – do we take our chances each time we enter the workshop or do we have a systematic approach to minimise risk?

This has made me curious as to how widely read is UK Woodturning magazine in the United States & Canada?

&

Are turners in denial that quite severe injuries, particularly head injuries leading to traumatic brain injuries, do occur & with quite high frequency in wood turning?

For any one going to the AAW’s Phoenix symposium I urge you to sit in on Lynne Yamaguchi’s rotations.




Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#2

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

Bill Howatt

I can't give you a hard number pertaining to the readers of Woodturning but I can say that it is read by some members of our woodturning club in Ottawa Ontario and I believe it is available at some magazine outlets perhaps in the hobby section.

It would be easy to say turners are unaware of the potential seriousness of lathe accidents. I don't think it is true because the real bad accidents I am aware of happened to experienced turners that one might assume know better. The issue seems to be turning unsafe wood rather than unsafe turning if you dare make the distinction. Of course, this hazard may be compounded by too high a rotation speed - another thing that is more likely to be done by an experienced turner than a scared new-turner.

I always try to remember that performing an unsafe practice without incident 10,000 times does not make it a safe practice the next time.

It is easy to look at the whirling teeth on a tablesaw blade and be aware of the hazard. A whirling piece of stock on a lathe with an almost stationary cutter looks pretty safe in comparison and for this reason new turners are often surprised that a lathe is dangerous. I remember somebody saying, "Your other tools can maim you but your lathe can kill you". When i repeat this I can tell you that a lot of people think I'm nuts.

Bill

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#3

Jim Barbour

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

Jim Barbour

I, for one, am a regular reader of Woodturning, though I have had to limit myself to the electronic version with the last rate increase. I am unsure of the sensitivity of turners to safety issues; there seems a pretty cavalier attitude in some circles and a very thoughtful one in others. It may be that as the initial fear of the spinning wood subsides we move to a false sense of well being until our first dramatic accident. Then, whether or not we were harmed, we come away MUCH wiser and more careful. At least that's the path I seem to have followed, and am lucky to not have been injured with a couple of pretty spectacular "flyings apart".

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Us men

lyle Jamieson

I think us men especially but some women too...don't need to read instructions...don't ask for directions...don't need help...we think trial and error will sooner or later get us there. Well when the error can hurt or kill you, that might not be the wise way to take up turning. A table saw can cut a finger or two off, a lathe can kill you.

I was fortunate to have some really great teachers very early in my learning curve. My dad stresses safety with all the woodworking tools I learned to use as a kid. And I have had some close calls but still have all my body parts. The most serious stupid thing I did is get a nasty catch on the band saw. Luckily the saw and wood took the brunt of the error and I did not get hurt. Now, I never use the band saw on a turning blank.

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#5

I prefer volunteers ...

Geoff Whaling

Lyle, I can relate to that ;-)

I prefer getting my experience from someone else so selflessly volunteering to be the guinea pig, perhaps unwittingly though. Almost every mistake that can be made has been done so hundreds of times over but we still get new recruits finding out for themselves.

A good tutor / mentor is worth a life long friendship IMO.

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Right on!!


Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#7

Re: Us men

DKWalser

Lyle - Some of us (of both genders) simply will not learn except through our own experience. It's not merely that we won't read the instructions, we reserve the right to edit the instructions if they don't make sense (to us). I once tried to correct my brother-in-law's stance at a tablesaw. (I used to be the safety office at a furniture mill.) No matter how I explained it, he simply couldn't understand how what he was doing was dangerous. After a half-hour, I gave up and told my sister to up the life insurance. Six months later, he called to tell me I had been right. The saw kicked back the piece of wood he was ripping. It missed him, but he'd learned!

It takes humility to learn things from instruction rather than experience. That's why I'm glad I was such a humble kid -- it's how I learned all I'll ever need to know.

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#8

Lyle Jamieson

good point


Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#9

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

phillip Medghalchi

Geoff, here is my take on the subject. I think (in my opinion) (others may not agree) the subject matter of safety is not the main issue being ignored. Turners are aware and have at least heard about this issue of the safety, however, to most this craft of turning comes as a hobby and when you have to justify forking out almost $400.00 for a safety gear then your other best half will have some saying in the matter. What I wonder for instance in the case of Trend face shield (not calling any names out, because they are the one of the only makers) that markets this product for $400. what or how they think that turners are going to easily fork out that much money? Of course, you may argue that when the accident happens it will cost more in expenses to fix the problem or you may not be around for it to get it fixed. I can use the analogy of buying cars. We all know that it has 4 wheels and will get you to form point A to B, however, then you got Mercedes at almost $80,000 + pr you got the little ol Ford for $12000.00 they would do the same thing of getting you to your destination however, if you get hit the Ford will get you to the Hospital with big bill and Mercedes may just get you scratched. but, how many people will buy the Mercedes? All along knowing that it is a safer car.

Now, back to the subject. when you see that there are only two or three manufacturers for the face shield and our craft is really a hobby so there is no boss or the company that you work for to buy you the shield, in most instances the turner will put the idea of buying the shield in back of their mind.

As the evidence in our craft suggest that we all are frugal in spending so we keep the cost low and therefor this subject falls in the same category. Yes, I do have face shield and not the Trend , but the one that majority of US use (Uvex). I have learned form the beginning that if I can not turn by standing to one side of the lathe out of line of fire then i have no business turning, and have been able to stay out of accident zone ( I have had many catches and blow outs) luckily, have been able to be to the side of it.

Unfortunately, I noticed that most of the accidents do happen to the more experienced turners who think that they have more knowledge and more luck and they get hit by not using their shield or other safety measures.

I hope that the manufacturers will see this thread and try to make it more affordable for the turners to acquire these gears and stay safer.

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#10

Free safety ....

Geoff Whaling

Phillip, you raise excellent points. I agree it is very easy to say" you should do..." but in many situations the $400 would be comparable to the investment in the lathe itself or the difference between a basic or upgraded new mini lathe or in paying bills.

When you have limited means it is always a stretch to purchase the personal protective equipment (PPE). Regetably it will always be a value argument, balancing risk, desires & benefits. It would be nice to see all turners wearing the works in personal protective equipment. Only an individual can decide what is of value to them.

Personally I would like to see simplified broad recommendations on PPE and safety controls for various levels of turning project and the associated levels of risk.

Say minimum, better, best options for approved PPE e.g.

Pen turning / small spindle projects

Minimum - safety spectacles - $10

Better - safety spectacles + face shield + disposable mask dust protection -$45

Best - safety spectacles + approved respirator + face shield OR approved impact rated respirator helmet - $200 to $500

And the same for equipment such as lathes, drill presses table saws etc.

Minimum - accessible power switch

Better - accessible power switch + emergency stop feature.

Best - accessible power switch + emergency stop feature + relocatable control panel.

One message that is very hard to get across is that many of the actions that turners can implement to improve their safety are actually FREE.

It does not cost one cent to check over the tools, turning blanks, the lathe, your workshop environment, power cords, store flammable items away, clean up waste, or to set aside a "dangerous" turning blank.

It is also relatively FREE, certainly low cost, to read up on the known hazards in wood turning and about how to minimize the risk.

What is also FREE is changing our attitude towards hazards & risk. Once we are aware of how to implement controls to eliminate, substitute or reduce hazards we can minimize risk.

Even reading through one document can assist

http://www.woodworkforums.com/showthread.php?t=164022

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#11

Re: Us men

Geoff Whaling

Lyle, Good to see you mention this in your newsletter - thank you.

ps I'm an Aussie & a Queenslander to boot, we're very different just ask a kiwi, crow eater, sand groper, territorian, cockroach or a mexican. :D

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#12

Re: Free safety ....

Barry L Elder

Most of the "free safety" devices equal common sense. When I decided, many years ago, to develop confidence in my approach to woodturning, I would spend many hours each day to learn the what, why, when, where, and how of turning crappy wood. The trees I had salvaged after the 'canes of 2004 had been on the ground for at least 5 months and had a lot of cracks. When I would start turning a candidate full of cracks, I would turn for a minute or two, stop the lathe and examine the cracks to see if any were expanding, turn for another little while, and repeat, and repeat, and repeat, and repeat. I like to feel that I became humble enough to avoid dangerous incidents with the liberal use of CA glue and lots of time. I took the time to learn how to sharpen gouges when I got tired of hot shavings burning the back of my left hand. Over time I learned to toss the blanks that would blow out since I had more time since retiring. I experimented with oak, elm, and tropical woods. God was generous beyond belief and guided me through months and months of practice. I like to think that what little common sense I have, He developed in my brain to allow me to continue.

Most of the accomplished woodturner/artists I know do turn without sufficient protection at the lathe, but would never teach anyone else their way! I guess I'm old-fashioned enough to use a big face shield that's all scarred up from many years of use, but never do I turn on a lathe while "naked".

Re: Safety - Risk or Certainty?

#13

Great approach to safety

Geoff Whaling

Barry,

I like your approach. It is a pity many turners just do not simply stop the lathe & look. Many developing hazards can be found by simply checking as you go, and a decision to discard or to repair & proceed made.

Having the fundamentals of turning helps though particularly attention to

Blank selection - stability, defects etc;

Adequate blank mounting to suit the size/mass of the blank;

Tool sharpening, presentation & control;

Lathe speed management;

I dropped into visit a friend conducting an intermediate wood turning class yesterday to see how it was going. He was earning his keep with a good mix of turners with varying levels of skills. Some listen & pay attention; some simply will do what they want "to do it their way" no matter what instruction, advice & warnings/cautions are given to them. Human nature I guess.