Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

On cutting and getting a good surface...

Posts

On cutting and getting a good surface...

#1

Steven Antonucci

On cutting and getting a good surface...

steven antonucci

I am fully convinced that presenting the tool to the wood properly is far more important than how sharp the tool is?

Yes, a sharp tool is good and important and all of that stuff... but I don't think it means squat if you jam it into the wood wrong. A sharp edge presented wrong not only doesn't cut well, but it beats that edge to pieces.

Anyone?

S

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#2

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

Mike Potts

Steven, there isn't just one thing that makes a smooth cut. In my opinion you need to present a sharp tool with a slicing cut (45 degree), with bevel support, at as high of speed as you feel comfortable paying attention to grain orientation. do all those thing and you will have a smooth surface.

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#3

Steven Antonucci

Try testing that...

steven antonucci

Simple parameters. Make a cut with a sharp tool, etc... good surface.

Then, take the tool off bevel. Not so good any more.

Then put it back on bevel, but not at 45...still a good surface? maybe not as good as first test, but still good?

Lastly, once the tool is good and dull (not intentionally damaged, but no longer sharp), take another cut.

Repeat it with a dull scraper or a dull skew...

I am not arguing for dull tools or odd angles to cut, merely that the single most important factor to a good surface is putting the tool on the wood the right way. If you do that correctly, everything else works out.

I'm betting that 80-90% of the result is determined my it. You may need to cut slower because of a dull tool, but as long as you don't mash it, it will still cut.

Steve

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#4

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

robo hippy

Steve,

To me there are 3 very important things, and you need all 3, which means they are equally important.

One, the tool has to be sharp. We can disagree about how sharp, but if it isn't sharp, it doesn't make any difference what you do with it, you can not get a clean cut.

Two is presenting the tool to the wood. This is about how to stick a sharp tool into spinning wood without getting catches, having things come off the lathe, and getting little tear out. Bevel rubbing or not bevel rubbing, scraper, gouge, shear angle, scraping cut all work, and at one time or another, any one can cut more cleanly than the others.

Three is moving with the tool so you get a smooth surface, which means no tool marks, and no bumps and humps that you have to take the 80 or coarser grit gouge to so they disappear.

robo hippy

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#5

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

John Lucas

Angle of cut is not as critical as you might think. You do need some angle and on some woods it does make quite a difference. I do this as part of my demo with the skew. It is very sharp of course and a peeling cut is always courser than and angle cut, However going from less than 45 degrees to really steep angle of 75 or so doesn't show much difference in cut. Same is true with my 1" spindle gouge.

Sharpness however makes a huge difference as I can tell when I take a skew straight off the 180 grit wheel and then hone it. The curls coming off tell the story and both angles are the same.

I won't even go into non bevel rubbing although a negative rake scraper with a good burr will cut awfully clean.

The speed the tool passes through the wood is right there with cutting angle in importance if not more. If you force a tool through the wood even if it's sharp and at the correct angle you will get tearout.

So I agree with what was said above. All 3 need to work together to get a good cut, especially on problem wood. Take away any one of the 3 and you get a lesser quality cut.

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#6

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

phillip Medghalchi

Steven, your argument is all good, however, how many times you bought a turning tool that comes with an instruction to tell you how and what angle to put the cutting edge to the wood at or with? Almost all of the turning tool makers sell their tools thinking that you already know how to use it, or hoping that someone will do the favor of showing you how it's done.If I am wrong please direct me to one of those tool makers, Please. Then they also go to the bat bad mouthing other guys toll that it won't do this or that. So, if you didn't have an official class training you, then you pretty much are screwed. Now, at present time you get enough scary people who put videos on the you tube about turning. Fortunately for them you tube doesn't have any liability as for the contents of the materials you put on their channel. I am sure you have seen what I mean on the you tube. Some of them go as far as sounding like they are experts and the tell you or show you things that makes you wonder where the heck they come from. On the other hands, if you think back in the 80's and 90's the internet was not as popular as it is today. So, if anyone ventured into the world of turning then they must have had some sort of formal training by somebody. So, they may identify with what you are saying. However, in to days market I am sure that there are very many of turners who do not know what the actual angle or how certain tools are supposed to be used. Also, many photographers have no slight idea as what angle to shoot the demo from yet alone knowing what is important to shoot. On the flip side of it is that many turners are self photographers and so, they put the camera on one angle and then they shoot. All the while not even knowing what they are shooting and if what they meant to show is actually showing in the videos, or was it close enough to show the intentions of what they are trying to demo.

You argument is very valid, but if the person doesn't have any guidance as how to use the tool properly then this argument doesn't make any sense to them. Since they have nothing to compare the right result with. If you don't know what you are doing is wrong, then you don't know you are doing it wrong anyways.

Even though that I have been blessed to have very nice fiends locally and being surrounded by some master turners who help me out unselfishly, i still struggle with good and proper use of tools since i have not been able to stand side by side while they are working and watch them at work or pay attention how they introduce the toll to the wood and even though our chapters have over head cameras and large screens we still do not have some one video savvy to shoot at the right angle and close up. so, my teaching were all by watching what I can and try to emulate what I heard all on my own and then those friends telling me that my surfaces need improvements or not. Most of my learning has been completely on my own and still have a lot to learn about surface preparation, so I don't have to sand as much. Although I have had my share of weird woods and hard ones that are teaching me a lot how to deal with them. Most importatnly, haveinng a chance to learn form here WC has meant a lot to me too.

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#7

I'm working on a bowl gouge video

John Lucas

I don't claim to be an expert and this is a very versatile tool with lots of different ways to use it. Consequently the planning stage is taking a while (that I have to do to many demos and other engagements that are eating up my time). Anyway I hope to get on it in May or June.

I also want to do a short video showing exactly what Steve is talking about and that is cutting edge angle. For skews and spindle gouges it's fairly straight forward but when it gets to bowl gouges and how we use them it's much more complicated. At least for some cuts.

Anyway, keep watching. I have several videos planned just have to find time to do them.

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#8

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

phillip Medghalchi

John, thank you. I am sure you already felt it here. You have been one of those guys that most contribute to this forum and give and share your knowledge unselfishly. I appreciate it that you talk to me and give me tips on the phone too. I am sure there are many others that feel same way because of your contribution. hopefully this time I can catch you before the show starts at SWAT (I am hoping that you are coming) and chat with you again. I hope to see more of the fine folks here coming to SWAT this year and I get chance to really visit with with them one on one.

Thanks again to every one taking time to answer and share their knowledge here on this forum. :) :)

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#9

Steven Antonucci

It is hard to explain how important the bevel is?

steven antonucci

I see guys who have been turning a very long time still not find the bevel. Unless you figure out the bevel, turning will always be "hard". YouTube is tough because 80% of the videos show you how to do it wrong, and anyone learning from them is learning the wrong way to do it.

Also, people sometimes attribute "good turning skills" with recognized names. I know several well known turners that produce fine work, but frankly, aren't very good turners. You could argue that there are many ways to get to the same result, yada yada yada, but when you see them cutting in the wrong direction for no good reason, or the torn grain that they sand away (for hours)...you have to wonder.

None of this has anything to do with the shape of the tool, what kind of steel, or whose signature gouge it is... the bevel is the bevel on any tool that cuts, and is first learned visually, and then from feel. I always start by teaching to be on the heel of the gouge, and then by slowly raising the handle, engaging the bevel. You know when you are on bevel when you start to see the edge cut. Stop lifting the handle, and hold that angle. Most people are not coordinated enough to put all of the motions together, so they need to learn them like dance steps, and then put the steps together.

Once you learn to engage the bevel, you will notice the feedback in the tool handle. I have shown cutting the inside of a bowl with one hand and just two or three fingers on the end of the handle. It becomes that automatic.

If you look at your work and see torn end grain, it means that you were not on bevel. The bevel prevents fibers from being lifted out by just not allowing them to move "up". Think of it like a temporary clamp behind the edge. If the wood cannot lift, it will not get pulled or cut below the surface.

Practice makes perfect, but only if it is perfect practice. Practicing the wrong thing for any length of time will make you proficient at doing something wrong. Finally, the thought that any one thing is the answer is also probably a bit misleading. I wasn't advocating for dull tools. I was suggesting that proper presentation was the fastest way to start seeing improvement. Better than sharper tools. Better than better steel. Better than a new grind. None of those things matter if you stick the tool into the wood wrong.

Steve

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#10

Doc Green's Articles on Gouges

Doc Green

I have, on my website, a series of seven articles that attempt to explain how gouges cut and the many ways to use a bowl gouge, for example. These articles are intended for new turners. Many photos show the details of rubbing the bevel and where and how the actual cutting of the wood fibers occurs.

Here's the link to the articles index:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/articles.html

The discussion of a bowl gouge begins with the third article.

Fun, fun, fun! ~Doc

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#11

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

robo hippy

"The bevel should rub the wood, but the wood should not know it." Unknown

"Hold the sword as you would a bird. Too tight and you kill it. Too loose and it flies away." From a movie about Cyrano DeBergac. I even heard it used on Roy Underhill's show.

robo hippy

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: It is hard to explain how important the bevel

Brad Vietje

I saw a YouTube video just last night that showed a very nice close-up of a freshly-sharpened gouge being used entirely wrong. The camera angle very clearly showed the 25-30 degree air space between the bevel and the wood!

I wish I could recall the video -- would be a great example of "how not to".

Maybe someone with good video editing skills could cull YouTube for all the great examples of how not to turn wood, but I'm not sure you could post it anywhere :\ Too bad -- LOTS of great examples of terrible turning out there.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Doc Green's Articles on Gouges

Mike Stafford

I try not to rub the bevel so that doing so results in a bruise. I was taught to glide on the bevel making only the lightest contact. I grind off the heel of most of my gouges to shorten the bevel to make "gliding" easier.

I am sure most folks are referring to the same thing when they say "ride".

Re: On cutting and getting a good surface...

#14

Steven Antonucci

I'm stealing this.