I retired on Feb. 1, and had a meeting yesterday to roll over my 401k to my credit union. I just really appreciate having a person to talk to instead of punching codes and speaking to a robot like I had to do with the company fund. Well they told me that they were rolling over the 401k money and a check would be going to the credit union, and they would also be striking me a check from the old fund they had years ago! It was after taxes, so it's all mine! I forgot completely about the way that went years ago. It's not a huge amount, but it will be so difficult to put that back into an investment. Wouldn't a call to Robust be so much more fun? Come on guys, who's with me on this? Oneway 2436 on one side of the basement, Robust American Beauty on the other? Decadence at it's best, or just too fun to describe?
Dick, you wrote: "It was after taxes, so it's all mine! I forgot completely about the way that went years ago". I used to be in insurance business, and helped lots of folks with this. I would hold off on that thought because the min. they cut that check they have to report it on your income. On the other hands that was part of your retirement and it was not supposed to be cashed in unless I am wrong. If they paid taxes on it then it is at your current tax rate and the whole purpose of the 401k is to keep uncle Sam away from the growth on the money.
Now, going back to what you want to do and buy a Robust, it's all tempting, however, if you are at my age and not quite 65 yrs yet then we have to worry about who the heck is going to pay to carry us though the yeas ahead. I don't have that much faith in the system that they would be able to pay all the retirees, So that's my two cents in the game.
I know it's very tempting , but i am sure at the end you will make the right decision for your own financial situation.
Oh, BTW, did I mention that for you to have the Robust, then your other better half would want the Diamond. Now, you got something to ponder about.
Congrats on the retirement, but if you already own a Oneway 2436, and you are happy with it, why would you want a second full sized lathe? I am a fan of the little floor space that I have in the shop, and until I get rid of the things I don't use, I am not bringing in another thing. A second lathe would only make sense if you taught frequently (in my mind). I don't even clean around the one lathe I own today, and to be honest, it is MY Nova 3000, and I consider it an old friend? (...but no, it doesn't have a name...)
If you have the sudden urge to spend money on yourself in the shop, why not travel to a symposium? Or take a class with someone? Doing things is better than owning things.
Now, if you are selling the Oneway to make space for the Robust, that is a another story
Personally.......if it were me, and it would not hurt me or my family, I would do it. The features of the American Beauty make it a really desirable lathe, and they won't get cheaper as the money that is being printed will not gain in value, but only lose some value. The adaptors for the spindle sizes might be a little additional unless you can have Robust make the spindle in the same size as your Oneway.........minor issue, however.
I have turned on a Robust AB........thanks to a friend who invited me to his shop for a day of turning.............that is one sweet machine!
Dick, I say go for it. I have the 2436 and love it. Brent English and Mike Stafford talked me into buying the Robust Liberty at the 2011 NC Symposium and I have never regretted it. Of course, my girlfriend has claimed it for her own. I do get to turn on it occasionally.
....Stubby 750 (Studly!) bit the dust after 11 yrs. of flawless service, and Bill the dealer will not return home from a cruise until Mar. 9th! I've had to resort to turning on the old Woodfast 1 HP DC, and that reminded me why I bought the Stubby with 2 HP AC! So at least I have the backup lathe, but I've been practicing making lighter cuts on smaller projects, just like in the old days before Studly arrived. There is some truth that a better lathe will make you a better turner, and a larger more powerful lathe will certainly make you a more aggressive turner, but I call that efficiency!
Sorry Jamie, I can't find any way to agree with this.
I know fellows with more money than brains (or talent, for that matter), and they think they are good turners because they own the 2436 with all the trimmings.
Just ain't so, and never will be.
I am convinced that a highly skilled turner with a 50-year-old Delta or a ShopSmith with a 5/8" arbor will produce better work 100% of the time than the turner who thinks spending more money makes him a better turner.
I would agree that a competent turner who's been limited by a mediocre lathe can do better work on a Robust or a OneWay, but that's because they have the skills to grow into the better machine -- and I assume that's what you meant. Having one does not make them a good turner. Only practice and dedication -- and some innate talent to start with -- will do that.
I don't mean to jump all over your response, but I really do know a half-dozen people who could have saved themselves some serious money by just staying with a Craftsman or Jet lathe, but now they think they are something special with their $8,000 lathe setup, and the sad truth is they have never learned to pay attention, nor put in the effort to ever be good turners.
Owning a Porsche will not make one a better driver, either!
I have 5 lathes in my turning shop, all cast iron as that is what I prefer. If you can afford it by all means get that American Beauty and enjoy the hell out of it as it is a great lathe no doubt. Whether or not it makes you a better turner matters not but everyday that you turn on the lights they will have a tough time wiping that smile off your face. Go for it!
Brad, Have you considered the personal joy in using a fine machine? Personally, it brought me a lot of joy after purchasing my Oneway in 1998. Isn't that what a hobby is about? Personal joy? Who cares what a person choses to turn on. Same as your analogy for cars. Sounds like you have had some bad experiences with someone bragging about their machine. Some will find pleasure with the frugality of getting a great turned piece off their Grandfather's Homecraft lathe, others will enjoy the adventure on a $10,000 lathe. You have also discounted the adventure of trying some advanced techniques. Who wants to try a bigger natural edge piece on a Shopsmith? Wouldn't that present an element of danger? As often stated, it's the journey, not the destination.
I just don't follow the desire to own both? They are essentially peer lathes... and neither one really gives me additional capability. A mini lathe is at least portable if you travel and demo...
I think lathes are viewed differently by us than other shop equipment? Does anyone own a second table saw or planer? If I won the lottery, I would dump all of my shop equipment for a new shop...except for my lathe. I might consider getting a second lathe after a windfall, but like I said...that is my Nova...