Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

Posts

Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#1

Brad Vietje

Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

Brad Vietje

Hi Folks,

I'm going out on a limb here -- pun intended -- to express my opinion. I'm not the Emperor of the Universe, so of course no one is required to agree with me, but I do hope everyone here at WoodCentral will at least stop and think about this important issue -- let your conscience be your own guide.

We should STOP shipping green wood blanks around the country and around the world.

I really love the idea of a wood exchange, paying it forward, trading my common woods for yours, sharing excess wood with those less fortunate, etc..., etc...

BUT

If we actually care about trees and forests, we should NEVER ship green wood anywhere.

The risk of spreading invasive pests and diseases is just too great. Here in Vermont, we are about to lose all our Ash species to Emerald Ash Borer, which has a nearly 100% mortality when it invades a region. That's about 7.5% of our forests that will be gone within 10-12 years due to a pretty iridescent little green beetle. Large areas of ,Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, New York, Ohio, Ontario, and Pennsylvania, have already seen the devastation caused by EAB. We already lost the American Chestnut to the chestnut blight, we are well on our way to losing the American Elm to Dutch Elm disease, and the Asian Long Horned Beetle is wreaking havoc in many areas of the Eastern US. These infestations -- both insect as well as fungal -- are all because infected wood was moved to a region where native trees had no immunity, or the pest had no natural predators.

EAB moves about 20 miles per year, if left to it's own devices, but it can travel 300 miles in a single day if someone hauls firewood to their vacation campground, or 3000 miles in a single day if shipped.


We know enough to know better. While I would dearly love to trade my Apple or Sugar Maple for your Mesquite or Persimmon, we really should only ship kiln dried wood, or wood that has been treated with either a fungicide, an insecticide, or both -- and quite frankly, I'm not too sure I want to handle wood treated with toxic stuff, either.

I know that only certain species are legally quarantined, but I suggest we stop shipping green wood, and only ship wood that is kiln dried, or treated in some way to kill invasive organisms. I know this can take all the fun and adventure out of exploring wood from other places, and as someone who mostly works with green wood, I'm not all that thrilled to be limited to dry dusty samples of the wood species you enjoy, but maybe that is the price we need to pay.

Like I say -- this is just one fella's opinion, and since I'm not the Emperor* no one is required to heed my warnings, but I do think we are asking for more and more trouble if we continue shipping green wood. None of us really knows what the next pest will be, or what species will be targeted next.

We can always introduce a new bug that eats the bad bugs, right? Well, sometimes that works, but history shows that when we mess around with Mother Nature, we sometimes end up demonstrating how much we don't understand, instead of how clever we are.

Thanks for reading my little rant -- let me know what you think.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

* If I was Emperor, I would change a LOT of things ;) !


Emerald Ash Borer Information -- USDA

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#2

Brad Vietje

Emerald Ash Borer Map *LINK*

Brad Vietje

I wanted to include this map, but the original was too large, so I had to shrink it a bit.

This is a map of sampling regions, and the density of detection traps, but it serves to show at a glance where E.A.B. has been detected, and where it is most likely spreading next. For full rez images, see the link in the original post.


This is bad news for Ash trees.

BTW: it kills all Ash species, not just one or two varieties. There is an insecticide that has been shown to be effective, but it is toxic to aquatic invertebrates in concentrations of 1-10 parts per billion, so treating the trees w/out killing the bugs (and thus affecting the fish downstream that feed on bugs, and everything that relies on eating fish, etc....) is a real issue. Maybe a better treatment will be developed? Who can say...?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


http://www.fs.fed.us/foresthealth/technology/invasives_agrilusplanipennis_riskmaps_2013.shtml

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#3

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Mark Wollschlager

No Bark. Air dried is the same as green.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#4

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

darrin hill

i tried to have this discussion in turning chat last year…

response was minimal… and no one seemed to care..

one guys response was 'as long as they're burning rain forests i think i can ship wood'..

d

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#5

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Nick

Along with what I think Mark wak trying to say, removing the bark cures the problem.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

not true

steven antonucci

If you've ever seen wormy ash, the bugs go way deeper than just the bark.

S

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#7

Emrerald Ash Borer

Mike Potts

I live in Ohio, we are totally infected. My personal experience is with an Ash that was taken down on my property because the power co. thought it was to close to their lines. This was in Sept 2012, I got 200 board ft from the trunk and this last winter turned about 20 bowls from the limbs. When turning I found no holes in the heart wood. There where some in the bark and the layer just below. now this may be because the tree was in early stage of infection. Unfortunately I'll be able to give you a better up-date later this summer. As I was going through my woods yesterday, every one of my 10 to 15 mature ash are infected, some in advanced stage, bark getting loose. Ok I,m a tree hugger, I love my trees, and it hurts to know in the next couple of years I have to take down more trees that I'll ever Turn, burn or use in flat work. So just be careful in what you get or ship.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Steve Kubien

I live 20 minutes east of Toronto and the town crews are taking down the ash trees due to the EAB.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#9

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

RCH

According to the city/county arborist in my town in central Kentucky, we have literally tens of thousands of ash trees. On many streets they are the street trees. EMB is very much in town and the region. All are expected to be be dead in the next few years. The Henry Clay estate is "Ashland". One of the supposed vectors for EMB being spread into Kentucky was campers carrying firewood with them from out of state -- from their dead trees.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Brad Vietje

As Steven and Mike suggest, there are so many interrelated issues.

- In my town of 56 square miles, there are probably about 10,000 - 12,000 Ash trees growing in the right-of way on either side of town roads, not even including the State and US highways. We are conducting roadside surveys through the Conservation Commission to assess the situation and get real numbers. At this point, it is assumed that they will all be dead within ~12 years, and a good many will fall onto or into the roadways if not managed.

- dead and dying trees falling into roadways creates multiple hazards, as well as clean-up and removal costs.

- It is easier -- and much safer -- to fell live trees than dead trees, so some towns are planning to drop them at the first signs of infestation, but everyone is trying to calculate what that will cost, how to spread out the cost, and who will do it -- town road crews, or tree services?

- Trees usually go through a 3-4 year decline from the first signs of infestation to a dead tree. Meanwhile, there are a few years when the bugs are munching the cambium and reproducing, while the tree gets weaker and weaker.

- If the trees are felled and processed before they start to decline, we could harvest the wood for its many uses. This could flood the market and depress the market price, which will go all to hell soon, anyway.

- I have suggested we cull sound trees in infected areas (before the trees die) and bring in woodworkers of all sorts to use the wood and create a market for Ash products to raise money to fund EAB research and awareness campaigns.

- Maybe some entrepreneur will store millions of board feet and leak it out to the market 25 years from now, when most of the Ash trees are long dead... Imaging what a huge stash of Am Chestnut would bring now, and what if someone had stashed away a huge supply of Am Elm?

- Peeling the bark off will help, but will NOT do the trick. The beetle larvae do spend ~18 months munching away between bark and wood, but they can also burrow into the sapwood. Even chipping the wood after debarking fails to control them unless the chips are small enough.

I don't pretend to have any real answers, but as woodworkers, I think we can all make smart choices as informed consumers, and I've already stated what I think that means.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#11

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Mark Wollschlager

Sorry, to brief of me.

No raw green wood, or air dried wood should be shipped with intact bark.

That is a primary location for bugs. Ash borer or others.

Likewise green or airdried wood with evidence of insects.

Kiln dried, ok. Finished work with natural edge, ok.

A big vector for transmission of insect and fungal pests is the movement of raw wood in the form of firewood. Nothing turning related about that.

Very similar to unwashed fishing boats transporting aquatic pests.

The spread of some of these pests seems inevitable, but can be slowed by folks taking a couple of minutes to think about their actions.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#12

EAB attack method

Dale Miner

I have seen ash with borer holes running throughout the wood, but those holes were not made by the EAB. The EAB kills the tree by tunneling in the cambium layer and essentialy 'girdling' the tree, preventing the flow of water and nutrients.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#13

Brad, I'm with you on this, so i want to suggest, *LINK*

Keith Newton

A few months ago, Ellis ides of whatever month was how to deal with insects.

I posted how I deal with insects in my wood, which is what the industry does. If you can heat the wood up to 133º F, all the way to the core, will kill all insects, as well as their eggs, which is where most poisons fail since they don't penetrate deeply enough, and are not effective when the eggs hatch, then go through their life cycles, to emerge later.

The method I wrote about was also good for finish drying of air dried lumber, and would not exactly work on big green turning blanks, due to the quick drying of the surface, while the deep moist core would still be wet.

However, it should be possible to heat a big wet chunk of green wood, wrapped or sealed in plastic, then allowed to cool without giving up the moisture in the process. There are oven bags for cooking turkeys in the oven that I'm pretty sure would work, and maybe someone could find a source for which other plastics would work too.

After writing the article, I did buy a digital thermometer for stabbing into the thickest part of the turkey, with a wire leading up to the LED outside the oven, tent, or insulated box. Since writing that, I have heated up a whole tree to 140º using this method, with that small heater blowing into the tarp/tent, but with 1" foam insulation on the sides as well as the top. The air was around 150º at that point, which was after about 3 days. The temp rises faster when evaporation slows.

I'm not sure how Ash would react to this much heat, then allowed to slowly cool while moist. It may blue-stain, and need to be cooled quickly, I don't know, but given the quantities that some of you are able to harvest, it may be worth experimenting with this.

Even though I've been using this method for some time now, I'm in the process of building a solar-kiln capable of drying about 1200 bf per month, although I really don't need that much capacity at this time.

Here is a link to the article. These heaters all come with a warning not to place it within 2' of anything which will burn, and I alway observe that caution. However, we started running low of propane at the cabin a little over a month ago. Since prices were at record high, and will likely drop next month, I chose to just use a couple of these space heaters. My golden retriever Sassafras likes to lay about 6" in front of it, and she has not burst into flame yet, although a couple of those long eye-brow whiskers took on a nice art-noveau curve toward the end. At least she didn't go poof, as she did in my troubled dreams. ha, It was a wasted effort to pull her away while scolding.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=newarticles&file=articles_946.shtml

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#14

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Mike Brazeau

Definitely a good suggestion Brad. Your post prompted me to contact our City of Hamilton, Ontario and then the Canadian Food Inspection Agency which handles the EAB situation in Canada. I have been driving by an enormous pile of Ash logs that someone is cutting up for firewood and selling on the side of this very busy road I travel frequently, Hwy 6 which goes from 403 north to 401. Turns out there is nothing to prevent movement of wood within the regulated area. That area is now all of Southern Ontario below a line from S.S.Marie to the Ottawa River and down to Ottawa and Eastern Counties of Ontario. It is incredible how quickly it moved from Michigan in 2002 to that area. Many of the cities in this area have up to 25% of urban trees as Ash and face huge forestry costs of dealing with boulevard and street side trees.

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks *LINK*

#15

Re: Shipping Green Turning Blanks

Haqrry Robinette

We now have the Walnut Tree's with Thousand Canker Disease that is killing the Black Walnut about as fast as the EAB.