Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

grinder choice

Posts

grinder choice

#1

grinder choice

John Lucas

OK these are just my thoughts on the subject based on 35 years of grinding and sharpening. I think we sometimes scare off new turners by telling them they need a fancy grinder with really expensive wheels, in some cased probably more expensive than the lathe they bought.

I sharpened for years on a very old Craftsman 3450 1/2hp grinder with gray wheels. Granted it wasn't perfect but I did a lot of turning and turned out some good projects.

I think what is important is a grinder that spins true and balancing and trueing up the wheels so everything runs smooth. It doesn't have to be expensive. I can buy a Harbour Frieght $39 grinder and put some inexpensive white wheels on it from Enco and have a good grinder. Maybe $50 to $60 invested. Speed of the grinder isn't important and your only going to be removing light passes on the metal so even a 1/2 horse is enough.

With a good tool rest and/or some good sharpening jigs added you can do a very good job of sharpening lathe tools.

Now I certainly won't argue that a Baldor 1725rpm grinder with a CBN wheel would be a better choice. Probably run you about $500 or more. Obviously the better grinder and better wheels you can afford the easier sharpening will be.

I think most people will say that the slow speed grinders sold by Woodcraft with a set of white wheels would make a very good investment for new turners. You do need to check to see if it runs smooth and then take some time to balance the wheels and make them run true. After that you have a good machine and is the one I have used for the last 12 years although I did add the CBN wheel recently.

Anyway those are my thoughts and probably worth the 2cents you get when you ask me a question. :) A nickles worth now that's a whole new ball game.

Re: grinder choice

#2

other choices

John Lucas

Over the years because I have been on a very extreme budget at times I've sharpened using a lot of other less expensive options. I started turning using a 12" disc sander on the outboard side of my Shopsmith and free hand ground all of my tools with no tool rest. Not optimal of course but does a surprisingly good job. You can move into the center to sharpen high carbon steel tools because the surface speed is so much slower, then move out to the edge for your high speed steel tools. The paper last fairly long. If you can buy the blue ceramic coated paper it lasts a very long time.

I went from that to a 3" belt sander turned on it's back. This works really well but take the cloth dust collector bag off. Mine now has tiny pin holes in it from the sparks. Again the blue belts are far superior.

I now use a 1" belt sander with a 1725 rpm motor and run the belt in reverse so it runs uphill. I can change out grits in seconds. I use the 320 belt mostly and man does it sharpen a tool well. It it aggressive so you need a light touch our you'll grind away your tools. Because I bought a used motor at a yard sale I have about $100 in this set up. I modified the tool rest and rigged up a way to use my wolverine jig on it. I can put a course belt on for shaping or an ultra fine belt for carving tools. I can even put a leather strop on it for maintaining carving tools. YOu can't get the blue belts in finer grits so the 320 on up belts wear out fairly fast , but they only cost $3 each.

Re: grinder choice

#3

Wet wheel options

John Lucas

For turning I'm just not a fan of these however if I only used it for turning it might be a different thing. The wheels groove fairly easily and I use mine for sharpening plane blades, planer and jointer blades and hand plane blades and have to true them up and waste away the wheel if I groove them with turning tools.

They do put a fine edge on a tool. The water was necessary for carving chisels and plane blades that are often high carbon steel. with HSS keeping the blade cools isn't necessary although you still need water for these stones.

I've owned a Delta, Makita, Sheppac and now the Tormek. The Tormek is without a doubt the best although I really liked the makita for planer blades.

There have been some pretty good arguments about a sharper edge holding an edge longer including one fairly scientific study. Glen Lucas who is a production bowl turner indorses the Tormek so you would think there is something to this. I'll keep playing with mine as I have the time and may update my opinion in the future.

These are expensive and kind of defeat the premise of the first post which is keeping the cost down for new turners.

Re: grinder choice

#4

Re: grinder choice

Bill Howatt

Thanks for the great, practical overview of your experience with the gamut of sharpening options which many new turners find confusing.

I get annoyed reading that you can't sharpen a turning tool with a gray wheel; it may not be the best but it will sharpen. In fact, I have a Norton blue on my 8" slow-speed grinder along with a gray. Blue for the gouges, gray for the scrapers and bulk grinding. I have used white wheels from LV but they are too soft and groove too quickly compared to the Norton blue. This brings me to one of the problems with the grays, they don't groove easily and therefore are prone to be used far too long without a dressing to create a new, sharp surface.

Bill

Re: grinder choice

#5

Joe Fleming

Re: grinder choice

Joe Fleming

When I teach about grinding, I encourage people to get a full speed grinder that runs true. Get the Oneway balancing system if you need to. I teach full speed because if you learn on the "most aggressive" (fastest) set-up, you can take your tools anywhere and sharpen them. Our club does demonstrations and we have a full-speed grinder with crappy tool rests. Not a problem for me to touch up my edges. And if you demonstrate, you will be the most portable.

Re: grinder choice

#6

Re: grinder choice

Bill Howatt

Even though I have a 1725RPM slow grinder, I don't think it is a necessity, what is a necessity is as you indicated is to learn to have a proper light touch.

On their website some years ago, Oneway used to recommend the 3450RPM grinder but that recommendation is no longer present. One theory is that they were talking to pros and now there are more amateurs????

Bill

Re: grinder choice

#7

Brad Vietje

I Agree 100% -- Thanks John


Re: grinder choice

#8

Harry Robinette

Re: I Agree 100% -- Thanks John

Harry Robinette

I agree also .To me everyone should learn on a 3450 rpm then when they go to a 1725 rpm. It really makes a huge difference on the learning curve. The actual movement of Sharpening and NOT Grinding is very easy to make if you ever used a 3450 that takes a VERY light touch.

Re: grinder choice

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: And now for a little diverging opinion....

Jesper, Denmark

My tool buying philosophy is this: Buy the very best you can afford to begin with. It may be expensive to start, but it is better and cheaper in the long run. My Baldor 1725 rpm grinder was bought some 20 years ago and has worked well ever since. Two blue Norton wheels are perfect and last longer than the white ones.

I did invest in a 180 grit CBN wheel a year ago, and while I like it, it is not so much better than the blue Norton to justify the much higher price.

As far as wet grinding for turning tools, I am firmly against. You DO need the burr on all turning tools, except the skew. There is probably no controversy on scrapers, but gouges also use the burr effectively - both for shear scraping and in the common push cut. If you analyze the cutting action in the push-cut, then the bulk of material is hogged off by the wings in close to scraping angles, while the final surface is produced by the area close to the tip. The burr reduces the shearing angle both places.

Re: grinder choice

#10

Re: And now for a little diverging opinion....

John lucas

I would have to respectfully disagree on the gouge needing a burr. For one thing the burr on the gouge is gone in 20 seconds or less once you start cutting When I need a really clean cut I sharpen my gouge and the. Polish the burr off before cutting. Works for me anyway.

Re: grinder choice

#11

Steven Antonucci

Agree... no burr on a gouge?

steven antonucci

Another fable that has been repeated without any real investigation?

Aside from shear scraping, there is no burr. I know I don't have one, simply because I strop it away on the rounded profile leather wheel on my Tormek. If you have a burr, you are not sharp.

But, guess what? Even if you hone away the burr, you can still shear scrape very effectively! I use a skew in end grain as a negative rake scraper, and will sometimes use a gouge of questionable sharpness rolled over. No burr, good results.

S

Re: grinder choice

#12

Steven Antonucci

A Tormek and a $10 flea market Sears

steven antonucci

For starters, you need to distinguish between grinding and sharpening. Grinding is about removing metal quickly without destroying the temper of the steel. Sharpening is about producing a refined edge.

Doug Thompson's grinding video from his demo in Missouri will show you what is possible with regards to how much you can remove, how quickly, and how a properly dressed wheel can do it without heat. You could certainly cut with that edge and never really miss a beat.

Sharpening is the exact same thing, only with finer abrasives. There is a practical limit to how sharp any turning tool needs to be and the amount of time it would take to get it that sharp. Even moreso, wear resistance of the steel will dictate how long it will remain sharp.

I had an old Sears plastic body grinder that someone gave to me at some point. When someone else was selling their metal body grinder for $10, I upgraded and gave away the plastic body one. The grinder has a platform that is roughly 1"x1"...aka, almost completely useless. I use it to rough profile tools like scrapers, grind off the heels of my gouges, and various other non sharpening operations. I think it is a 3450, but I don't know for sure. The one gray wheel is 60 or 80, the other is 80 or 120... I don't really know? Both run pretty true, and get dressed after any heavy use.

The Tormek is usually a little dished from gouges, and I spend a few minutes getting it flat again when it is 1/16" low in the center. If I am going to do a flat blade, I will get it perfect. Usually, I just get it close.

Prior to both of them, I used a belt sander with a used 220 belt. You can make stuff wicked sharp using a belt sander, and replace the belt easily when it wears out. If you invested a little bit of time in making jigs for a belt sander, it would be a formidable solution...

S

Re: grinder choice

#13

Re: grinder choice

robo hippy

Well, I would suggest for most turners, if they are not used to being around a grinder, that a slow speed one would be less intimidating. Other than that, learning the difference between sharpening and grinding is pretty big. I think that a lot of professional turners over sharpen. For a gouge, one pass to the right side, one pass to the left side, and you are done. Maybe 2 passes to raise a good burr for a scraper.

I will have to check my gouges for burrs. I never hone them off, but never thought about how long they are on. I am pretty sure there is still a burr left when I am done turning with one. Reasoning is that the CBN wheels raise a better and stronger burr than standard wheels.

robo hippy

Re: grinder choice

#14

8" Baldor is $1000 new, no CBNs


Re: grinder choice

#15

Re: Agree... no burr on a gouge?

Steve Worcester.

With a negative rake scraper, you are using the bur. easy way to tell is when you go to the grinder, assuming the wheel is moving down, there will be a bur on the top side. If you think the bur isn't important, flip it over and see how effective it is at cutting.

Re: grinder choice

#16

Re: A Tormek and a $10 flea market Sears

Steve Worcester.

So, when your are sharpening, aren't you bringing away metal? Inserting semantics will only make it more confusing.

Re: grinder choice

#17

Steven Antonucci

grit determines edge

Steven Antonucci

You can use a 24 grit wheel to remove metal, but you won't get much of an edge. There is a middle ground where you go from stock removal to creating a cutting edge. Removing metal is required to sharpen, but do you want to cut with a 24 grit edge? Or would you rather reprofile a gouge on an 8000 grit water stone?

Semantics, but again...not.

S

Re: grinder choice

#18

Steven Antonucci

Hone the burr off of a skew

steven antonucci

and try it as a NRS... then tell me if you still think it is important.

Not 100% convinced it is required...but I rarely use a NRS (except my skew).

S

Re: grinder choice

#19

Steve, a 24 grit edge would cut......

JamieDonaldson

...wood just fine, but we call those tools "saws!" ;)