Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

Posts

TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#1

TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

phillip Medghalchi

Hey Reed, I watched that video and earlier Steven started a thread emphasizing the importance of introducing the tool the right way will result in a much better finish. I watched your videos and I had a qsn. on this one. I own few of those gouges that you demoed with specially the large round nose and the outside and inside gouges and when i asked at the local club they told me that you use them flat on the tool rest and horizontal to the bed ways. I noticed that you use the bowl gouge way above the center line and then you use the scrapers much different ways. Could you please explain the exact position of the tool rest and why and how these tools are best used? I have been using he round flat scraper and the outside scrapers wrongly and I use them horizontally to the ground or the bed ways therefore wrong way, however, i have been gettiing lucky and my finishes have been coming up much smoother and I have been able to make it to sand lesser time or with higher grit sand paper. I try to post the picture of what tools I have so you can see what I have in my arsenal to use. I'd appreciate it if you could tell me where I can really learn the appropriate way of using the tools. I acquired soem my tools which I will put eh pic.s on here tomorrow for you by chance form my friends who their spouses passed away and so i got the tools, however, some are not HSS, but carbon steel I just own few HSS tools.

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#2

Steven Antonucci

Probably not one thing

steven antonucci

There are many ways to get to the same end point, but usually within those ways, only one or two ways to get there "right". Using a scraper flat will remove material. Using them in shear will result in a better cut. Using a bowl gouge will result in an even better cut. Using a bowl gouge in shear will result in the best cut.

Only if you are using them correctly.

If you are not, for the most part, you are probably scraping with whatever tool flat on the rest for all practical purposes. The one to use is the one that you can master most effectively. If you cannot ride a bevel with a bowl gouge, using it ineffectively will probably lower your results vs. traditional scraping.

Watch Glenn Lucas's videos on bowl gouges...

S

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#3

Re: Probably not one thing

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, well put. Like i said in your thread if you never watched it done correctly, I mean up close not on the you tube with camera being 10 feet away. I am talking the master being right there within a few feet away form you either watching you turn or use the tool and pinpoint your errors or you watch them very up close and from different angles and move around them to see how exactly they offer the tool to the wood and perhaps you try to mimic them and they hone your mistakes and try to lead you to better use of it. I mentioned it before that if you don't know what you are doing is wrong then you don't know what's wring to begin with.

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#4

Steven Antonucci

It is more than seeing it close up

steven antonucci

There are two things at play. One is knowledge. The other is practicing the application of that knowledge.

I often see people who have been turning for years, who think they are doing the right things and very good. I used to be that guy. I can often show them better ways, which is sometimes argued down, or other times accepted in the moment. For that brief second, they become enlightened. Leave them for 5 minutes, and they go right back to their old ways.

I had to force myself to break my old ways. It involved me taking a huge step backwards and relearning all of the things I knew that I had "learned wrong". trying to do something you cannot do can be frustrating, but when you understand it, you can move forward.

Once you understand it, you can practice it to get better before finally getting good. Knowing and doing are two very different things. I know how to dunk a basketball, but I cannot.

Seek knowledge first, and then try to learn how to use it. Robo's as good with a scraper as anyone I know. Glen Lucas is probably one of the best bowl turners in the world. Start there. Ask questions until it clicks.

Steve

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: Probably not one thing

Alan Zenreich

You mentioned

"Only if you are using them correctly. "

I'd suggest rephrasing it slightly,

"Only if you are using them effectively."

It's more in line with the sentiment in your next paragraph.

For example, although most people use flat carbide tools in a scraper orientation, the tools are just as readily used in shear cut, and other presentations (including bevel riding for some configurations).

So if the tool presentation gives the desired results, it's effective. It may not be the "correct" way in the eyes of another turner. I like taking religion/dogma out of practices that have as many varied techniques as woodturning.

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#6

Re: It is more than seeing it close up

phillip Medghalchi

Indeed, very well put. I am very much grateful for this forum. At least you can ask and you get some response to put you on the right track.

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#7

Re: Probably not one thing

phillip Medghalchi

I agree.

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#8

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

robo hippy

Well, the easiest way to answer this one would be to have you in the shop for a day or so. It is a question you could write a book about. I am still getting clips up of footage I shot for a video that I am going to just put up on You Tube. I had 8 hours worth of edited footage.

Most of the time, I have the tool rest at center height, +/- a little. In this clip, with the twice turned bowl, you do not have clear access to the bottom of the bowl, and still have to turn some off. This is why I drop the handle, roll the tool over on the side, and do what is called a shear scrape. It gets you into a narrow spot and allows you to cut. You can't rub the bevel in there, and this works, even if it is much slower than turning the outside to finish before you reverse the bowl to do the inside.

There are 2 basic cuts, a bevel rubbing cut shear cut, and a scraping cut. There is a hybrid cut called a 'shear scrape' which to me is not a scraping cut at all. So....

Shear (I first thought like wind shear where inside the thermal the wind goes up, and outside the wind is going down or the other direction), or Sheer (as in the sheer face of a cliff) as Lyle says, refers to the angle of the cutting edge to the wood as it spins. If your scraper is flat on the tool rest, the cutting edge is 90 degrees to the rotation this is a pure scrape. There is no shear at all in this cut. It is very coarse, except when turning end grain where it works very well. A higher shear angle makes for a cleaner cut. I compare it to driving over speed bumps in the parking lots. If you hit them square on (scraping cut) it can be a pretty big jolt/bump. If you hit it at a 45 degree angle, you get a much smaller bump. If you hit it at a 70 degree angle, it smooths out still more. So what this means is that the higher the shear angle, the more gently the cutting edge slips in under the wood fibers and lifts them off.

Scraping cuts can be done with scrapers and gouges. This is all about how the cutting edge enters the wood. At 90 degrees, a pure scrape. With a gouge, you hold the handle level, roll the flutes over on the side (3 or 9 o'clock) and cut (safety note here, if you hold the handle/tool level, roll the tool all the way over before putting it into the wood. If you roll it over rubbing the bevel, then roll it over more till it cuts, the point where you come off the bevel, there is no tool support and it will dig in very quickly). You do not rub the bevel, and these cuts are best for heavy stock removal. A scraping cut is a cut, I can get nice long ribbons of shavings when doing this, but it does leave a rather coarse surface.

Bevel rubbing cuts are probably the best finish cuts, and can be used for roughing, but I don't find them to be nearly as efficient as a scraper. With the curved shape of the flutes, there are a lot of different ways to rub the bevel. Most of the time I hold my gouges more level, and roll the flutes over at least 45 degrees away from the cut. The nose is doing a nice 45 or so degree shear cut, and the wing is doing more of a scraping cut. You can increase the shear angle some by dropping the handle. This also makes the wing do more of a shear cut. This is some times done with the bevel on the wing rubbing. If you drop and roll enough, the wing can get in a 60 degree or so angle shear cut. With the fluteless gouge, you can easily roll to 70 or 80 degrees. Most of the time this works better for very soft or very stringy woods, while the standard 45 degree shear angle works for most other normal woods. This is generally a final cut. If you leave the flutes pointing straight up, there is a tendency to catch or try to cut with the inside wing (one closest to the wood you are cutting) and the tool will roll over into the wood/catch.

The shear scrape is a hybrid cut. This is generally used to clean up tool marks and all those little bumps and humps for when your other tools are not working like they should. Again, this is a high angle shear cut, but you don't rub the bevel. With a gouge, you drop the handle, and roll the flutes over, do not rub the bevel. Some times this almost has your flutes upside down. It is a clean up cut only, and not for heavy stock removal. It will take several passes to even things out. I prefer a swept back scraper for this. Same idea, burr on the edge, drop the handle, and no bevel rub. Multiple passes for clean up. The advantage over a gouge in this case is that you can see the edge as it cuts where with a gouge, it is rolled over to the point where the view is obscured. On the inside of the bowl, you can do the same thing, but I prefer a scraper with a ) shape nose or very little sweep. Drop the handle (this has the added benefit here of making it impossible to cut with the high side of the cutting edge and getting a catch), and gentle pull cuts up towards the rim using only the lower part of the tool. Great for blending in the stop/start marks the gouge leaves. This cut is mostly used for little clean up things that you could sand out, but who wants to sand when you can cut it out. I also find this cut handy if I want a perfectly round bowl, as it will take out that tiny +/- 32nd of an inch or so of bounce that you always get. Not critical unless you are making a bowl less than 1/8 inch thick.

Now, the finished surface, bevel cut or shear scrape? Of course, it depends on a lot of things. One point Jimmy Clewes makes is that he doesn't really like a bevel rubbed finish. His explanation bought back memories of doing flat work where you never took it beyond 220 grit before finishing. The reason was the higher grits would actually burnish the surface, and the finish wouldn't penetrate or adhere because the surface needs a bit of coarseness. Jimmy said he likes a shear scraped finish because a bevel rubbed finish, because it is burnished, requires you to sand through the burnishing before the abrasives really start to cut. Well, for sure this is true with some of those little lines you see from when you are rubbing too hard, or stop/start a cut. The thing is that a bevel rubbing cut usually leaves the cleanest/least amount of tear out surface when compared to other cuts. Some times a shear scrape, no matter which version you use will rough things up rather than smooth them out. Most of the time this involves really punky wood or some that tend to be really stringy. Some times the shear scrape really is an advantage. It depends on the wood. Well, a sharp tool as well.

Oh yea, I have a brother in law who is a 'Grey'. We tease him unmercifully at family functions. I am a Gray. No offence at all.

robo hippy

Re: TWICE TURNED BOWL By Reed Grey

#9

Steven Antonucci

Optimally?

steven antonucci

Correctly? Effectively? Optimally?

There are shades of religion and "correctness". Could I drive a screw with a hammer? If it went into the wood, is that "effective?"

There is a line between using something wrong, using it properly, and using it well. Take your beloved carbide scrapers, for instance. Almost anyone can step up to the lathe and remove wood with one. Used "correctly", they may even produce a passable result. Used "well", the result could be as good as any scraper in an expert hand.

The broader issue here is that Philip asked about tools, and unfortunately, that's not the right question. Any tool can only produce a result that echoes the capability of the hands it was in. Each tool, each edge has the potential to produce a "best output", and the work limit equation where the turner tries to approach the limit of the edge.

We humans are subtractive from tooling, which is why we let machines make most of the things we use today. Generally speaking, a machine doesn't make mistakes. That's why everything got automated. If people worked better than machines, we'd still be using them. Craftspeople try to capture that level of perfection without being perfect themselves.

We can play the semantics game all day, but in the end, the biggest upgrade you can make to your tooling is your hands. There are no short cuts or carbide finger tips that will make you better with the scraper/gouge/hook/carbide in your hand other than putting edge to wood, but doing it the same sub-optimal way 1000 times will produce the same sub-optimal result 1000 times.

If one turner looks at his surface with a bowl gouge and compares it to another turner's bowl, and the first turner has torn end grain, it is time to admit to yourself that you are doing something "ineffectively/wrong". The first step is admitting you have a problem...

Or, sand your way to glory...

S