Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Two more Questions,Please

Posts

Two more Questions,Please

#1

Two more Questions,Please

Mike Potts

OK I rescued the box elder from a campground I belong to up on Lake Erie, would have been used for fires this summer. In the same area I picked up 10 more Maple blanks that where smaller (10" to 11" bowls) I assumed they where from the same tree just higher up on the trunk. I've turned a couple and they do look look like the ambrosia maple on-line. see photo, do I have both maple and box elder?

Question #2

I'm trying to make the bowls food safe. What I have been doing so far is to put a heavy coat of mineral oil on bowl the wait 24 hrs and put second coat, then another coat after 24 hrs. finally finish with a mixture of white bees wax and mineral oil ( Mama wasn't happy when I used here blender to make it). Opinions or suggestions.

Re: Two more Questions,Please

#2

Rob Wallace

Re: Two more Questions,Please

Rob Wallace

Hello again Mike!

Question 1. The sample you show does look like Ambrosia maple, complete with larvae holes and the invading dark fungal streaks typical of ambrosia maple. BTW - Ambrosia maple is not a species, per se; it really is a condition found in several species of maple, depending on which part of the range the maple comes from. Once the Ambrosia beetle larvae chews it way through the wood, the fungus it disperses as it burrows then grows into the wood to generate the characteristic darkened streaks. Without evaluating several microscopic characters as seen in the end grain to determine which actual species of maple it is, I think it would be acceptable to call it "Ambrosia maple".

Question 2. Use of mineral oil as a food safe finish in/on the wood is sometimes recommended, but you need to be aware that mineral oil never polymerizes or "cures" in the 'drying' sense, so bowls saturated in mineral oil tend to be a bit "leaky" and occasionally deposit oil rings on the surfaces upon which they sit. Even if you use a wax mixture on the surface, the mineral oil will never really become solid, and has the potential to leak out, sometimes at inopportune moments. In contrast, the "drying" oils such as linseed, tung, and walnut oils will combine with oxygen and form polymers and cross-links between molecules, effectively binding them in the wood; they will "dry" and not leak out once fully "cured". Producers of utilitarian "user" bowls often will oil-finish their bowls with a drying oil - a commercial example of this is [Mike] Mahoney's oil finish, a food-safe, walnut-oil based product, which will dry and polymerize over time when in contact with the air [oxygen is needed for the molecular cross-links between the fatty acids of the oil to form]. My own recommendation is to finish your 'user' bowls with a drying oil finish, and avoid the use of mineral oil altogether (BTW - "vegetable" oils can oxidize and go rancid fairly quickly, and these also should be avoided). If you want a glossier shine or higher luster, you can use carnauba wax on the surface which is much harder and more durable than a beeswax finish. Carnauba wax is fully food safe (it is used to coat medicines, is found in lipstick, and in other food coatings such as candies and other confections).

I hoped this helps!

Rob Wallace

Re: Two more Questions,Please

#3

Re: Two more Questions,Please

Dale Gillaspy

It looks to me like BE and Maple, but I'm not a wood id expert. As far as food safe stuff goes, ask 100 people and you'll get 100 different answers. Any finish is "food safe" as long as it is fully cured. It comes down to a matter of preference. What you did will work just fine. I prefer Mahoney's Walnut Oil to Mineral Oil just because Mineral Oil is a petroleum product, but that is just personal preference.

Re: Two more Questions,Please

#4

Re: Two more Questions,Please

TomB

Boxelder is a maple, so your two examples could be from the same tree. As mentioned, the steaks are from the beetle. Other names for Boxelder are Manitoba maple and Ash Leaved Maple

Re: Two more Questions,Please

#5

absolutely 2 different trees


Re: Two more Questions,Please

#6

Re: Two more Questions,Please

John Cotten

Looking the bowls in the rear of the photo, Box Elder, nice red patterns to them, the bowl in front looks like a soft maple species. As far as a food safe finish be careful using nut based oils on food bowls. Walnut oil, peanut oil, and even hazelnut oil will all work, but if you run into someone with a nut based food allergy, the results can be bad. I have a friend whose daughter has a nut allergy, a salad out a walnut finished bowl landed her in the ER with a reaction that caused her throat to swell shut and her mouth to become enflamed. The doctor said it was a rare occurrence, but possible. I quit using walnut oil on my stuff shortly afterwards. There are some food grade finishes available, salad bowl finish being one of them. Most of the popular woodworking stores or turning catalogs carry a line of them. Mineral oil has long been my fallback food finish, but there are some better out there.

Re: Two more Questions,Please

#7

Re: Two more Questions,Please

John Cotten

Looking the bowls in the rear of the photo, Box Elder, nice red patterns to them, the bowl in front looks like another soft maple species. As far as a food safe finish be careful using nut based oils on food bowls. Walnut oil, peanut oil, and even hazelnut oil will all work, but if you run into someone with a nut based food allergy, the results can be bad. I have a friend whose daughter has a nut allergy, a salad out a walnut finished bowl landed her in the ER with a reaction that caused her throat to swell shut and her mouth to become enflamed. The doctor said it was a rare occurrence, but possible. I quit using walnut oil on my stuff shortly afterwards. There are some food grade finishes available, salad bowl finish being one of them. Most of the popular woodworking stores or turning catalogs carry a line of them. Mineral oil has long been my fallback food finish, but there are some better out there.

Re: Two more Questions,Please

#8

Bill Blasic

Re: Two more Questions,Please

Bill Blasic

I use Mahoney's Walnut Oil. This is stated about his product:

My walnut oil is 100% high linoleic acid walnut oil developed for woodworkers who want a non-toxic alternative to petroleum based polymerizing oils. What makes the oil unique is its ability to dry. I source my oil from trees in Northern California which are naturally high in two key fatty acids that help the oil polymerize. This is absent in culinary walnut oils. I also heat-treat the oil to remove the proteins that may cause allergic reactions to those predisposed to them.

Bill