I'm looking to spend my tax refund on a new lathe and could use some recommendations. I currently have a Jet midi lathe and I find it lacks in a few areas. Particularly, I can not turn wide platters and bowls due to too small a swing. I also don't like having to move the belt to change speed ranges.
I would like:
1) ability to turn platters of at least 16" diameter, or a few inches bigger.
2) electronic variable speed
3) reverse direction of motor
4) not have to move belt among pulleys
I do not turn long spindles so a long bed is not necessary. I'm also not a pro so I don't need any of those uber pricey models. 220v is acceptable.
It sounds like what you need is a Powermatic 3520 lathe.
All of your desiderata items are met in this lathe - it is arguably one of the most popular (if not THE most popular) 'big' lathes out there.
You'll get 20" of swing, sliding head, electronic variable speed, two speed ranges, long enough bed for most spindles, easily convertible into a short-bed lathe, tailstock & banjo with very smooth operation, and enough weight to make most people happy.
If you can live with a smaller swing, the Jet 1642 (16" swing) is also among the best values for the new lathe dollar. (you can go 1.5 HP at 110V, or 2 HP at 220V).
Lots of opinions out there - now you have mine....
Enjoy my Vega 2600. Able to turn large platters,bowls etc. Small foot print, takes up less floor space and able to turn hollow forms standing at end of lathe.
at least once. Folks recommend the DVR all the time, I hate it. It is so distracting to me to have to stand there and hold the button down to change speeds. The headstock on the Powermatic is a HUGE block. Maybe your technique would not work well on it. I love my Oneway, but now that machines have sliding headstocks, I would consider one of those. Did you mention budget? I've purchased cars that cost way less than the big lathes now. I sure wouldn't buy a car without driving it. Anyway, call a local AAW club and do some visiting before making the big investment.
I am in the sliding headstock group, and dial a speed. The DVR, while a nice lathe for the money just doesn't work for me. The speed changes are way too slow, and the pivoting headstock is way more cumbersome than the sliding headstock. That would leave the PM, or the Jet, and preferably the 2 hp, 220 volt models. They have a lot more mass than the Nova as well. I had a 3520 A for almost 8 years before stepping up to a Robust.
I have a Powermatic, a DVR and a Jet 1642 1.5 HP. I never have been worried about the ramping speed of the DVR and got used to it so quickly to make it a non-factor. It can be wired for 115 V or 220 V and comes in a 20" (I believe the 20" version only comes in 220 V) and 16" version. The Jet 1642 is a very nice lathe that Like its big brother the Powermatic has a sliding head, variable speed, two speed ranges and the only complaints that I have heard are about its banjo (has not bothered me and it also comes in a 2HP 220 V version). The Powermatic is as stated probably the best bang for the buck of any lathe out there, weight and power sliding headstock etc. The important thing for me with these lathes is that all three are cast iron and cast iron is what I like. The Jet and the 16" DVR are both a hair under $2000 at the moment. the 24" DVR is slightly over $3000 and right now the Powermatic can be had for $3,399. If you can afford it the Powermatic is hard to beat but myself any of the three that you could afford will work. If I ever get another lathe it will be a Vicmarc.
All good recommendations here but find someone with the lathe you think you want to buy and try it out first.
I went with DVR XP (after trying one) because of my shed size and lack of 220v. The swivel head helps me because there just isn't room for me to turn off the end of the lathe like you would with a sliding head lathe.
I use the preset speed capability to put in the speeds I most commonly use and that makes it a breeze to change speeds. A slight bump up or down is also no issue...for me. It's all in what you get used to.
IF I had an actual shop I'll be looking for a PM given the current pricing but that's because of overall swing rather than any issues with my DVR.
I purchased the JET 1642 (120V) a couple years back and have not regretted the purchase. I have turned large platters and bowls. The only caveat would be if you plan on really deep 16" bowls, you can bog down the motor on an aggressive cut.
Some good suggestions so far. I want a long bed. I start and end everything I do between centers. My bed is 7 feet long, love it!! My advice would be to spend more money then you think you need now. You will grow into the better lathe. It is better to get it now than to have to upgrade again, likely sooner then later.
I would recommend a Powermatic 3520 even though I don't have one myself.
The John C. Campbell Folk School has PM 3520's and they hold up to constant use and abuse that you as hobbyist turner are unlikely to match. The 3520's at the Folk School are used 8-10 hours a day, 5 days a week, sometimes on weekends for 50+ weeks a year. They hold up well and are used to turn everything from large bowls and hollow forms to delicate spindles and birdhouse ornaments.
From my experience they are great machines for the money.
If you have the cash I would go for one of the Robust machines. They are all superb machines and I have yet to hear a complaint from someone who owns one. I have only turned on the American Beauty and it is a superb machine. It will be the next lathe I buy if and when I need another.
How do you do that when you don't live near a club or store. That's why so many people rely on us. I will let anyone come to my shop and try out my two lathes for fit and finish if they want but of course you probably need to live within an hour or so from me to do so.
Just in case anyone is, I live 2 miles off I40, exit 280 and have a Powermatic 3520A and a Delta 46-460.
If you have to go by internet forum recommendations, it's like trying to decide from any reviews on the internet. Same item by two people will get 5 stars from one person, 1 star from the next. I said I hate the DVR, the next guy loves them. So you suggest he makes a decision from that? Travel to a Woodcraft, a regional symposium, or I still say contact the nearest club.
Dick I highly recommend traveling to a club or store to look at lathes but I realize that it just isn't possible for a lot of people. so all we can do is give them the best advice we can. And yes you do get a lot of opposite opinions.
I belong to a club that probably covers all of the "big lathes" that are out there, and it would still be nearly impossible to get any meaningful time on all of them. The things that probably matter the most in evaluating the lathes can actually be gathered (with a grain of salt) via a forum like WC.
1.) How does the vendor respond when there is a problem? How many problems are people having with the lathes?
2.) What opinions do people have about what is important in the platform? If you turn a lot on many different lathes, what irks you about one vs. the other and most importantly why?
By gathering the info, the buyer can think about things that they probably wouldn't otherwise consider. Where the handles are, how close you can get to the work, and what access from the headstock side feels like are all things that make me wonder if some of the lathe manufacturers have ever turned? If you cut with the handle low, you probably hit the tool handle on the banjo handle all of the time.