Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

That One Tool

Posts

That One Tool

#1

That One Tool

Mike Potts

I'm fairly new to turning, but have been working with wood & my hands all my life. There are bowl, spindle, detail gouges,SRG, all kinds of scrapers, carbide tool, chucks,face plates, glue blocks......and on and on. Isn't there just one tool that you could use one every project that would make things easier, this all seems so confusing. Thanks for your comments

Re: That One Tool

#2

My candidate for the "almost universal"......

JamieDonaldson

..turning tool would be the 5/8" deep flute, side ground bowl gouge. I use it for probably 75% of my spindle and bowl work, not including the hollowing that I do.

Re: That One Tool

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Totally agree

Lyle Jamieson

The bowl gouge can do almost everything you might want to do. It should be the first one to master the techniques for. All the other tools on the tool rack are used for specialty purposes. They get used for a few minutes at a time, then go back to the bowl gouge. It can rough out, it can shape, it can be the finishing tool, it usually is used with bevel support, but it can also scrape and sheer scrape. I have a bunch of YouTube clips showing all four cuts with the bowl gouge. On the outside of a bowl my goal is to start sanding with 320 sandpaper. I don't even own 80 grit.

We all have purchased many tools that sit in a drawer or shelf collecting dust. Another tool is not going to make you a better turner. Invest some time in learning to use the tool already in your hand.

Re: That One Tool

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: That One Tool

Mike Stafford

I agree with Jamie about using a bowl gouge but I prefer a 3/8" deep flute bowl gouge. I learned on a tool of that size and it is still my favorite. I use the larger gouges but when it comes to finesse cuts I always reach for my old standby 3/8".

Re: That One Tool

#5

thompson 1/2" V bowl gouge

John Lucas

Take away all my tools but that one and i can do almost anything with the exception of some things a parting tool will do.

Re: That One Tool

#6

We should tell you 3/8 english is 1/2" american

John Lucas

I did a survey one time and by far the most common tool used was either a 3/8" english gouge or 1/2" american. The USA gouges are measured on the outside diameter of the tool and British are measured from the flute so a 3/8" English is virtially the same tool as the 1/2" American.

Re: That One Tool

#7

Re: We should tell you 3/8 english is 1/2" america

Dale Gillaspy

I agree with all of what has been said above, but your question is kind of like asking….Bandsaw, Table Saw, Scroll Saw, Mitre Saw, Coping Saw…isn't there one kind of saw that will do it all?

Re: That One Tool

#8

Steven Antonucci

i need two tools ...

Steven Antonucci

Same on the Thompson V bowl gouge, but I also need my Thompson 3/8" detail gouge. It is the tool that I lean on for beads and tenons. I probably could make a tenon with a bowl gouge, but the fine beads would be hard.

Steve

Re: That One Tool

#9

Bill Blasic

Re: i need two tools ...

Bill Blasic

Thompson 5/8 V, like Jamie I use it most of the time.

Re: That One Tool

#10

Great comments, but the answer IS...

Mike Potts

OK guys this was sort of a trick question, there is one tool that more versatile, and powerful. It can be use on any project, whether turning or flat work, it's called an open inquiring mind. As always there where some good and valid points made, which we can learn from. Right now I'm into bowl turning, and yes Lyle I've seen your U-tube, bought the bowl video, and have one of your Crown bowl gouges. It's the only tool I use start to finish on bowls. when I get back into Lidded boxes, offset candle sticks, goblets and I need to try one of John's Pendants ( wife likes to make jewelry) I'll grab my Thompson 1/2" spindle and 3/8" detail gouges. But what ever I'm doing using that powerful tool before, during and even after a project will make things go better, faster, and smoother. Keep you comments coming, us less experienced turners will keep trying to learn from them.

Turn Safe

Re: That One Tool

#11

Oh my god no   

John Lucas

Your not saying we should engage our brains before working. I prefer the Hey Bubba Watch this technique. :)

Re: That One Tool

#12

Don Leydens

Totally agree!


Re: That One Tool

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Oh my god no   

Mike Stafford

John, we usually say, "Hey bubba, hold my beer, watch this!"

Your technique could result in spilled beer. :b

Re: That One Tool

#14

Re: That One Tool

phillip Medghalchi

Mike,one thing they all forgot to tell you is patience. You are getting inspired by all that you see here or on the you tube and you want to do them all, which in reality you should ask how long these pros have been turning to get to these answers you just received. There is no short cut and there is always a price for every one to pay before they get recognized for their work. All of us have paid our dues one way or another and as we progress in our advancement we finally get to the point that we find somethings work for us or not and we go on honing our skills with that one or two tools based on what style of turning we develop. Lyle and every one here got very valid point, however, if you stop and study where they come form and what type of tools they honed their skills on they can tell you all kind of stories that they started out with carbon steel tools and some of today's tools were not even around when today's master turners started out. Like you don't want your surgeon cut you open with scalpel then heat up the same tool to cauterize you, do you? This is the same way. From what I have seen the answer to this qsn. over and over again is the bowl gouge and you have to master that to use it like Lyle and many others mentioned above.