Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

Posts

I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#1

I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

Craig Daymon

An artist friend posted a link to this on FB. A driveway made of old manhole covers. When I see round shapes, I immediately think how I might be able to apply it to a turning. I think there is something here.


Driveway paved with old manhole covers

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#2

You have seen Alby Hall's pieces?


Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

Moulthrop, Gianfranco Angellino?


Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#4

Re: Moulthrop, Gianfranco Angellino?

Craig Daymon

I can't say I recall any turnings by Alby Hall, but I cannot think of any piece by either Moulthrop (which one?) or Angellino that put me in mind of what I see in those manhole covers. Angellino's work, from what I've seen, is much more refined and polished. When I see the manhole coveres, I picture something that has a more industrial look to it, maybe like Vessery's, "Junkyard Ball". Still, everyone might see them differently.

I can imagine doing platters that are turned and burned to look very much like an interesting manhole cover from different major cities around the world.

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#5

Steven Antonucci

Repetition of form within form

steven antonucci

Moulthrop did the sliced in epoxy. Angellino did his repetition with some negative space. If you factor in the industrial aspect, you have something new(ish)... steampunk maybe?

Which just goes to show that two people can look at the same object and see something completely different. I looked at the picture and saw the repurposing of the round forms within a broader space and the negative space in between...and you saw industrial. How cool is that?

Wonder what you and I missed?

S

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#6

Re: Repetition of form within form

Craig Daymon

Yes, obviously. I was looking at each of the manhole covers as individual inspirations with the patterns on them. (Though I very much like the look of a driveway made of a large number of them.) Of course, if you were burning a pattern on a turning and made that pattern of similar, yet different images (like manhole covers) it would make for an interesting piece. One that when viewed from a distance would have a diferent appeal than when viewed from up close.

It is interesting that you again mention Moulthrop as a single individual. When I look at the work of Ed, Matt and Phil Moulthrop, I do see very little to differentiate them. I've seen rooms decorated with pieces from them that make for nice decor, but I've never been a fan of their work. Just personal opinion.

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#7

Steven Antonucci

On Moulthrop ...

steven antonucci

I see the three of them more as a "studio" producing work rather than original artists. Just like Sam Maloof had people working for him in his shop, I see those $40,000 rockers as being Maloof Studio pieces because he didn't make them. Did he work on them? Absolutely. Was it a collaboration? No, not really...because it was his design. But could he ever have made as many as he did on his own without the help of the other people in the studio... no way.

The three generations have all basically worked the same way having learned from the prior. The work is not very distinguishable from one Moulthrop to another, so I didn't bother to credit whichever one of them did it. Not a wrong and right thing... but I do believe it is different.

If you wanted to try a "manhole piece", there are so many ways you could tackle it... it boggles the mind.

S

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#8

Re: Repetition of form within form

phillip medghalchi

Craig, hwo many hours are you intending to put into it, copying the manholes of different cities? Then again why manholes and not soemthing more meaningful with the same idea of different circles? I fi were you putting in hours uinot a design I'd create something dcept.ifferent with a different concept. Just my two pennies in the thought.

hopefully, my thoughts won't raise an animosity issue here, just my opinion as another member of this forum. I left another forum just for the reason that it became more of the vendor sites than the actual turners.

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#9

Re: Repetition of form within form *LINK*

Craig Daymon

What is it you percieve as more meaningful? Cave painting drawings like Molly Winton does? Feathers or leaves like Vessery does? Soup cans like Warhol? (No disrespect to any of the artists mentioned.)

Not all of those covers are worth replicating, but some (older ones) have real character and were created back when there was an effort to add art to even the most mudane. They also speak to the town from which they came with some sort of labelling to indicate it. I'm picturing the dish of the platter as replicating the manhole cover and a lip/rim burned with street scenes, possibly appropriate to the same era as the manhole cover.

I can also imagine a box with a manhole cover lid that requires two keys to open, in the same fashion that real covers have keys inserted to use as handles.

If you really want to see how far the art of manhole covers can go, check out the covers in Japan. Granted, these lack the industrial edge that appeals to me, but these are very artistic.


Manhole covers of Japan

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#10

Steven Antonucci

If I lived in Japan, I'd collect manhole covers

steven antonucci

Freakin' awesome.

Nuff said.

S

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#11

Steven Antonucci

How many hours question...

steven antonucci

If you need to ask that question, you probably shouldn't start. Best work is always when time passes without account, and you are working with passion. Manhole covers, feathers, whatever...

S

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#12

Re: Repetition of form within form

phillip Medghalchi

Craig, I didn't mean to burst your bubbles. I appreciate it that you showed the Japanese manhole cover, they don't compare to the ugly ones we got in San Antonio. I don't care to look at the ones here (San Antonio) they have no artistic designs in them. Now the other thing I may not have understood is that you really mean to utilize a real manhole cover and then make a box around it or just to replicate the design off it? Utilizing the main manhole with all that weight is a different story and would take a hefty box to be turned to hold all that weight. On the other hands, you make what strikes your fancy. I just expressed my take on it. We don't have to agree on the same subject. And, if it did offend you then that was not meant for the post.

Look at the Japanese one don't they look colorful and attractive in design Vs. the ones in that picture? Now, we are talking different taste.

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: If I lived in Japan, I'd collect manhole cover

Mike Stafford

Funny that you mention collecting manhole covers.

Around here people are doing just that. They are collecting manhole covers, drainage grates alongside the curb and all sorts of things like copper pipe from under your house, aluminum gutters and downspouts. One guy I heard about had the aluminum siding collected right off of his house. Shoot there are even some avid collectors that chop into your heat pump with an axe and collect the copper condensing coils. We had all three heat pumps at our church collected.

My understanding is that the people doing the collecting are pickers and the art ends up at a gallery called a metal recycling plant. :(

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#14

Steven Antonucci

double your money on a penny

Steven Antonucci

Government had to make it illegal to melt them when copper prices rose above melt value. Nickels are worth about $.07...

But, if you can get the five finger discount, it is all profit...

S

Re: I think there is a turning here somewhere *LINK*

#15

Re: Repetition of form within form

Craig Daymon

No manhole covers for box lids. (That would be one big box.) I meant making a box with a lid that looks like a manhole cover and turning/carving some wooden "keys" (handles) that would be inserted into keyholes to make it easier to lift out the lid. Might even be able to turn the box so it looks like a T section of pipe, capping the opposite ends and putting the turned cover lid in the perpendicular end. Probably need to make a little cradle to hold it, or put it into a section of burl and make it look unearthed.

Could also carve a little alligator to glue inside the box.