Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

problem solved, at least for now (long)

Posts

problem solved, at least for now (long)

#1

problem solved, at least for now (long)

GaryG in MD

I use a CA finish on my pens. I use the Stick Fast kit and approach.

[This involves sanding to 600, applying thin CA and then 6 coats of medium

CA, followed by sanding with Abranet 400 and polishing with one or two creams depending on the level of shine desired.] Early on, it appeared to work great, and I was quite happy with it.

After a series of successes, however, I began to have a problem with the finish getting spiderweb cracks.

There are a number of ways that cracks can be generated (using regular bushings for finishing and cracking them off, not sanding the finish off the ends, careless sanding of the ends, pressing parts together too hard, etc.), but to the best of my knowledge, I was avoiding all those and doing everything right.

I read all the info online and found that lots of other people are having the same problem with the CA finish cracking. Answers to the question of "why" were always guesses, some better than others, and few if any actual hard solutions were reported. Frustration caused my output to grind to a halt.

But then I had a need to provide a timely pen for a grandchild, so I made a hypothesis and acted on it.

I'm here to report an apparent solution, based on a small sample of two successes (after previous four increasingly bad failures in a row).

The Stick Fast procedure calls for the application of the medium CA directly over the sealing coat of thin CA. As with many finishes, multiple coats of CA do not "meld" or "melt" together -- they remain independent layers that must adhere to one another. When I sanded the finish off the previous failure, I found that the cracks went all the way down to the wood (or to the thin CA?), as closely as I could judge. It struck me that the problem might be that the medium CA was not sticking to the thin CA. In my recent pens, I had gotten into a habit of "sealing them better" and using two coats of thin instead of one. Hmmm....

OK, so I carefully sanded off the spiderweb with 150 grit, sanded it back to 600, cleaned it with acetone, put on the thin CA, and misted it with accelerator (that's part of the standard "book" procedure) to cure it. THEN (simple new procedure, and the point of this post), I sanded the thin CA surface very gently but thoroughly with 1500 MicroMesh. I cleaned that with a dry paper towel and then completed the standard procedure with 6 accelerated coats of medium CA (which only takes a total of about 60 seconds). I let that cure for 2-3 hours and Abranetted and polished it. Voila! A perfect finish. Zero cracks.

That was three days ago -- no cracks have formed since. I repeated the procedures on another pen and achieved the same success. So I think that's the problem. The medium CA is not adhering to the shiny thin CA. A couple seconds of sanding the shiny, cured thin CA surface with MicroMesh 1500 solves the problem. Anyway, it works for me. So I'm happy and back on track.

Yes, I understand that, in theory, the same thing could happen between the layers of medium CA. But it doesn't -- perhaps because it is naturally roughened during application or because for each coat of medium CA, I purposely make one pass back across the blank with the applicator (a folded paper towel) before accelerating, and that dulls it slightly.

Parting thoughts: This is a tricky finish to use, and, as with anything else we do, there are many ways to do it wrong and get bad results. But if you figure out all the don'ts and do's, it yields a really nice, quick, reproducible finish that is durable and resists fingerprinting better than any other. The level of shine can be adjusted, if desired, with a grade of MicroMesh of your choice.

...GG

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#2

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

Philip F Duffy

Gary, Try using closed cell foam- - the packing material for electronics - to apply the CA and let us all know what you think. Philip

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#3

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long) *LINK*

Mike Brazeau

Sounds just like crazing in plastics. Decades ago, I sold laboratory supplies and equipment and it was often a problem with clear styrene products like petri dishes. There is a good discussion of crazing on wikipedia. Is it really necessary to build up a thick coat of CA? I only do the occasional pen and use perhaps a half dozen coats of medium thin. Seems to work well and stand up to everyday use. If you think about hardwood floors, we walk on a thin layer of polyurethane and they stand up for years. A pen gets a lot less severe use.


The Joy of Wood

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#4

Mike,

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the reference. Yes, crazing appears to be what is happening, but they go all the way to the surface and can be seen as slope discontinuities in a surface reflection, so I would call them cracks too. And some "let go" as little pieces as I was sanding the crazed/cracked CA off for the redo.

You say: "Is it really necessary to build up a thick coat of CA? I only do the occasional pen and use perhaps a half dozen coats of medium thin." In my description, I said I put on 6 coats of medium CA. So I think we have a case of "six of one and half a dozen of another" here. :-)

The bottom line is that, crack or craze, it is highly undesirable, and sanding the glossy surface of the thin CA coat before applying the 6 coats of medium CA appears to solve the problem that is widely reported in the literature. ...GG

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#5

Philip,

GaryG in MD

I expect that various materials can be used to apply the CA with success.

Using plastic implies that you would continue to reuse the same surface.

I think that would be a problem because it would be contaminated with a mixture of CA at various levels of curing, and it would get hard and stiff. That's just the opposite of what's desired. IMO, what is needed for smooth application is a fresh, uncontaminated, soft, flexible absorbent surface. For each coat, I tear off the used end of the folded strip of paper towel and always use a new, fresh, soft, absorbent surface. I think that's the best way to go. ...GG

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Want more pot time??

Lyle Jamieson

If you want more work time, or "pot time" with CA?? I'm in Michigan not Colorado so I mean the right kind of pot time. Make sure to use Nitrile gloves and Webril Handi-pads. 100 percent pure cotton. They are used for optical applications. I don't remember where I got mine. I think a medical supply place. They are on eBay. For $7.00 you will get a lifetime supply. Other towels and cloths will start the curing action immediately with CA due to the contaminants. keep them in a plastic bag to keep your towels clean before use.

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: Want more pot time??

Bill Blasic

Lyle,

I'm pretty sure cotton is one of the fibers you do not want to use with CA glue. An exothermic reaction starts very fast with cotton. When I did the article on CA glue for the AAW magazine I tested this and although it did not start on fire it started smoking very fast. I'll have to look at the article.

Bill

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Want more pot time??

Lyle Jamieson

I don't remember the source for the advice, and it was a decade or more since I used CA as a finish. I remember it worked better then what I had been using, paper towel. The heat and smoke from thin CA was the problem. I didn't work with Medium CA at all, but I would think it would be even more forgiving with the thicker CA.

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#9

it's not a problem

GaryG in MD

Bill, Lyle,

This is a quick and easy (when you do it right) and durable and attractive pen finish (if you like them shiny) that does not fingerprint anywhere near as badly as shellac and wax based products.

I use brand-x paper toweling, and it works just fine with both thin and medium viscosities. No heat or "smoke" are generated from rapid polymerization. The accelerator mist is needed to get it to cure quickly enough to keep applying more coats in rapid-fire succession, as is desired. And don't forget that a spritz of accelerator is put on to cure the last coat only a few seconds before putting on the next coat, so it probably pre-accelerates the next coat regardless of the material used to apply the CA.

Even if it did/does initiate polymerization, that would be desirable for this application in which 6 coats of medium are applied in as little as 60 seconds. It's literally just swipe/spritz/tear off/ swipe/spritz/tear off/ swipe/spritz/tear off/... The "tear off" is to get a new, soft, absorbent, flexible, smooth paper towel surface so the CA goes on smoothly and doesn't build up ridges.

I think it's probably a good idea to let the CA'd blank sit and completely cure for an hour or two before sanding, but I've done it much more quickly than that with success -- but no reason to push the envelope and risk a failure if you don't have to.

...GG

Re: problem solved, at least for now (long)

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Philip,

Brad Vietje

...but the cellulose fibers in the paper towels will harden the CA, too.

I agree that a soft, clean, lint-free surface will work best, and as the CA hardens, a new surface should be used, but I think pieces of paper towels might not be the very best answer. I've used 'em, but you have to move pretty quickly, since P.T.'s are basically made of wood.

I've had pretty good results with small pieces of polyester batting used by quilters or for the insulation in comforters. I cut a bit off the mat, then fold it in half while twisting it at least 1/2 turn, then wrap the ends in masking tape to create a small applicator with a tape handle -- much like a fat little "Q-Tip". It is important -- and fairly easy -- to make sure all the loose ends of the fibers are bound up by the tape, so you don't get a bunch of them sticking to the work piece. You can get the polyester batting at a fabric store, and make up a bunch of applicators ahead of time.

Since the polyester is not made of wood fibers, it does not accelerate the hardening of the CA, like the paper towels or cotton Q-tips will. They will harden up after use, but they work pretty well.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT