Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Posts

Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#1

Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Dick Coers

Not picking on anyone here, just wanted to see what others think. We have two posts going, asking for help with demo presentations. I see this kind of post from time to time, and on several different forums. Shouldn't the presenter be the expert? Shouldn't he have such a range of experience that he can do the show without help from the masses? Of course no single person can have had every experience, but shouldn't you be expected to know enough to talk for a couple of hours based on your level of skill and experience? I seem to see a trend that after just a couple of years turning part time, some folks now accept the position of expert and accept the role of instructor. To me, they are coming up a little short of the title, and may not being doing the best service for those hoping to learn. Probably just me getting old, but I still highly value the dedication taken to develop a skill to the level where you have a full and complete understanding, plus the ability to share that knowledge. I've been honing my skills for 29 years this year, and I'll not stand up in front of anyone unless I really have the confidence that I am fully versed on the methods. Am I looking at this incorrectly? Are these people just to provide enough of a taste to inspire someone to experiment on their own? Go ahead, fire away!

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#2

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Barry Irby

I'm a little unsure about this. I have seen demo's or attended training events that ranged from really poor to fabulous. Not sure there was much correlation between the expertise of the presenter and the quality of the presentation.

Some very knowledgeable demonstrators fail to grasp what the audience needs to know. Sometimes they are so far ahead of the masses they can no longer relate. Sometimes they don't want to. So if nothing else, getting advice from the masses might tune up their thinking.

Also, almost everyone knows something I don't know and I will take advice where I can get it.

Then there is the old saying See one, Do one, Teach one.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#3

I believe you're asking a "relative"..............

JamieDonaldson

...question Dick, relative to the subject and scope of the presentation. Some demonstrators such as the AAW Symposium recruits might also be considered moderators, selected to lead or chair a discussion on a selected topic. Having broad general knowledge of that field aids in structuring a discussion, but the moderator doesn't necessarily need to have an encyclopedic knowledge of the specific subject, and he/she is not expected to supply all the answers to all possible questions. Often formulating a question is the most important and difficult part of deductive reasoning, the methodology of coming to a satisfactory resolution to a question. In a group discussion, active input from participants generally yields a broader and more beneficial outcome. As a specific example, Dave Long doesn't have to be an electrician to lead a discussion that addresses lighting in a show booth, because as an active collector he has spent many hours in such booths all across the country. I would much prefer to have interactions with a person who knows how to structure a discussion, rather than preach the answers as he knows them to a captive and silent audience! ;)

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#4

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Roger Chandler

I think a demonstrator should be competent in the thing he is demonstrating and general competence in the aspects of lathe use and turning.

That being said, I do not think every demonstrator can be an expert at all things related to turning. I have done several demos, and am slated to do a demo at our state symposium in September.........that does not mean that I know all there is to know related to turning. I can hold my own and try not to overstate my credentials in turning or anything else for that matter!

The fact that others who have seen my work, including a demo or two, ask me to do demos and such, is an indication that at least to some degree I have demonstrated competence first of all.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#5

Demonstrators asking the masses

jeff Willaford

Just as I do not hesitate to ask a question of the demonstrator I have no issue with the demonstrator asking a question of me. That's how we both learn. Just my personal opinon.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#6

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

John Lucas

Well it's quite simple. We can't know it all. I know an awful lot. Been turning for almost 30 years and try all sorts of things. However I firmly believe I can learn more. Especially from a group such as this. Not fussing at you just trying to explain that any instructor who thinks he or she knows it all and can't learn something from a group like this is not very open.

In my case about thread chasing. I've done it a lot, and tried quite a few woods but simply can't try them all. I thought I would put it out there and ask others what they use. I'll post the list shortly so you all can learn what I picked up. It wouldn't be as good a demo if I only mentioned 3 or 4 woods none of which you can find locally. Part of preparing for a good demo or article is doing the research to be able to help your audience learn.

We have some awfully sharp people on the various forums and if I can pick their brains and then share this knowledge with others I think we all benefit. When I did my article about 12 years ago on making tools from files, I spent a good month or more doing research and talking to blacksmiths and metalurgists so that I could distil the info down to something the general public would use and understand. That was before computers and took a lot of leg work. I don't see what we do today as any different except you have a much wider group of "experts" to try and learn from.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#7

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Sergio

My personal opinion is that asking is not wrong. It may help expand the lesson or demonstration.

Having said that, I also believe that the real expert are only a few, and would not be enough to cover all the symposiums out there. The business must go on, experts or not experts.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Lyle Jamieson

I’ve done a LOT of turning, I’ve done a LOT of teaching and demonstrations. But I’m just a C+ kind of guy. Half of folks are smarter and more savvy then me. I am in a pretty good place here because I’m ahead of the rest of you. Every time I do a demo or teach a class I learn something. If I quit asking questions I might as well hang it up.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#9

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Dick Coers

I guess I've never seen you ask a question on the internet or in person Lyle. Maybe I should not be interpreting the questions as lack of knowledge or skills. I do all my own research, experiment with techniques and methods I want to try, then work at it till I'm happy with the level I get to. Could be I'm just surprised at what people ask about instead of working it out themselves. Heck, I read a question on a forum from a guy that was asking about dust on his eyeglasses! I'll chalk it up to being raised on a farm, and the way I am wired. I plan on learning till I can't take a breath. I mean that from old age, not from dust inhalation!

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#10

Steven Antonucci

I ask questions to keep the audience engaged.

steven antonucci

Aside from helping me improve what my demo is, asking questions is vital to keeping the audience alive. We've all been in demos where the audience is lost, or disengaged. If I am showing you something that is not interesting, I want to know... so I ask various questions with different goals?

Do you understand what I am doing (I know I do, but that doesn't mean you do?)

Is it interesting? (who is going to go home and try it?)

Are there things that I could add or remove?. (not my jokes, you have to sit through them...)

If you have ever been to a demo at the national symposiums, you will see people walk out on all kinds of demos. Big names, no names, etc... I always want to know why. If you have never demonstrated, you probably don't know how much work goes into building a new demo. Doing something and showing something are two different things. Something that takes 5 minutes to do might take 20 minutes in a demo because you need to stop and start to get questions.

Nothing wrong with questions from demonstrators.

S

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#11

Re: I ask questions to keep the audience engaged.

Dale Bonertz

Steve,

I can partially answer why some people walk out of demonstrations. I don't think that for most people that they are walking out because it is a bad demonstration but rather other reasons. I have only been to our symposium (Rocky Mountain Woodturning Symposium) but the people that I observe leaving often times are working the symposium (I have had to leave many demonstrations). Others are trying to get to two demonstrations in the same time slot. They go to one first because they know what they want to learn will be in the first part of one demonstrators demo and the second part of another demonstrators demo (I to have done this). I have also heard some tell me they had to leave because they can't sit or stand that long (bad back for instance). Always so much to learn, things to do and reasons for having to move.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#12

Misunderstood OP question?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

Steve: I think you misunderstood the OP question. I believe he was asking about demonstrators using something like WC to ask questions about the topic they were going to demonstrate on (i.e. shouldn't the demonstrator already know those answers already since they were the 'experts'?).

You are absolutely correct about audience engagement and feedback though!

Henry

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#13

Alan Sweet

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Alan Sweet

I agree John. I my opinion, no matter how much you think you know or have experienced, there are always people in your audience that have had experiences from who you can learn. I don't have time to spend to try to learn everything about a subject when a simple question will yield the desired results.

With this large and varied forum, the range of experiences you have to draw from is fantastic. In fact, I don't think I would ever just reply on my experiences as the final answer. It is amazing how God has given us unique experiences and skills.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#14

George Taylor

Also depends on the venue ...

George Taylor

... club meetings or symposiums ... or more importantly paid or volunteer?

I think we (as attendees) would naturally expect a more professional, in depth demonstration from a paid demonstrator whether at a club meeting or a symposium. Having been involved in both small club and large, I see the challenge in getting more members involved in demonstrating. I would not criticize any demonstrator that has volunteered his time and effort to put themselves out there in front of a group.

Just my 2 cents.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#15

Steven Antonucci

I consider this "an audience" too?

steven antonucci

My point was that it should be considered best practices to be able to ask a question of anyone at any time or in any forum if you were a demonstrator. Being an expert doesn't mean you know everything, just more than most people. In some cases, more is just a little bit more than someone who is not an expert.

There are as many right ways to do things as there are wrong ways. If I don't learn something every time I demo, I probably didn't do a good job. I only go to demos to learn how to demo better... I can usually figure out how to do something on my own.

Steve

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#16

Re: I consider this "an audience" too? *LINK*

Dick Coers

If the demonstrator just barely knows more than the audience, it better be advertised that way.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFWeoxrhbE8

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#17

Re: I ask questions to keep the audience engaged.

Mike Brazeau

I walked out a demonstration at the St. Paul Symposium because I lost interest in the topic when it got to a certain stage. Managed to catch second half of Todd Hoyer's presentation on Turning Burls and Figured Wood in a nearby room. Was the highlight of the symposium for me!

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#18

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

John Lucas

Walking out on a demo happens all the time. Not so much at local demos of course but at symposiums where there are lots of choices and the vendor and instant gallery areas it happens a lot.

There are many reasons. First off you have to consider the fact that quite often at symposiums there are a lot of turners there as good or better than the presenter. Or it could be as simple as "I've seen that before" since many demonstrators do the same demo from year to year.

We are an older crowd. Could be you simply needed a bathroom or coffee break.

At almost every demo I do at least one person is nodding his head. As I said before we are an older crowd and lets face it, sometimes demos get boring at parts. :)

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#19

In My Experience

George Guadiane

Asking others about a topic they are going to demonstrate seems appropriate.

ESPECIALLY if you REALLY know the topic and have not demonstrated it before... Here's why:

When I'm preparing for a new demo, or one I haven't done in a while, I ask for suggestions on highlights and/or details. If I "really know" the topic, I might do it by rote and neglect to transfer some of the more important details, because for me, they seem obvious or so routine that I just do it and keep going. If no one asks the question, the info gets lost and the demo is not as good as it should.could be.

Even if I KNOW the topic, the "skin a cat" aspect comes into my mind and I like to have methods and ideas from others in my pocket in case someone doesn't get what I'm trying to say. Knowing what to do and translating that into a teaching moment isn't always easy.

AND, I'm not embarrassed to say that as much as I know, I could still learn more.

Also, I have demonstrated a few things and seem to get a good response. I was a top 40 copy band singer for about 10 years, so I spent a lot of time in front of people. I'm comfortable in front of a crowd. People who are not comfortable in front of an audience can get nervous and go blank. Asking the audience "for help" can be a way to get back on track AND keep the audience engaged as they fell more like participants than observers.

I like to include the demo audience as I have often learned something unexpected.

As an additional but perhaps tangential thought, I have participated in several clubs as a demonstrator and in the audience. I almost ALWAYS stay for the demonstrations. I want to support the club and even as a "professional knowitall," I learn things.

With beginners and friends, I have been asked to observe and report on how they did. But primarily, I stay because it is respectful... and I almost ALWAYS learn something - even if it's what not to do.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#20

Mike Stafford

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Mike Stafford

Competence is in the eye of the beholder.

I love seeing comments from turners about their own competence who use flowery words and phrases such as "stellar" and "work finished to some degree of excellence" to describe their own work.

Self promotion, self aggrandizing comments about one's own work do not guarantee competence. I sometimes wonder if some people don't have sore arms from patting themselves on the back. I do know that these same turners claiming competence have more excuses and responses to their own threads than people commenting on their "stellar" work.

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#22

Don Leydens

:-)


Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

#23

Re: Demonstrators asking the masses for help?

Dick Coers

All things considered, that was close to the direction I was going with this Mike. I know that with my personality, and the grouchiness of aging, I have less and less tolerance with folks that look for marketing advice on the second or third bowl they have ever made. Then I would see those that have little experience with some techniques that they learned from other professional turners, and go around demoing to anyone that asks. As mentioned by others, maybe we just need that many turners to fill the demand, but I think of it more as entertainment compared to teaching. Just to pick a subject, how many guys go around demoing how to make boxes? Didn't we learn all those basic techniques from Raffan, or even someone earlier? It can be a good demo if done well, but if I have to watch a turner sneak up on a little jamb chuck too many times, I just about pull out what little hair I have left. So if I watch someone talk about their design, surface enhancements, or some new tooling, I will consider it a demo. If they just stand up there and make a box, I hope it is entertainment.