A friend has asked me to turn several replacement spindles for an antique urn like stand. here is a picture of one of the spindles (total of eight) that are arrayed around a center turned section.
is the best way to copy this challenging piece to make a story stick with small sharpened brads to mark the transition points... I was planning to use a skinny parting tool and a couple of small skews to turn these
Any pointers on how to approach making a set of 8 of these skinny spindles
A string steady really wont do anything for you. Works well to keep long thin spindles from whipping but won't stop chatter while your turning.
Just start in the middle where it will whip the most. Then work your way left and right turning each element as you go. If you have enough wood to put one end in the chuck it will help reduce whipping.
I suspect I may be offering more than you need, but once I got started thinking through how I would approach this it just ran away with me. The curse of being a professor!!
You really have two spindles, reversed and joined by a disc in the center. Think of them as a left (headstock side) and right spindle.
I think I would chuck and turn my stock to the diameter of the center disc, then cut away the center with a very narrow parting tool, making the cut flat on the fillet and then slightly concave on each side. When I cut it away I would remove the tailstock side first and, while everything is centered, drill a 3/16" or so hole in the precise center of the headstock side, through the disc and into the stock that will become the left spindle. This hole needs to be small enough to serve as a guide for your drive spur. Then cut away the headstock side and set the center disc, which is done and ready for reassembly, aside.
The left-side piece is ready to mount, with the wide section to the headstock, and with a hole to align the center on the drive. The right side does not have a centering hole yet. I would reverse the right-side piece, put it in the chuck and drill a centered hole to match the ones in the center disc and the left-side piece.
Be sure to mark each piece so that the grain can be realigned later.
Do to here for all eight pieces.
--------------------------------
Now take each of the side pieces and turn the spindle between centers. That way you will be turning sixteen of the same thing, rather than eight each of mirror images, which is marginally easier. The small holes allow you to center each piece on the drive spur, and glue them all back together aligning the grain so that it is nearly invisible, and hold it all in place with a small dowel.
Of course there are lots of ways to do it, but I think this would minimize chatter and eliminate whip if you start at the small end of each piece and work back toward the headstock. Just be careful and don't put too much pressure with the tailstock (which increases the tendency to chatter and to whip).
Sounds like a fun project - be sure to post the outcome.
Can't say for sure but it looks like its only about 10 or 12 inches long. If you turn the center element first leaving the rest about an inch thick and turn elements about 2 inches on either side you shouldn't need to do anything else. Glue up some scraps a d try it first before you go to exotic measures
Being about 12 inches long and approx 3/8" minimum diameter I would agree with John L & others - a string steady won't help you any & any "enclosing" steady will actually get in the way over that length. I would be confident turning this without a steady.
Use 3 story sticks, 1 overall, and 1 ea of a LH & a RH story stick (this spindle looks symmetrical so only one req'd) & calipers. Mark out & create the main disk detail and scotia & do any "major" sanding now,. Then reduce the spindles to over size, at least 1/8" above max dia of the bead detail in the spindle, to help reduce whip. Mark both LH & RH detail on the oversize spindle & work evenly from center outwards on both sides. Complete the LH then the RH element and step out. Do not revisit the main disk once the spindles have been reduced to near final size.
Mounting between centers should not be an issue however a colett style chuck will give better access to detail on the head stock end & a little more support plus reduce vibration somewhat but not eliminate it.
You could use a traditional Vee block steady made from a "greasy" wood, or a modern two wheel steady mounted to the rear of the main disk element which is left very slightly oversize to to allow for removal of any bruises during final sanding. Sand lightly to prevent torqueing of the main disk which twists & shatters the fine spindle grain..
Nice exercise in skew & spindle gouge use. Practice on a bit of Monterey Pine or similar to iron out any bugs first.