Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Trying to hone

Posts

Trying to hone

#1

Trying to hone

Jack Savona

I'm at the point in my tool use that I'm ready to hone between my CBN wheel sharpenings. The question is: What do I put on the stone? Saliva? WD-40? 3-in-1 oil? A pencil eraser?

I have seen demonstrators use saliva (remembering to raise their face shield) and other turners use oil on an "oil" stone and water on a "water" stone.

What has been your experience for effective honing? And what kinds of stone, abrasive, and grit do you use?

Re: Trying to hone

#2

Re: Trying to hone

John Lucas

I use the Trend diamond hone and just put a dab of water on it. It's a little expensive but has a 5 year warranty. I went through the less expensive diamond hones pretty fast. They just don't hold up. I've used this for over a year now and it still cuts like new.

Re: Trying to hone

#3

Re: Trying to hone

Michael Gibson

John while you are right that the Trend diamond hones are superior to others, water is the wrong thing to use on Trends because of the way they are made and will void your 5yr warranty.

Michael

Re: Trying to hone

#4

Malcolm Ray

Re: Trying to hone

Malcolm Ray

I have one of Alan Lacers diamond hones,had it for years and still as good as new,just use a toothbrush and some PB Blaster on it once in a while,you will pay more for two or three lesser ones and wear them out.......and the radiused edges work great on carving tools and inside of gouges.....you wont regret spending the extra for it....

Re: Trying to hone

#5

Re: Trying to hone

terry quiram

I have Lacers diamond slip and use it dry.

Re: Trying to hone

#6

Alan Lacer's hone

Jorge

Is a sound investment, had mine for years and still going strong. Now and then clean it with some dish soap and a tooth brush.

If you want a mirror finish strop it with either the green or the white compounds, stay away from the rouge, it is for soft metals.

Re: Trying to hone

#7

Why hone?

Dick Coers

One pass on the CBN and you are back to turning. Now making a burr is a different story, but if you are looking for sharp, stay on the wheel. You won't loose much steel if you just make one pass on the wheel.

Re: Trying to hone

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Waste of time....

Jesper, Denmark

Honing anything other than a skew really does not help.

I am of the opinion that the burr actually helps in cutting, but have not yet found a reasonable way of representing it graphically so that it becomes understandable.

Re: Trying to hone

#9

Re: Why hone?

John Lucas

I'm finding after using the CBN wheel for a about 6 months or more that it removes a lot of metal. I grind very light. On my 100 grit white wheel I barely noticed the gouge getting shorter. After just 6 months or so on the 180 grit CBN I have noticed that my gouge is getting noticeably shorter.

I bring that up because a friend who bought one about the same time I got mine asked me if I thought the wheels were aggressive. He said he seemed to be removing a lot of metal. I thought this was interesting because I had just come to the same conclusion a week or so before.

I've never honed my gouges much except when traveling. It was usually just about as quick to hit the grinder and there was little chance of rounding the edge since I use jigs or tool rests for most sharpening. I also like a short main bevel and it's harder to keep from rounding the edge with a hone on a bevel that is that short.

Re: Trying to hone

#10

I agree and dissagree

John Lucas

Yea I know, I should have been a politician. The reason I say this is, a honed edge is sharper and if you believe the results of a few sort of scientific studies holds an edge longer. I can prove the sharper theory because I often will use the hone when cutting difficult wood. I notice the tool is not cutting as well, I sharpen on the grinder and it usually improves however some woods just need more. I hone the edge and it almost always cuts cleaner.

Now here's the problem. When I hone an edge it's very difficult to keep the hone perfectly flat. consequently after enough honings it doesn't seem to be as controllable or simply takes too long to hone because the micro bevel you put on it has become large enough to take a lot of passes with the hone. When you have to spend too much time honing to get the good edge you round it even more. Then because it's rounded you have to take off more metal when you go to the grinder to get it back to normal. So in that instance I'm not sure it saves metal. For me the jury is still out on that part of the issue.

Now when I hone using green compound on a leather wheel it's a different story. You have to do it very frequently because it's simply a much finer grit, but the edge is maintained very accurately and can be done many times before needing to go to the grinder. It is a super sharp edge but must be re honed very frequently to maintain this edge. My friend who teaches carousel horse carving does it all by hand. He told me he almost never has to go to the grinder because any time it seems like he has to work at cutting he touches them up on the green leather hone. It's harder for turners to get this feel because the wood is being forced passed the tool and you can't feel it like you can when your hand carving.

Now I won't argue that when turning green wood, especially on all but the final passes, honing may not be much good or improve the cut enough to be worth it. John Jordan uses a 60 grit wheel and his pieces are very nice right off the tool. However if you take that final pass on a freshly sharpened tool that has been honed most of the time it will leave a cleaner finish. However you need good tool control because if you go back and shear scrape in some cases you make the finish courser.

As always I'd like to hear other opinions on anything I say because all that I have learned is from personal experience and not scientific in any way so my conclusions are definitely not that last word. I learn a great deal from these discussions.

Re: Trying to hone

#11

Bill Blasic

Re: Why hone?

Bill Blasic

John,

I have found just the opposite, I feel the CBN wheel takes of less metal than the stone. Just one very light pass on the CBN which I could never seem to do on the stone. Maybe because the grinder with the two 180 grit CBNs is only used for my Thompson gouges and the jigs are never moved or changed.

Bill

Re: Trying to hone

#12

Re: I agree and dissagree

ron bauer

To hone or not to hone ....that is the question. First of all I am in the small minority here because I use a 180 diamond wheel to sharpen. It has been in use since Jan 2009 and shows no sign of needing replacement even though I probably over sharpen. I do use a light oil when sharpening but it does not make a mess. The first or subsequent shaping is done on a white wheel. I have two grinds and thus have two wolverine holders that are never changed. This takes only a very light cut to raise the burr so I suspect that my gouges will last a very very long time. Now, to the real question.

I lightly remove the burr which forms on the inside of the flute with one of those diamond "sticks" that are used for touching up fishing hooks. Of course this now moves the burr to the outside of the flute, albeit it is now a smaller burr. I then take one more very, very, light touch with the same diamond stick on the outside to remove that burr which probably creates a miniscule micro bevel which does not seem to affect the feel. I used to hone on a leather strop but found that my heavy hand rounded the edge. All of this takes less time to do than to write. So I guess I don't, or at least only rarely, hone. This of course is IMHO.

Re: Trying to hone

#13

Steven Antonucci

Yeah, maybe not?

steven antonucci

Honing is a choice (I am pro-hone).

1.) Better edges last longer. John said it, and there is evidence supporting this. So not only sharper, but longer lasting.

2.) Honing is faster that resharpening. I keep one in my pocket, and before you could even get over to the grinder, I would be done. It only takes one stroke to resurface a tool if you are doing it right (which is a big IF)

3.) Waste less metal than a grinder (no matter what grinding method you use). @600 grit, in one pass, I can restore an edge 4-5x before I regrind my tool (because I use very small bevels). If I didn't grind off the heels, I would probably get 50X out of it.

It is a choice, but evidence support that the time is not wasted.

S

Re: Trying to hone

#14

I do occasionally "touch up" the ......

JamieDonaldson

...bevel edges on my roughing and bowl gouges with a Lacer diamond hone. It usually extends trips to the CBN wheel and saves a bit of time and metal. ;)

Re: Trying to hone

#15

Re: Yeah, maybe not?

ron bauer

Perhaps I am confused with semantics. I thought honing was done with a strop and compound. I do use a fine diamond for touch ups to the edge between trips to the wheel.

Re: Trying to hone

#16

Steven Antonucci

Honing means to refine the edge

steven antonucci

A grinder has an 80 grit wheel, leaving an 80 grit edge.

A Tormek is somewhere between 220 and 1000 grit, but usually towards 220 unless you maintain it religiously.

A red DMT hone is 600 grit, give or take. Green DMTs are 1200. Touching up the edge is honing. I've also used a 400 grit paper glued to a flat piece of MDF when I couldn't find my hones.

You can further refine the edge with rouge on a board, but a strop on the edge tends to round it. A hard, flat surface is almost mandatory. I usually use the red DMT as is a good balance between speed and effectiveness. Green one takes more time, and clogs faster.

S

Re: Trying to hone

#17

Thanks everyone for your responses.


Re: Trying to hone

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Trying to hone

Keith Tompkins

HI Jack, I also use a diamond hone with water with a bit of dish detergent added...I feel it helps float away debris from honing. I use the bench-size diamond hone, and always hone drawing the tool towards me..the handle is facing me, honing toward the edge. Never back and forth except on the narrow sides of a skew, and never honing in the cutting direction. Many turners hone with a credit card hone, back and forth. I don't believe it works as well, because of the tendency to rock the hone against the edge. Don't think honing matters? Try carving with a freshly ground chisel. Nearly worthless. Then hone with a diamond stone followed by stropping. Yeah it works on carving, but how about turning? Try it....you will become a believer.