Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

twisted goblet.

Posts

twisted goblet.

#1

twisted goblet.

John Lucas

I'm been working like crazy reorganizing my man cave that masks itself as a garage. I still have a lot of work to do but simply had to stop and turn something. We had a demo at our club on turning twisted boxes and that was the presidents challenge. I figured I could turn a goblet and not take up too much time away from the shop rebuild.

For those who have never done something like this the process is quite easy. The tool control however is quite challenging to get clean cuts without ridges since your only hitting the wood for 1/3 of the revolution. I should have tried a scraper just for the heck of it but doubt you could do it. I think it would tear the trailing corner and the corners on these need to be very clean to show off the twist.

what you do is simply turn a cylinder. Then draw a circle about 5/8" from the center on each end. Mark off 120 degree dots. These will be your off set centers. Mark the dots 1,2,3. Do the same on the other end making sure 1 aligns with 1 etc. Now mount it between centers using number 1 on one end and 2 on the other. turn this. Then mount it between 2 and 3, then 3 and 1. Then mount it between centers and turn a tenon onwhat will be the bottom of the goblet. The trick is to get the offcenter sides exactly the same width. I had forgotten that step since it's been probably 10 years since I did one of these. That throws the goblet opening off center so one side is thin compared to the other 2. You can't see that in this photo (because I'm a good photographer and know how to hide things like that)

Anyway it was fun so now I have to get back to doing flat work and finish the shop redo.


Re: twisted goblet.

#2

Re: twisted goblet.

Steve criscenzo

Very nice John. I watched a video by Barbara Dill on you tube a while back and gave it a try but I struggled to get the there sides the same. Might be time to give it another go.

Steve

Re: twisted goblet.

#3

Nice job!

GaryG in MD

I like it! ...GG

Re: twisted goblet.

#4

Re: twisted goblet.

charlie belden

Multi axis turning is pretty much an unexplored area of turning, with an almost unlimited amount of possibilities for new and interesting turned pieces, especially turned sculpture. Once you escape from single axis symetry - and "functional", things get really interesting. But if you don't understand the fundamental concepts of multi axis turning, and how they effect the "outcome", it can be a Hit Or Miss thing - sometimes your turn something nice and interesting - but most times the result is not so interesting. And because you're turning on multi axis, what you turn on one axis will affect what you've already turned on another axis - or preclude what you can turn on the next axis.

Barbara Dills articles and demos of her Structured Approach to Multi Axis turning provided a way to develop a "mental model" of multi axis ideas, something I'd tried but was unable to do 'til Barbara came along and shared her discoveries and approach. It's easy to demonstrate HOW. It's much more difficult to explain WHY - to link Cause to Effect.

What's made getting fundamental concepts of multi axis turning acrossed - in drawn or photographed illustrations is the difficulty of conveying 3D information in static 2D images. But with video and virtual 3D objects created in 3D CAD programs, that obstacle is being overcome. I've been working in Google's free SketchUp 3D CAD software, creating virtual 3D models showing fundamental concepts of multi axis turning. Collaborating with Barbara, and Peter Rand, who is scultping on a lathe using multiple axis, for the last year or more, I'm half way through putting together a web page Multi Axis Primer that will use 2D illustrations, 2 1/2D illustrations taken of virtual 3D models, video animations of virtual 3D models and downloadable SketchUp files of virtual 3D multi axis objects. In the process, I've learned how to DESIGN multi axis pieces virtually - and have all the information needed to actually turn DESIGNED pieces - and hopefully will be able to show how to do that.

It'll be another month or two before what I'm working on is done. When it is I'll post a link to it. Stay tuned . . .

Re: twisted goblet.

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: twisted goblet.

Keith Tompkins

Great job John. I like how you turned a multi-axis exercise into an attractive finished product.

Re: twisted goblet.

#6

Re: twisted goblet.

Peter Lamb

John,

You are becomming the new Barbra Gill!

Well done. I am not surprised by your skills

any more.. Sorry.

Re: twisted goblet.

#7

Jim Barbour

very nicely done 


Re: twisted goblet.

#8

That's Barbara Dill, not Gill

charlie belden

Barbara Dill is the one who developed A Structured Approach To Mulit Axis Turning, wrote three articles on the subject for the AAW journal, put together a DVD on multi axis turning, has YouTube videos on multi axis turning and demonstrates multi axis turning at AAW symposiums, at several arts and crafts schools (Arrowmont for example) and for turning clubs. A very busy person with a real passion for multi axis turning and a real desire to share what she's learned about this expanding field of turning.

Re: twisted goblet.

#9

I've made the same mistake. It is Barbara dill

John lucas

I e been doing off enter turning for years and have most of the books co ering the subject. Barbara is the first one to rally try to break it down into understandable terms. As charley mentioned some have tried describing maybe one technique in 2D drawings but Barbara tries to teach you how to approach it ills a sequence a d keep notes so you can better judge a logical progression.

If you join the AAW. You have a cess to not only her great articles but many more. The cost is about the same as one good book.

Re: twisted goblet.

#11

Re: twisted goblet.

Jason Clark

I was thinking of doing one of these the other day. The 3 sided captured ring and base are cool.

I have a very simple numbering system to label the point on each end so you can do points 1 and 1, then 2 & 2, then 3 & 3. That way I don't have to remember if it was 1 to 2, or 2 to 1, or 3 to 2, etc.

Jason

Re: twisted goblet.

#12

Re: twisted goblet.

John lucas

I just rotate by hand and watch where it clears the tool rest. That keeps me from making mistakes I can sort of preview where ill be cutting

Re: twisted goblet.

#13

Re: twisted goblet.

Lloyd in Mississauga

John,

Nice piece, with a little carving at the inside of the cup to bring the outside corns into your center to trick the eye into thinking that you some how off set the inside as well.

I think the trick for getting the sides all the same depth is to try and put a narrow little tenon at the top and bottom to use as a guide for cut depth. Once you get the sides turned down to that tenon depth, then all should be the same. Peter has done a few demo's at our club as he is a member there.

Lloyd