problem solved, at least for now (long)
GaryG in MD
I use a CA finish on my pens. I use the Stick Fast kit and approach.
[This involves sanding to 600, applying thin CA and then 6 coats of medium
CA, followed by sanding with Abranet 400 and polishing with one or two creams depending on the level of shine desired.] Early on, it appeared to work great, and I was quite happy with it.
After a series of successes, however, I began to have a problem with the finish getting spiderweb cracks.
There are a number of ways that cracks can be generated (using regular bushings for finishing and cracking them off, not sanding the finish off the ends, careless sanding of the ends, pressing parts together too hard, etc.), but to the best of my knowledge, I was avoiding all those and doing everything right.
I read all the info online and found that lots of other people are having the same problem with the CA finish cracking. Answers to the question of "why" were always guesses, some better than others, and few if any actual hard solutions were reported. Frustration caused my output to grind to a halt.
But then I had a need to provide a timely pen for a grandchild, so I made a hypothesis and acted on it.
I'm here to report an apparent solution, based on a small sample of two successes (after previous four increasingly bad failures in a row).
The Stick Fast procedure calls for the application of the medium CA directly over the sealing coat of thin CA. As with many finishes, multiple coats of CA do not "meld" or "melt" together -- they remain independent layers that must adhere to one another. When I sanded the finish off the previous failure, I found that the cracks went all the way down to the wood (or to the thin CA?), as closely as I could judge. It struck me that the problem might be that the medium CA was not sticking to the thin CA. In my recent pens, I had gotten into a habit of "sealing them better" and using two coats of thin instead of one. Hmmm....
OK, so I carefully sanded off the spiderweb with 150 grit, sanded it back to 600, cleaned it with acetone, put on the thin CA, and misted it with accelerator (that's part of the standard "book" procedure) to cure it. THEN (simple new procedure, and the point of this post), I sanded the thin CA surface very gently but thoroughly with 1500 MicroMesh. I cleaned that with a dry paper towel and then completed the standard procedure with 6 accelerated coats of medium CA (which only takes a total of about 60 seconds). I let that cure for 2-3 hours and Abranetted and polished it. Voila! A perfect finish. Zero cracks.
That was three days ago -- no cracks have formed since. I repeated the procedures on another pen and achieved the same success. So I think that's the problem. The medium CA is not adhering to the shiny thin CA. A couple seconds of sanding the shiny, cured thin CA surface with MicroMesh 1500 solves the problem. Anyway, it works for me. So I'm happy and back on track.
Yes, I understand that, in theory, the same thing could happen between the layers of medium CA. But it doesn't -- perhaps because it is naturally roughened during application or because for each coat of medium CA, I purposely make one pass back across the blank with the applicator (a folded paper towel) before accelerating, and that dulls it slightly.
Parting thoughts: This is a tricky finish to use, and, as with anything else we do, there are many ways to do it wrong and get bad results. But if you figure out all the don'ts and do's, it yields a really nice, quick, reproducible finish that is durable and resists fingerprinting better than any other. The level of shine can be adjusted, if desired, with a grade of MicroMesh of your choice.
...GG



