Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

99% hollower...

Posts

99% hollower...

#1

Steven Antonucci

99% hollower...

steven antonucci

No idea if I have ever posted this, but if I have, here it is again:

For all practical purposes, I think I can claim that I "invented" this version of the hollowing bar first popularized by Ellsworth (as far as I know?)

The new thing that I claim is the dual position capabilities, in that the cutter can be mounted either straight or at the angle. In addition, because the cutter is locked with a set screw, you can make cutters that are a little longer to be able to reach further over for undercutting shoulders. A quarter turn is all you need to drop in a new cutter, and as they get shorted from sharpening, you can just replace the longer one... the longer one becomes the shorter ones.


To start with, I have a steel bar that I source from the local big box store. In general, you pay around $13 for 3' of 5/8". This one is galvanized, but only because I didn't see the standard cold rolled in the rack. Pretty much any steel bar will work. If you have a local scrap yard, you can buy odd bits for next to nothing.

Machining this may sound intimidating, but I assure you it is not. The first bar that I ever made was drilled with a cordless drill by hand and eyeball. If you own machine tools, feel free to use them, but I assure you that the holes are not required to be machine tolerances.

After cutting the rod to length, I hold it in the headstock of my lathe between the jaws on the four jaw chuck. Set the lathe speed to your slowest speed (200rpm for me). Drilling into the metal requires a starting mark, which can be made with a punch or carefully with the drill bit point. Once you have a center point, put a drop of oil on it, and you can begin drilling your longitudinal hole. Back the drill out frequently to clear the metal shavings, and be sure to wear eye protection and gloves. Those metal splinters are like razors.

I usually drill my hole out about 1" deep, give or take. I won't over-complicate the angled hole- I grind a small flat in the edge, punch it to get my starting point, and then drill it by eye, aiming for a 45 degree angle. When it breaks through to the center line hole, I usually drill into the other side by 1/16" or so, as it help register the cutter in the hole.

Last hole needs to go from the top side (or the bottom) and is located where the first two holes intersect. I have a pretty good eye, so I always have my hole pretty much dead on, but you can use the angled hole to visualize where it needs to be. The longitudinal hole is on center line, so you just need to know how far back to spot it. I grind a little flat on the top because it is much easier to punch my mark on a flat than it is on the round.

Now that holes are drilled, you just need to tap a thread in the top hole. A little oil, turn the tap, back it out. I usually turn the tap between an 1/8 and 1/4 rotation before backing it out. When the tap bottoms out in the hole (and it will), you may not have finished your thread to the bottom. If you cut the last 1/2" off the bottom of another tap, you can use it as a bottoming tap to finish your threads.

On to the cutters and their sizes. I buy 10% cobalt cutters from Enco for about $3 each, and they get cut into two or three cutters of different lengths. I use either 1/8" cutters or 3/16" cutters, and I drill my holes just smaller than the diagonal of the cutter. For a 3/16" cutter, this means a 1/4" hole. A light pass on the grinder to relieve the corners of the cutter until it fits completes the job. You do not need to or want to make the shank of the cutter round. the goal is to make an octogon with 4 long sides (existing flats of cutters) and 4 short sides (1/64" facets)

Make yourself a handle or put it in your favorite system, and you are ready to cut...

This bar will cut 99% of the vessels posted on most woodturning sites. It will probably not reach the outer corner of a small opening, wide, flat vessel... but we'll save that for another time...

Steve

Re: 99% hollower...

#2

Re: 99% hollower...

John Lucas

Steve YOu didn't say how long the bar is. I would be pretty nervous about hanging 12" or more out of my 4 jaw chuck. As long as everything goes OK your fine but if that bar gets off center at 200 rpm it will go sideways extremely rapidly and could do a lot of damage.

I think you would be a lot safer just drilling the end by hand as you suggested. It doesn't really matter if the hole goes in straight.

I have 2 bars that I used most often. One has the cutter straight in and the other has the cutter mounted at an angle like yours. Consequently your idea is sound because it incorporates the 2 I use most.

Re: 99% hollower...

#3

Steven Antonucci

The secret sauce...

steven antonucci

My headstock taper is a #2. With standard jaws (50mm), when you close them down on a 5/8" bar, the bar sits in the taper and is held almost perfectly in between the jaws. I usually wear a gloved hand to act as a steady rest up by the drilled end. It is a non-event.

As soon as you put the drill point in, it acts like another center.

If the bar won't go into your taper (e.g. 3/4" or 1"), drilling by hand it the ticket.

S

Re: 99% hollower...

#4

Re: 99% hollower...

Don Evans

Sorry Steve, but you weren't first nor was Elsworth. The metal lathe industry has had this type of hollowing (boring bars) for many many years, probably longer than you are old.

I got one for my metal lathe about 25 years ago, it has square holes (broched is how they are done square) and I use 3/16" square cutters in it. One end the hole is about 45 deg and the other end the hole is straight through.

With a cutter in either end it can be placed in a larger holder like Lyle Jamiesons unit, just one example.

FYI, I have square HSS cutters that are 1" square x 4" long.

Don

Re: 99% hollower...

#5

Steven Antonucci

Only the two hole tip ;-)

steven antonucci

No doubt that others have come up with solutions throughout the ages and adapted from other areas and mediums. Not trying to get rich, but at least to my own knowledge, I have never seen a bar that had two positions for the cutter... seems like a great way to cut costs... and I am pretty cheap.

If I sold tools, I would probably make two of them ;)

S

Re: 99% hollower...

#6

Very cool, Steve!


Re: 99% hollower...

#7

Re: 99% hollower...

phillip Medghalchi

Steve, a master turner in my area that I respect his opinion once said that there is no tool or any design that we do nowadays on our turnings that has not been done in times past and everything we do today one way or another was done or created before wood turning was fancied up and glamorized by all new carbide or HSS like it is today. That's why it is very difficult to get a patent on tools or turnings that we do.

I am sure if you'd asked David Ellsworth he would have his version of the story, so we give you the credit that you showed us your tool, as for the who came up with it first, we just leave it alone so we won't start a claim dispute here.

Thanks for sharing your idea of the hollower.

Re: 99% hollower...

#8

Re: 99% hollower...

Keith Newton

Steve, you said, "Pretty much any steel bar will work. If you have a local scrap yard, you can buy odd bits for next to nothing". Like you, I bought some round mild steel rods back when I was making some of my tools. Then I ended up scavaging some stainless rectangle strips, that I rounded off the corners, to make them more closely match the elliptical shape that a small round becomes when entered from an angle. These tools are a lot stiffer than the mild steel round.

If any of want to check your salvage yards, skeleton plate is what they call the big sheets which have had parts cut out leaving this material from between the parts.

Re: 99% hollower...

#9

Re: 99% hollower...

phillip Medghalchi

?????????????? you lost me.

Re: 99% hollower...

#10

Re: 99% hollower...

John Lucas

Keith Not sure what happened around here but you can no longer go into the salvage or scrap metal yards and buy metal. I used to do that all the time but they stopped letting you in. Possibly liability would be my bet.

The same is true with our chip mill. We used to go there and they would let us cut up whatever logs we wanted before it became mulch. Now they stopped.

We aren't supposed to remove logs from the dump but I went in there with a truck load of brush one time and came out with several logs that I know weighted more than the brush. The lady that weights and monitors the dump didn't say anything.

Re: 99% hollower...

#11

Re: 99% hollower...

Keith Newton

All of it????

Stiffness of a rod or beam, is relative to it's height. If you draw a circle, as Steve suggested 5/8", then draw vertical lines through it, dividing it into 5 sections. Only the middle section will be 5/8 tall. The next two out are probably ~1/2", and the outside ones, really are more dead weight, than adding much stiffness. There is less metal in a 3/8" x 5/8" bar than the 58' round, but it would be much stiffer. Round rods also resonate more, thus will chatter quicker.

Using the same amount of metal in a hollow box beam is a way to make it even stiffer using the same amount of metal.

Re: 99% hollower...

#12

Steven Antonucci

It's not obvious ;-)

steven antonucci

Taken from a Physics website:

The way to think about it is that if I bend a rod, I am placing one side under tension and the opposite side under compression. Somewhere in between, there is a line where the material is neither under tension or compression. I can therefore remove this material without affecting the strength - I've now turned a rod into a tube, which is pound-for-pound stronger than a rod.

Read more: http://www.physicsforums.com

Steve