Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Threading jig ?

Posts

Threading jig ?

#1

Threading jig ?

Richard Jones

While it seems we're on a threading "kick", has anyone tried the EZ Threading Jig Pro from Chefwarekits.com? Looks pretty simple, was wondering how it does in real life.

Thanks,

Rich

Re: Threading jig ?

#2

barry rockwell

Re: Threading jig ?

Barry Rockwell

I just treated myself to buying one but haven't had a chance to try it yet. I called and ordered it and had excellent service. It was shipped the same day and I received it 2 days later. I've examined and assembled it and it seems exceptionally well made and high quality materials. All functions seem to work and fit great. Really anxious to try it but got busy, and now I'm packing up to go back to Montana. That will be one of the first things I do when I get home.

Re: Threading jig ?

#3

Re: Threading jig ?

Dick Coers

Never used one, but I would be concerned about the mounting in the banjo. There is nothing to keep it aligned with the bed of the lathe. It's mounted on a round shaft in a banjo, so 1 pivot point. Then you have the second place for alignment when clamping the banjo to the bed. You have to reposition the whole system between threading the box and the lid, so you loose the alignment between the cuts. The guy in the video talks about using a square on the banjo to align it to the lathe, but how does it actually align in the banjo. It's also very narrow with no way to reduce backlash in the thread. I know we are cutting threads in wood, but there just looks way too easy to get tapered threads. The video on the web site does nothing to show alignment, and you can see the runout in his jacobs drill chuck when he starts it up. Argh!

Re: Threading jig ?

#4

barry rockwell

Re: Threading jig ?

Barry Rockwell

Dick, my thoughts when I purchased it were as follows: as a retired surveyor I would not have much trouble aligning the unit with the ways of the lathe. It has a very nice, smooth, cross slide mechanism and I've checked for play in all the moving parts and found virtually none. I also figured I would normally be threading no more than 1/4" to 3/8", if that much, on anything I'm going to thread. It would have to be a serious misalignment to get tapered threads in that distance. I would worry more about getting the turning right on before trying to thread it. So anyway, I bought it. It will be a couple weeks before I'm going to be able to actually try it, but when I do, I will post my results and opinion on WC.

Re: Threading jig ?

#5

Re: Threading jig ?

Dale Miner

I built a jig that mounts in the toolpost similar to this several years ago. I did add an additional bearing to the spindle to reduce the effect of clearance in the threads. Since the cutter is held in the lathe headstock, and the part being threaded is moved past the cutter, it is impossible to get a tapered thread from alignment of the jig (more on this below).

If the jig is mounted a few degrees off parallel to the bed ways, the thread will not be a tapered thread, but will have an inaccurate form. That is, instead of the thread having a 60 degree angle on both sides, the thread will have an angle of a bit more than 60 degrees on one side and a bit less than 60 degrees on the other. I line my jig up by looking over the top and eyeballing the spindle parallel to the ways. For wooden parts that need plenty of clearance to work with changing weather conditions, perfect thread form is not needed.

Back to the tapered thread issue: If there is excess clearance in the threads on the spindle so that the part being threaded can wobble as the thread are being milled, then the wobble can cause a slight taper, or more likely, and out of round thread. Excess clearance can also allow the cutter to pull and push the part being threaded axially, resulting in a varying thread pitch.

Out of round and varying pitch threads will require more running clearance and at some point there will be insuffcient engagement and the threads will 'strip' when tightened.

Actually, even with clearance in the thread on the spindle, a bit of manually holding the spindle clearance towards the cutter while rotating results in very good results. Just a short learning curve.

Re: Threading jig ?

#6

Re: Threading jig ?

Richard Jones

Yep, would think the owner would post an actual instructional video.........

Re: Threading jig ?

#7

Re: Threading jig ?

John Lucas

I have one and helped write the intructions on how to use it. It works. The alignment obviously isn't as good as ones mount on the ways but as was said earlier if you off a hair it makes a tapered thread but since your only making 1/4 ot 3/8" long thread it really doesn't matter much. It depends entirely on how picky you are.

I use the Baxter threader and love it. It's like driving a fine car. Everything about it works precisely and you can make very accurate threads. With the Chefware threader it's more like driving a chinese car. It gets you there, sometimes with a little effort but it still works.

Seriously though it's not a bad threader just not in the same league as the Baxter theader. But then neither is the price.

Re: Threading jig ?

#8

Nicely explained

Dick Coers

I only have experience with a Klein lathe and fixture. Bonnie used to make a big deal about the alignment of her fixture staying parallel to the center line during her demos. I wonder if the misshapen threads will be a bigger deal if threading corian or acrylic where the threads can be tighter?

Dale, Did you use a larger hand wheel on the fixture shaft your threading jig? The one on the ez pro seems really small.

Barry, I look forward to your review. I thought I could see motion in the threads on the video. When you add the thread overhang, the length of the chuck, and the length of the box, I would be curious if you would add an indicator on the box and see how much you can flex those threads. I'll be patient. I have a Carba-tec Threadmaster in a box that I bought in 1995. It's never been on a lathe!

Re: Threading jig ?

#9

Re: Nicely explained

Dale Miner

The handwheel used was about 4.5" D if memory serves true, and has a crank handle to spin it with.

The method I use;

Turn the spigot or bore to desired dimension, and leave in the chuck. Remove the chuck from the lathe spindle and set the jig up and put the chuck/part on the jig spindle. Do not remove the part from the chuck until the threads are cut. Turn the jig spindle by hand by holding the chuck against the slop in the threads towards the cutter. This will keep all clearance in the threads loaded towards the cutter and help eliminate errors. When turning the chuck by hand, it is necessary to use both hands and keep the spindle side loaded when changing hands. When the thread is cut to the end, stop the lathe, back the cutter away from the part, and wind the spindle backwards. Winding the spindle backwards with the cutter against the wood can sometimes mess the thread up if the clearance in the jig parts lets the cutter find a new path.

My jig has 16 tpi, and I allow. 070" for threading between the spigot OD and the bore ID. (Spigot is. 070" larger than bore.) This is probably a touch more than needed but it allows for sneaking up on the thread fit.

Re: Threading jig ?

#10

Mike Peace

Re: Threading jig ?

Mike Peace

Interesting analogy, John. I agree. It does get the job done for a price that a hobbyist who is not making threaded boxes for a living might afford. If I was making LOTS of boxes, I would stick with the Baxter or Klein jig. I am happy with the results I get from the EZ Threader based on the price I paid for it.

I still get a lot of satisfaction hand chasing when the wood is capable of hand chasing.

Re: Threading jig ?

#11

Re: Threading jig ?

Stuart Johnson

How well does it work on softer woods? I thought that was one of the biggest advantages along with ease of use for the Baxter and others but in the video he says it would work better in a something harder.

Re: Threading jig ?

#12

Re: Threading jig ?

John Lucas

With softer woods you may have to make a light cut and then soak the threads in CA and then make a deeper cut etc until you have the full pass. The reason I bought my Baxter threader was because it (and other powered threaders) will thread woods that are far too soft to chase threads. I do a lot of boxes in Cherry, walnut,soft maple, and poplar with excellent success. No CA needed on those. I have cut threads in Box elder which is rediculously soft. I used the CA and got great threads.

Re: Threading jig ?

#13

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Threading jig ?

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, I would guess that a coarser thread pitch would be best suited for the softer woods. What is your experience and what is your go-to pitch for woods of medium hardness?

Dennis

Re: Threading jig ?

#14

Re: Threading jig ?

John Lucas

I use 16TPI for almost everything. 20 works well with hardwoods. I don't do larger boxes but if I did I would go with a courser thread to compensate for wood movement. I would also make them fit a little looser for the same reason. if you make a box over about 3" and 20TPI you might have the same problem. I use 20 for small boxes made of hard woods.

I do have an 11TPI chaser. So far the only time I've used it was on a moderately large box that had epoxy for me to chase the threads into.

You can also not cut the thread full depth and leave a flat on top. This makes the threads tougher but you need to make the tolerance between the sizes a little tighter.