It is hard to explain how important the bevel is?
steven antonucci
I see guys who have been turning a very long time still not find the bevel. Unless you figure out the bevel, turning will always be "hard". YouTube is tough because 80% of the videos show you how to do it wrong, and anyone learning from them is learning the wrong way to do it.
Also, people sometimes attribute "good turning skills" with recognized names. I know several well known turners that produce fine work, but frankly, aren't very good turners. You could argue that there are many ways to get to the same result, yada yada yada, but when you see them cutting in the wrong direction for no good reason, or the torn grain that they sand away (for hours)...you have to wonder.
None of this has anything to do with the shape of the tool, what kind of steel, or whose signature gouge it is... the bevel is the bevel on any tool that cuts, and is first learned visually, and then from feel. I always start by teaching to be on the heel of the gouge, and then by slowly raising the handle, engaging the bevel. You know when you are on bevel when you start to see the edge cut. Stop lifting the handle, and hold that angle. Most people are not coordinated enough to put all of the motions together, so they need to learn them like dance steps, and then put the steps together.
Once you learn to engage the bevel, you will notice the feedback in the tool handle. I have shown cutting the inside of a bowl with one hand and just two or three fingers on the end of the handle. It becomes that automatic.
If you look at your work and see torn end grain, it means that you were not on bevel. The bevel prevents fibers from being lifted out by just not allowing them to move "up". Think of it like a temporary clamp behind the edge. If the wood cannot lift, it will not get pulled or cut below the surface.
Practice makes perfect, but only if it is perfect practice. Practicing the wrong thing for any length of time will make you proficient at doing something wrong. Finally, the thought that any one thing is the answer is also probably a bit misleading. I wasn't advocating for dull tools. I was suggesting that proper presentation was the fastest way to start seeing improvement. Better than sharper tools. Better than better steel. Better than a new grind. None of those things matter if you stick the tool into the wood wrong.
Steve