Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Lesson Learned

Posts

Lesson Learned

#1

Lesson Learned

Dale Bonertz

I have done quite a bit of coring with the Mcnaughton tool. I have worn out and I have ruined blades. Inevitably it is large honey locust when I ruin a tool. At the transition point from the side to bottom, where you start cutting into end grain, is where the catch wants to grab. I will no longer core honey locust using the jumbo blades (the only ones I ruin). All other blades seem fine but the density of honey locust and the resultant stress put on the jumbo blades is just to much. I have been successful with honey locust and the jumbo blades but also have ruined to many blades - just not worth it. BTW I have the tool height adjusted correctly, I have played with many different speeds and rate of entry, opened kerf (made it worse), waggle method and etc. Some woods just don't want to be cored when they are that big and dense.

Lesson learned, anyone else have a lesson learned to share.

Re: Lesson Learned

#2

Re: Lesson Learned

ron bauer

My last broken knife was the large shallow knife, at the same point as yours, in a huge hard maple block. While it is probably well known to other "corers" I have started bringing the tail stock up while coring. It is used every time I can depending on size. If they are too small and the handle interferes with the tail wheel I will go so far as to remove the hand wheel becauise I feel it is that inportant. This has resulted in a substantial increase in success and decrease in stress. Some will say that I am doing something wrong but I have tried all the recommended techniques and was still having trouble until I started doing this.

Re: Lesson Learned

#3

Re: Lesson Learned

John lucas

That why I wrote the article on bending your own tools. I broke mine and had to make another. The longer mcnaughton tools flex too much or something and reallfight you when you get deep

Re: Lesson Learned

#4

Re: Lesson Learned

John lucas

Ron have you ever tried a morse taper extension in the tailstock it extends the reach of the quill about 4"

Re: Lesson Learned

#5

Re: Lesson Learned

ron bauer

John, Thats a great idea. I am sorry to say that I have one and it never crossed my mind to use it. Thanks for the idea. R.

Re: Lesson Learned

#6

Re: Lesson Learned

ron bauer

John, Would it be bold of me to ask where I might see your article? I have thought about this but could not decide on the steel to use (amongst others issues). TIA. R.

Re: Lesson Learned

#7

Re: Lesson Learned

robo hippy

If John doesn't beat me to it, it was in Woodturning Design a month or so ago.

Dale, I haven't turned much honey locust, but have turned a fair amount of black locust. I have never FUBARed ('fouled' up beyond all repair/recognition) a blade. You know there is flex in the blades, and flex in the tool rest. Consider the lever forces on a large blade when extended. If you have ever tried to remove the stub that is left when coring, you will note that the wood has no problem pushing a blade down an inch or more. Of course, this is worse with more dense woods. I am pretty sure this is what is happening. You end up with a scraper well below center. Add to that the vertical blade in a round kerf, and it all adds up. You can raise the tool rest some more, or if you have full length handles and are VERY CAREFUL, you can lower the handle and raise the tip slightly. You are experienced enough to feel when it starts to get really grabby.

robo hippy

Re: Lesson Learned

#8

Re: Lesson Learned

Bill Gasper

Dale,

I have cored a quite a few bowls and a lot of honey locust using the Oneway system. By far, locust has been the most difficult with numerous catches irregardless of what I do to prevent it. Haven't had troubles with any of the other woods I've cored. Never did figure out how to eliminate the catches but now all my locust is cored.

Bill

Re: Lesson Learned

#9

Steven Antonucci

Cold setting steel

steven antonucci

I have to assume that you mean that the blade gets bent or twisted, and not sheared off in any way? That would be a catch to end all catches.

If your blade gets twisted or bent, You can probably cold set it back to "close enough" to factory if you have a vise, a wrench and a long enough pipe. If you think about the enormous amount of force required to deform steel at that thickness, well, it's going to take that much to put it back. The long pipe on the end of a wrench will give you leverage. I have taken the kinks out of them in the past, and with a 15 year old mowing rocks in the yard, I've used this method to straighten out lawnmower blades too.

S

Re: Lesson Learned

#10

Re: Cold setting steel

John Lucas

Steve Mine broke. The actual shaft, about 3" back from the tip. The metal appears to be cast because of the way it looks when you look at the break. It is very springy and hard to bend. That's why I made my replacements out of steel.

Re: Lesson Learned

#11

Re: Cold setting steel

Ralph Lindberg

John

I don't believe the blades are cast, simply because the blades don't behave like cast steel. My guess (and it's a guess only, since I have never looked that a broken blade) is that it's a low carbon cold worked steel. That type of steel often brakes roughly with a grey "cast" to the break area.

I say this because you can bend the blades, you can't bend things like (cheap) cast tool-rests.

Re: Lesson Learned

#12

Re: Lesson Learned

Ralph Lindberg

emm... I may have to order that issue (I didn't renew last year)

Re: Lesson Learned

#13

Re: Lesson Learned

Dale Bonertz

Steve,

That is the method I use to straighten or should I say rebend them.

Robo,

You can raise the turret or as you mention raise the tip but in a round kerf you can only go so far before the top of the blade starts rubbing on the edge of the kerf. I am sure what you are saying is correct but locust is so dense it is hard to get it high enough compared to the downward stress on the blade. I have successfully cored large locust but it is always a guessing game if it will catch or not. So I have decided to be happy with a small core or two and leave the second to largest core alone and turn it out.

John,

I do not subscribe to that magazine. Can you send me a copy of your article. I am very interested in reading it.

Thanks to all.

Re: Lesson Learned

#14

Steven Antonucci

Agree, Ralph!

steven antonucci

If you get the heat treat wrong in the steel, it will be very brittle. I forge hook tools and a simple tap on the table will snap them if I don't anneal them.

S