Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

'Nuther McNaughton Question

Posts

'Nuther McNaughton Question

#1

Brad Vietje

'Nuther McNaughton Question

Brad Vietje

I have an older McNaughton Center Saver from about 12 years ago -- not at all the same as Chuck Engstrom's. My dad bought this setup and only got the largest set of knives, and I inherited it when he died in 2004. These are from before they were pointed at the tip, but were a straight cutting edge, skewed at an angle from the tip.

I would like to get the medium and small knife sets, and wonder if anyone has experience with this? My set was manufactured before the smaller knives were released, so there are only 2 guide positions. I heard a rumor that to use the smaller knives I would have to adapt the medium size guide posts to accommodate the narrower profile of the small knife set. One idea was to put a short piece of copper pipe or tubing over one or both of the guides to narrow the gap so the smaller knives wouldn't rattle about. I'd also have to either raise the unit to use the smaller knives, or consider some sort of spacer to lift them up to the same center height as the other sets.

I'd like to be able to invest in the medium and small knives without having to buy a complete new setup, which I can't afford to do right now. If there's no good solution to adding the small cutters, I'd probably just add the medium set, which should require no adaptation at all. I'd appreciate learning from the wisdom of the group on this.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#2

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

robo hippy

The medium knives should work fine. With the small set, I am not sure, You may be able to fit them in the medium slot as I think they are the same thickness, but you would have to raise your tool rest a bit. The micro knives would not work here. Also, if you can afford it, I would replace the large set as well, except for the straight one. Having the tip centered on the blade is a huge advantage over the older dog eared ones.

robo hippy

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#3

barry rockwell

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

Barry Rockwell

I believe the older blades can be re-shaped to resemble the newer ones. I believe I saw a thread about it on WC or WoW. You Might check. IMHO the micro blades are not worth worrying about unless you're as good as Mike Mahoney. Making micro nested sets loses it's allure quickly. My $0.02.

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#4

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

robo hippy

Well, actually, the old blades can be reground so they are more of a spear point, but then the point is not centered on the blade. The flange of the blade is all on the outside of the blade. The newer ones have a flange on both sides of the blades. This was a huge improvement. I really wish there was another blade with a curve in between the medium curve and the small curved blade.

I use the standard set of blades for 90% of the cores I take, and on rare occasion will use the small and micro blades. I don't often use the large blades either. Mostly because I don't turn that bit very often. They are for tiny cores of valuable or precious woods.

robo hippy

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#5

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton

Darryl

Brad when I received my mid size blades I also received a small piece of tubing and a riser block to fit my gate. Took me a bit to understand what the additional pieces were for. A piece of tubing copper or aluminum would suffice. The riser block would be useful but you can get by by setting the blade tip at the center of your work thereby eliminating the need for the riser. The tubing only serves to keep the blade form twisting when you work so it just needs to be large enough to make the blade snug but not tight as it slides through the pins.

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#6

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton

Dale Bonertz

I was going to say what Darryl covered. Kel told me once that he makes a sleeve for the old turrets so people can use the new blades. Email him to confirm and find out who to order them from.

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton

Brad Vietje

Thanks, Guys -- this is helpful. I knew the medium set would be fine, and I thought there was a way to adapt for the small set.

Raising the gate is another issue -- I have a PM 3520B, so the shaft seems pretty short to begin with. I need to get a machine shop to make me a longer shaft, and possibly a collar to bear down on the top of the cast iron of the banjo.

The original set was used on an old Rockwell-Delta lathe with riser blocks, and if I recall, my dad had ordered the medium knives from a Woodcraft store about 2-1/2 hours away, and they somehow got the large set instead of the medium, and after driving all the way over there, he accepted the big set instead of driving home empty-handed, when I would have had them send me the medium and eat the large knives... Maybe he figured with riser blocks he could work pretty big blanks, but taller does not more massive nor powerful make, and I only recall him trying to use them a few times before he took ill.

I don't use them much, but would probably use the Medium set quite often. Small set would be for nicer burls and smaller natural edge bowls, and I don't anticipate ever needing the micro set -- I tend to make hollow forms and ornaments, but not bowls from smaller chunks of high-value wood.

I appreciate all the good advice and knowledge from the WoodCentral brain trust!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#8

Get the new gate

Jorge

and you are set to work with all the different size knives.

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#9

Re: Get the new gate

robo hippy

Out of all the gates, other than the one shown here, my favorite are the 2 gate, and 3 gate models. The newer Mark 8 just has too much going on.

You can easily make a stop collar if you turn an end grain piece and hollow it out go go around the tool post. My old coring video is now up on You Tube, and I show it in there.

robo hippy

Re: 'Nuther McNaughton Question

#10

concur

Jorge

The 2 gate and the 3 are best, I got the 3.