Recently attended a David Ellsworth demo. In discussing faceplates, he claimed that a rough surface on the faceplate gave it more "traction" and aided the holding power of the screws. Recommended leaving it out in the rain and rust pitting the surface. Most of my faceplates are aluminum. Do you think that using a knurling, texturing or chatter tool on the faceplate surface would be equivilent and is this worth doing?
I certainly won't say anything against Ellsworth but I doubt it adds all that much. Most failures I've seen were either screws breaking from using the wrong screws or the endgrain pulling out because the screws didn't hold well enough. The one thing I will recommend however is to counter sink the holes on the wood side of the faceplate. When you put a screw in it want's to pull the fibers down and the flat part of the wood may not seat as well as it should. ( in that case of course no matter how rough your faceplate is it won't matter. By counter sinking the holes a little those fibers are pulled into that gap and the wood will sit flat on the faceplate.
For your aluminum, I think I would put the coarsest grit disk I could find on a right angle grinder, then set my VFD on its slowest setting, then hole the grinder against it, with it tilted so the scratch was perpendicular to the rim.
How thick is your aluminum FP? I hope it is thick, otherwise, a bigger problem than slip, could be breaking it. The only one I ever had break, was aluminum, where the threaded hub in the middle broke out.
Just a quick comment - I have received a report (and have seen photos) that a turner using a cast aluminium face plate sold by Grizzly snapped off where the plate met the cast-in threadedhded section. I have never heard of a turned 6061 aluminum faceplate breaking.
The face of the face plate acts as a shoulder like the faces in the dovetail jaws. Do anybody build rust in their chuck jaws?
PS: what holds wood " against" the face plate are the screws. If the screws get loose then the platter or whatever starts to vibrate. In any case for friction Rather than rust I'd like a paper towel or thin foam.
Don't worry about a rough surface on the faceplate. It seats around the edge or rim of the faceplate against the concave surface of the wood. Not enough help to make any difference. Do not use a texturing tool on the faceplate. You want the rim running true. Id also recommend steel faceplates.
Just stick a piece of coarse PSA sand paper on it and it a try. I have no idea if this would help, but it would be easier to take off and throw away than to smooth out your face plate.
I think I have an instinctual understanding what David Ellsworth is getting at. Maybe someone else can explain it better, maybe with the actual mathmatical terms. I'm thinking that the screws apply a tension and compression force from the wood to the faceplate. If there was zero friction between the wood and the faceplate, the forces are all on the screws in the wood. I believe these are the major forces needful to hold wood to the faceplate. However, I also believe there is a sheer force between the faceplate/wood. Without friction, all of the sheer force is applied to the screws and thus the wood. How much sheer force there is, I don't know. I think David wants to increase the friction component as to reduce the forces applied to the wood through the screws. Thus reducing screw/wood failures by some small, probably unprovable amount.
I don't take anybodies word as the last word, but when experience and wisdom speaks, I tend to listen. Just thought it would be interesting to hear what others thought.
I believe you are on the right track Dave and David. There is an engineering basis for doing this. There are two components of added stress that will occur if the coefficient of friction at the faceplate is low. One is the sheer stress on the screws, which adds at right-angles to the tensile stress on the screw to produce a higher total stress. The other is a direct increase in tensile stress caused by the fact that as the rotational joint slips the, screws have to stretch since they now have to reach at an angle between the two anchor points instead of directly across the joint. There is extremely large leverage involved in this last component so rotational slippage must be constrained by some means if the screws are otherwise operating near their failure point stress. One means is to use friction. Another is to use pins or additional screws with enough sheer strength to prevent rotational slippage. Use of screws that are a snug fit in the faceplate holes will also help.
I probably should have added that this is only an issue if the screws have been driven so tight that they are near their breaking stress. Use more screws and don't over-tighten them.
...Ellsworth also recommends spraying water on bedways to induce rust that increases the holding power of banjos and tailstocks. While true in theory, I know very few turners who would intentionally rust those metal surfaces we often work hard to maintain as nice shiny surfaces!