I am a novice turner. I have a mini lathe and have started to turn some small blanks. I have noticed that the position of cutting surface of the chisel to the wood surfaces is very crucial. It sometimes seems that I have my tool rest too high because i having to point my chisel down. This seems to me to be incorrect. But I seem to have read that you don’t position the tool rest lower than the center of piece of wood.
Is it more important to have the chisel cutting surface above the center of the blank?
Cutting edge is usually about the center of the wood, the tool rest is then lower by at least the diameter of the tool. Lots of good videos on you tube by John Lucas, Reed Grey and others that show good cutting techniques. If you can get in touch with a local turning club for some hands on advice and instructions.
I like to cut just above center with bevel rubbing tools. With the skew I cut even further up. With scrapers I want to cut on the center line for spindles and above center for bowls. I adjust the tool rest height based on where on the wood I want to cut and where on my body I like the handle. I use my body to control the cut as much as I use my hands. So I position the tool where I want on the bowl and my body and then adjust the tool rest so it touches the tool.
Here is a link to one of my videos although from the angles I shoot from it's hard to tell much about tool rest height. there are quite a few more.
John, thank you. I will try your technique. I am sure that it will correct my chisel position and improve my cutting. I will watch your video. Thanks again. Steve
Dick, thanks. I was using a cutting style tool so my cutting edge was positioned wrong. Thanks for clarifying handle position for the scrapers. It is critical that the cutting edge be correct with wood surface that much I am learning. Steve
Most of the time, I have my tool rest around center. This allows me to angle the scrapers down, and the gouges more up, which is pretty standard. John has some good videos, and i have a few as well. There can be a lot of variation from one turner to the next.
Could you clarify your position on using scrapers on bowls? Did you mean that you use scrapers above center even on the outside of a bowl, or were you thinking of the inside of a bowl?
Steve: Referring to a simple, traditional scraper, I teach beginners these rules like they were carved in stone:
Outside of bowl: always below center -- never above
Inside of bowl: always above center -- never below
This is so a catch is pushed away from the wood, and into air, instead of burrowing in deeper and deeper, and creating a huge problem. Negative rake scrapers may be somewhat different (?), though I still use them as described above. BTW: a catch with a scraper is a pretty rare thing, but if the angle of the bevel and the curve of the spinning wood come too close together, a violent reaction can occur when the scraper digs in deep.
Maybe I'm wrong about this, but I learned these as absolutely fundamental rules of safety -- and I do mean rules, not suggestions. Perhaps I have a lot more to learn about scrapers (?), but that's how I was taught. I certainly don't mind hearing that I am wrong, or learning more from others, so feel free to correct any misunderstandings on my part; I just want to make sure a beginner doesn't get hurt when a bowl blows up.
No your right I wasn't clear. Inside is above center and outside below center. However that's for a flat scrape. For shear scraping I have the tool tilted at an angle and the handle is down so i"m always above center on those. I actually rarely use flat scraping any more. My cuts are usually clean enough off the bowl gouge that any lumps or bad areas can be cleaned up with shear scraping if necessary.
Thanks John -- I'm always thinking of how an absolute beginner would read our words and try things at home without the benefit of additional instruction. That's why the really good instructional videos like yours are so helpful. I only with we could find a way to separate the good stuff on the web from all the stupid and dangerous examples out there!
Sorry to come off so bossy! There are so many ways to do things that there is no one absolutely right way, but there are a few ways that might increase the risk of injury. I just want to make sure no one misunderstands and gets hurt.