Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Broken ferrules on tools?

Posts

Broken ferrules on tools?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Broken ferrules on tools?

steven antonucci

I seem to recall a thread where someone brought up the topic, and yesterday, I think I encountered it?

While working at the Peters Valley Open House with my turning group, I had a "monster catch". It was so loud that the shop went dead quiet and everyone looked over at me with a look like "did that just happen?"

Then it happened again. I joked that it must have been the tools, since I had used all of the catches in mine up.

Little did I know that I was right?

After the second catch, I thought about it, and I couldn't figure out why I had gotten a catch until I looked at the tool. The ferrule had split along where it was dented into hold it in place, so the tool was actually twisting in the handle, hence my catches came from the tool rolling itself inside the handle to engage the wing.

I didn't look at every tool in the shop, but there were at least three like this. We have roughly 70 I will need to inspect.

Does anyone have any updates on what the vendor did to remedy this failure?

Steve

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#2

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

robo hippy

Hmm, not sure about the vendors, but I have one or two that are or have broken like that. When I make my own handles, I use 1/8 wall thickness brass pipe, and pound it on. My tool holes are usually sized pretty tight as well, most likely because the bit drifts a bit as I drill. I did have one manufactured tool spin loose on me, but it went back in pretty tight. The ferrules do work a bit loose in our dry summer here, as well as the manufactured ones. The tool you were using must have been really loose to rotate into the cut like that.

robo hippy

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#3

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

Dick Coers

I wouldn't expect the ferrule to keep the tool from rotating. Maybe a combination of things happened and the ferrule split, but I've had a spindle gouge that the ferrule split and fell off years ago. I continue to use it a lot, and no issues. Maybe the handle is also split?

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#4

Steven Antonucci

Split ferrule, maybe split handle...?

steven antonucci

I agree that the ferrule splitting shouldn't cause the tool to spin, and the handle may also be split underneath...but perhaps it is because the ferrule split in the first place? I don't know...

The ferrules were very thin, and in the ones that I looked at that were cracked, it was always in line with the punch/ crimp mark. Like Robo, I use copper tubing because it is cheap and easy. I usually undersize the tool hole and slightly oversize the tenon. A drop of CA glue isn't necessary, but I will sometimes add it.

I hold the tool with the tang up, and then drive the handle over the tang. Lastly, I loose my vise slightly, and then slide a ferrule up to the oversized tenon. It helps to taper the tenon at the edge to the right size. I then drive the handle down onto the ferrule. Even if the wood shrinks as it dries, it still holds.

I am just dubious about trying to re-ferrule roughly 70 tools... ugh.

Steve

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#5

Rob Wallace

I routinely use epoxy....

Rob Wallace

....when setting tools into new wooden handles with ferrules. I never have had a problem with wood shrinkage near the ferrule or tools coming loose over time. I also use brass tubing or copper pipe couplings as ferrules; these get tapped on with a thin film of epoxy underneath which both lubricates the installation over closely fitting tenons, and solidifies the wood-metal bond of the ferrule and tool shank.

Rob

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Has anyone ever seen a broken ferrule?

steven antonucci

Outside of this one vendor?

Commercial, big name catalog vendor...

Steve

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#7

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

Craig Daymon

I like using brass compression nuts, along with epoxy to set both the ferrule (very little needed) and to set the tool shank in the wooden handle. Especially good for 3-point tools as it gives you reference sides when sharpening.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#8

Re: Split ferrule, maybe split handle...?

Craig Daymon

Keep in mind that CA glue is brittle and the bond may be susceptible to shattering when given a good shock like the catch you described. This won't happen with epoxy.

There are some CAs that are suppose to be more flexible, which might be better for this purpose.

The first catch may have loosened it and the second may have been a result of it being loose.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#9

Steven Antonucci

The first catch it was already loose...

steven antonucci

I have no doubt that it was already broken when I picked it up. I just don't get catches like this one ...ever. I was turning the shoulder on a weed pot and the flute was rolled over and out of the way... the only way the wing got into the wood was if the tool turned in the handle...

I don't like epoxy for the exact reason you state. It holds too well, which means if I ever want to get the handle off, I am likely going to end up cutting it off. I like CA as it can be "shocked" into failing. I will grip the tool with a vise, and then use a mallet and a piece of wood to knock the handle off in one piece. I can throw it in a drawer, or give it to someone else without having to think too much about it.

That said, aside from these Packard ferrules, has anyone ever seen a broken ferrule?

Steve

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

Dick Hines

Except of a couple Thompson handles I make my handles out of 6016 Aluminum. Don't have any ferrule problems.

They weight more than wood but I like the feel of them better.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

Mike Stafford

I saw this happen on a number of Sorby tools a few years ago. I think their ferrule stock is so thin and brittle that it does not have the strength to hold up to the seasonal expansion of the wood and splits.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#12

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

robo hippy

Mine were from Craft Supplies, the Artisan brand which was their in house brand. Just way too thin for any real stress, and well, I stress my tools.

robo hippy

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#13

I started the thread on Cracked Ferrules

Geoff Whaling

Steve,

I was the one that started the thread on split ferrules on new tools that had not been used at all nor had very little use. I have 5 tools myself with cracked ferrules on tools that I set aside in a well ventilated tool storage area with many other tools after purchasing them from a business that was struggling.

Predominately they were from a few connected manufacturers who all appear to use the same supplier of ferrules perhaps even the handles. The "brass" in the ferrules exhibits a very granular structure through the crack line, certainly visible to the naked eye. The ferrules all cracked in the same place - through the triangular shaped punch mark. In the case of the large scrapers and bowl gouges the timber remaining around the tang of the tool between the ferrule is minimal, so little in my opinion as to be next to useless. I believe that is poor quality material, design and assembly that presents a potential hazard with a high probability of failure contributing to a serious "accident" / injury.

I guess if you make tens of thousands of tools & handles & recieve only a few complaints means you are travelling well. Unless we determine the extent of the problem nothing will change.

I sincerely hope no one gets injured using a tool with a cracked ferrule as you have in this instance. A loose/cracked ferrule or a sloppy/loose connection between the tool shaft/tang & tool handle certainly can produce a catch that contributes to a critical failure. Severe injuries are probable in such circumstances and unfortunately are often treated as “user error” or as a rare “accident” when critical analysis will show a series of factors contributed to the event/s that produced the injury.

I wrote to the manufacturers involved to express my concern about the matter to get the following response from one -

"Dear Geoff,

Thank you for bringing this to our attention, feedback is always appreciated.

Splitting of the ferrule can happen in the right set of circumstances. It is critical to the tool

and handle set up that the ferrule is very tight. Using a flexible adhesive on the ferrule wouldn't

work.

It’s usually damp conditions that result in the handle growing and splitting the ferrule. We control

the moisture content of the timber very closely and always turn and apply the ferrule at a set %. In

our 200 year history we have found this to be the best moisture content in order for the tools to be

ok in many environments in different country's.

Unfortunately it’s unavoidable that tools will be left in damp places from time to time and

splitting of the ferrule will happen. We do use the best quality brass for the ferrules but there is

no material that will stand up to the swelling of ash in damp conditions. We have some ferrules made from heavy gauge steel and we have had these split in the past.

If we were to make the ferrule less tight we would have an issue with them falling off in extremely

dry conditions (this happens from time to time)

We have around the same number falling off as we do splitting so we can only assume the best average.

This is a problem that has been around for 100s of years on all wooden handled tools. All xxxx

tools carry a life-time guarantee so anyone who has a split ferrule should contact us and we will

replace the handle free of charge. Please remember we produce tens of thousands of wooden handled tools and the percentage of tools that are reported with a split ferrule is extremely small."

This to me seems to be a cop out more or less saying its “user error” and started an exchange with the manufacturer not accepting it is poor material and design.

The tools steel & tool designs are good, no issue from me. Some of the ferrules & handles particularly supplied on handled large bowl gouges & scrapers are rubbish IMO and are very unsafe in typical use.

Do yourself a big favour - replace any cracked ferrules, repair loose handles & better still use or make yourself some heavy duty handles for tools like bowl gouges & scrapers that experience high stress loads.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#14

Steven Antonucci

Thanks... I recall it now

steven antonucci

You describe it perfectly. Right through the punch mark...

Both spindle gouges. Now I need to look at 9 lathes, each with 8 tools or so...

Going to be a busy Wed night.

S

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#15

Use copper yorkshire unions

Geoff Whaling

I prefer HD copper yorkshire union fittings. The copper seems to be more forgiving and appears to move in a complimentary manner with the timber in our seasonal moisture variations in the tropics. We don't get winter freezing like you guys though ;-)

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#16

Aluminum handles last winter.....

Dick Coers

were no fun at all. The cold soaked into my hands and didn't do my arthritis any favors at all. I much prefer wood.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: Aluminum handles last winter.....

Mike Stafford

Dick, I am in total agreement with you. I love my Thompson and Glaser tools with aluminum handles but not when it is cold. I go back to my wooden handled tools.

I have to wear gloves now to work in the shop even in cool weather and contacting metal surfaces in my unheated shop with an ungloved hand can be a very unpleasant experience.

I am so glad to see warm weather arriving.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#18

Bill Blasic

Re: Aluminum handles last winter.....

Bill Blasic

No one seems to remember that Doug Thompson made aluminum handles with foam covering and the same nose piece as the square aluminum. Yes they may roll but they are very comfortable on the coldest days and are among my favorites.

Bill

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#19

Re: Aluminum handles last winter.....

Mark Wollschlager

I think those were Dave Peebles handles.

Nice. Yes.

I put lacrosse stick cloth grip wrap on my aluminum handles in the winter.

Still have cold in them, but not as harsh.

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#20

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

phillip Medghalchi

Mike, mine did the same thing on the Sorby, but I never thought of anything until reading this article. I ahve to get the pic.s for you guys to see how thin they are. I wonder if they really saving money by using thin ferrules like that when they know that the tools are going to be under a lots of stress? Well, I think the thinking is that " I am not using the tool, so it don't matter, huh?"

Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#21

Bill Blasic

Re: Aluminum handles last winter.....

Bill Blasic

I have a few of Dave Peebles' handles and they are very different from the ones Doug made.


Re: Broken ferrules on tools?

#22

Re: Aluminum handles last winter.....

Mark Wollschlager

Interesting. Never saw those at a show or online. Just the 'new' style.

But Dave was selling his at Doug's booth for a while.