As I have gotten back into turning the one of the upgrades I would like to consider is a more stable base. I have an older Rockwell lathe with the metal stand. I have a box of sand on the shelf but I still get some racking of the stand. It is held together with bolts so there are a number of pivot points. What I was thinking is a bench/stand out of maybe MDF with a built in "container" that I could fill with sand for weight and stability?
I have a Nova DVR, one of the early ones. I had some oak, Ripped into strips about two inches wide and glued it up into a "cutting board" longer than the lathes and about eighteen inches wide. I made a cabinet that has a hollow space under the head stock, sort of a vertical column. Its about twelve by sixteen and as tall as the cabinet and its filled with sand. (300 lbs?) Under the ways there are to banks of drawers, three by three, six all together with full extension 100 lb rails. There is a toe kick under the drawers with another 100 pounds of sand, and there is a space under the top that has about fifty pounds. Then there is a huge amount of stuff in the drawers. Takes a lot to get it rocking.
Cautions: Do not build it too tall. Much easier to raise the lathe than to cut the cabinet down. Put it where you want it before putting the sand in. No easy to move, although I moved mine using pipe as rollers. (Learned it back in the day when I was with the Egyptians building the pyramids.)
Also, I am not sure a cabinet with a flat top is the best design. Tends to get buried in shavings and tools and whatever. I like mine and the drawer space is a definite plus, but a really solid sturdy frame with no place to accumulate crud might be better. I have added a roll around cabinet to serve as a "butler" while I am turning and that's a good thing. If you build one with a flat top, build spacers under the lathe to allow you to easily rake the shavings out. Mine was too low. And if you have drawers, keep them closed or they fill up with shavings.
I am 6'6" so my PM3520B's factory legs are way too short. I took a 6" x 6" x 8' cut into four two foot pieces. I stacked them into sets of two fastened with 10" lag screws. Before stacking I cut mortises in the center for a 2" x 8" that connects the ends into an I---I. The lathe legs are bolted to the top of the frame. In five years of use, I have NEVER made it walk!
Barry, Your idea has spark some ideas! I think 2 cabinet "towers" filled with sand. and maybe multiple layers of 3/4" MDF for a top. I also like the drawer idea.
I will try to get you a picture later today when I am back home.
I might have the weight wrong on the sand but its a lot. There is more to this than meets the eye. Dampening the motion is more complex than it appears.
Mass/weight helps. Takes a lot of momentum to get the mass moving. But apparently things like the sand have an effect because its granular. The granular "structure" tends to absorb the vibration.
Lowering the center of gravity helps. Two ways to do that. Widen the base and move the weight lower. The stands that have the flared legs help by widening the base. But, the legs get in your way if they are too flared.
I have seen suggestions that having hardened pointed steel leveling legs help. Not sure I entirely grasp it but the idea that the points do a good job of driving the vibration into the slab.
I have also seen suggestions that you can put a vertical post up to the ceiling and have it press downward onto the lathe or stand. This might work but also has the chance of jacking up and/or damaging the ceiling.
And there are designs for a post or pole you weld to the top of the head stock with some sort of weight hanging off an arm. You move the weight and arm around until you find the sweet spot that dampens the vibration. Not sure anyone has done this or proved its worth, it sound like Internet Magic.
I have one really odd thing about my setup. Years later I added a bed extension. I did not want to rebuild the base and top. Based on a suggestion from Tim Geist who used to be the rep for Nova in WV, I bolted the extension onto the end of the bed and it just hangs out in the air. Its been that way for about five years and seems to be fine. I don't turn a lot of spindles.
Before I built my big lathe, I went to some length trying to stiffen my old PM. We have a good scrap metal yard here that will let me roam the place. I found two pieces of 1" thick plate steel already the right width, then I cut the height and bolted and bonded one to each end. I also widened the stance which helped a lot.
The best thing you can do to make a stand more rigid is to make the footprint larger. Of course everything else counts as well. You must have rigid joints and sand in a box near the bottom really helps. I put the sand in bags so that it can be easily removed if needed and it doesn't leak out.
I've built several stands for lathes before I finally got my powermatic and the larger footprint makes a huge difference. In fact one of my friends who owns a powermatic but turns really off center pieces added 6 foot thick angle iron pieces to the base. The difference was amazing. It does have a trip problem of course that you have to deal with but the difference in stability was hard to imagine.
...are using sand for ballast around machines with moving parts (esp. bearings) and electronics. Washed river gravel will do the job of adding mass and vibration abatement, yet not so easily escape containers and is more easily handled than sand. If you can't gather your own, most landscape suppliers have it available for use as ground cover, and the cost is reasonable.
OK, my qsn. is how big of a log mass are you putting on your lathe to turn and are they just a log out of balance that you didn't cut it to a round blank on the band saw? I am tryig to picture that why you folks have to go to this length to beef up the lathe. On my Nova DVR XP if it starts to vibrate then I adjust the shaft under the head stock tighter and also slow down the speed until I round it to a point that vibration is minimum.
Slowing down the lathe is the way to correct excessive vibration. Even if the lathe isn't walking around the shop because of added weight it is still vibrating. When I got my electronic variable speed lathe the desire to add mass went away. Also adding mass to the lower part of a non-rigid stand can still allow too much vibration at the workpiece even if the lathe seems secure on the floor.
slowing down does reduce the vibration but on some of my projects there's so much air to turn I need the really fast speeds to make it easier for the tool to bridge that air gap. That's also why my friend added the angle iron supports to the footprint of his lathe.