Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

speed in turning

Posts

speed in turning

#1

speed in turning

Mike Potts

I've been trying to wrap my mind around turning speed. I think I've got it, but wanted to bounce off you guys. When we talk about speed RPM always comes up " What RPM should I turn at?" After thinking about it quite a bit, the true factor in my opinion would seem to be the INCHES PASTED A POINT. examples

1) turning a 2" piece on a spindle ramping and it up to 3000 RPM seems to be fairly common. in this case 2" x 3.14= 6.28 x 3000 RPM = 18,840 IPP

2) In the case of turning a 6" bowl to get fast enough so you won't have the tunk-a-tunk turning Lyle talks of is about 1000 RPM 6" X 3.14 X 1000 = 18,840

Ok I've been turning some bowls around 12" and been starting around that 1000 RPM, running the numbers out would be 37680 IPP, so it would seem that if my thinking is right that on a 12" bowl blank I could start at 500 RPM and still get the same IPP AS 1000 RPM on a 6" bowl. I haven't tried this yet as the thought just became clear to me.

Any thoughts or experiences from you guys

Thanks Mike

Re: speed in turning

#2

Re: speed in turning

robo hippy

Well, I never had a read out on any lathe I have owned, so I only have guesses, but with my big heavy duty lathe, I turn 12 inch bowls in the 2,000+ rpm range. This is safe for me, and always with good sound wood with no bark or knots or cracks. The proper answer is to turn at what ever speeds you are comfortable with. Add to that, turn at speeds so your lathe is not trying to walk across the floor. Any vibration in the spinning piece which causes vibration in the lathe will cause an out of round piece. I wouldn't want to stop and have to figure out which speed I should be using for each bowl. Turn your variable speed down to 0. Turn the lathe on at a low speed to see how true the piece is spinning. Then, while standing out of the line of fire, turn the speed up. I always round the blank out and true it up first, then turn the speed up again. I turn way faster than most people. Years of production work, and working on safe technique so I can avoid catches. I don't turn as fast as Jimmy Clewes though, that kind of speed makes my sphincters pucker (when sphincter tightening exceeds chuck tightening, you have a problem from Pat's Fan on Woodnet). Main problem is knowing when your sphincters should be puckering. You do not have to have high speeds to enjoy turning. Safety is the more important aspect, and comfort is highest concern here. As you get more comfortable, you can raise the speed if you want to. Most formulas are guide lines or suggestions.

robo hippy

robo hippy

Re: speed in turning

#3

Steven Antonucci

If the lathe is shaking, it is too fast

steven antonucci

Seriously, there are numerous guidelines that talk about speed to diameter ratios, but the read thing to worry about is mass. If you lose a pen blank at 3000rpm, it might sting bouncing off of your shoulder, but it probably won't kill you. A 15" bowl blank will.

Always ask yourself "how much will it hurt?" if something happens, and use that to make your own judgments. I cannot recall the last time I moved past 1400RPM?

Steve

Re: speed in turning

#4

Lathe Speed Article by Doc Green *LINK*

Doc Green

Here is a discussion of lathe speed that offers suggestions for RPM based on a guideline first put forth by Dale Nish (I think).

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/lathespeed.html

Click on the chart to see the suggested RPM for a piece of a given diameter.

The article also presents a smattering of rotational physics, and a way to visualize the energy contained in a rotating bowl blank.

Hope you find this interesting/useful.

~Doc


Doc's Website

Re: speed in turning

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Lathe Speed Article by Doc Green

Dick Hines

When you hear that little voice in your head " this could way to fast stupid!"

Take the advice.

Safety trumps speed every time.

Re: speed in turning

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: speed in turning

Mike Stafford

The right speed at which you turn something is the speed at which you are comfortable and safe. Just because I might turn something at a higher RPM than you doesn't mean it is safe for you to do so.

In the long run learning to make the cuts efficiently and accurately should be your goal and the speed at which you spin a piece of wood will be what is best for the way you cut. I constantly vary the speed at which I turn to suit the piece of wood and the cut I am making.

Speed kills and not just on the highway. :(

Re: speed in turning

#7

Re: speed in turning

Bill Howatt

When you have a freshly mounted piece always start slow, determine if it is wobbling or out of balance. As you clean up the piece you will then be able to bring the speed up to a level that you find comfortable. If that speed is not as high as somebody else's preference who cares. Be safe and comfortable.

The real hazard are the blanks that have bark inclusions and/or cracks. The danger turning blanks with these problems rapidly increases with rotational speed - the centrifugal force causes the blank to fly apart. Bark inclusions can be nasty because their extent may not be seen at first but as you turn away the supporting wood the piece quickly loses its strength and will "explode". This is the reason extra care needs to be taken when evaluating and turning a burl.

Most pieces that come loose from a chuck tend to fall down but they can bounce off the bed, pieces that explode send heavy chunks in any direction and there have been very serious and even fatal turning accidents from this due to head injuries.

The area in front of the rotating blank is the line of fire and you should develop your technique to keep out of this area as much as possible.

Bill

Re: speed in turning

#8

Re: speed in turning

Dennis Bilevich

Don't be in a hurry, stop and look at your turning offen , it only takes a second to stop and start again.I have turn bowls at 29" and not more than 600rpm. Stay safe.

Re: speed in turning

#9

Re: speed in turning

John lucas

I've never had a lathe that would read out the speed I simply use the speed that feels safe As my skill at turning and selecting wood has increased so have my speeds.

Re: speed in turning

#10

Thanks Guys

Mike Potts

As usual there are a variety of opinions, on this subject. I guess my lifetime of flat work, where you measure twice cut once, and there are certain way things are done leaves me a little lost on the way things seem to be done on the turning side of woodworking. My thoughts where, is there some way to nail down the correct speed to turn. I know there must be other newer turners that are in the same boat as me, clubs are to far to travel to. We learn on whats on the net or from videos we buy. Well Thanks again

Mike

Re: speed in turning

#11

Re: Thanks Guys

robo hippy

Measure twice and cut once??? I thought it was 'cut it 3 times and it is still too short'.

With wood, there never seems to be one 'correct' answer.

robo hippy

Re: speed in turning

#12

Re: Thanks Guys

Steve Worcester.

This is a question that comes up all the time in demos. The answer is really part of what Mike said, don't listen to the DVD or demo and turn at a speed you feel comfortable with.

Most of us aren't turning for money, so time isn't money. If you slow down the speed, slow down the feed (of the gouge), it works the same. High speed can cause big and catastrophic disasters. Surface feet per minute has some play in it, but safety is more important.

Just because turner X turns at speed X doesn't mean you have to. You may not have the same lathe fastened in the same place and definitely not with the same blank, and probably not at the same level of bravado.

Safety is a singular mindset and singular situation that isn't worth pushing.

Bad things happen when wood flus, worse things happens when wood flys at high speed.

Re: speed in turning

#13

Re: Thanks Guys

Steve Worcester.

This is a question that comes up all the time in demos. The answer is really part of what Mike said, don't listen to the DVD or demo and turn at a speed you feel comfortable with.

Most of us aren't turning for money, so time isn't money. If you slow down the speed, slow down the feed (of the gouge), it works the same. High speed can cause big and catastrophic disasters. Surface feet per minute has some play in it, but safety is more important.

Just because turner X turns at speed X doesn't mean you have to. You may not have the same lathe fastened in the same place and definitely not with the same blank, and probably not at the same level of bravado.

Safety is a singular mindset and singular situation that isn't worth pushing.

Bad things happen when wood flys, worse things happens when wood flys at high speed.