Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Turning and Fibonacci?

Posts

Turning and Fibonacci?

#1

Turning and Fibonacci?

Barry Irby

There has been discussion here about making identical turnings. I grew up in a Church that had a railing along the front. Spent many Sundays staring at the rail and when I got interested in turning I noticed the spindles were slightly varied and I passed it of to the fact that they were hand turned without the benefit of a duplicator of any sort. This week end I attended a funeral there and sat staring at the rail again. Suddenly I noticed there was a pattern. 11235, repeated four times. Somehow I can't imagine its a coincidence but its also hard to imagine it was an intentional use of a Fibonacci series. Where is Dan Brown now that I need him?

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#2

Alan Sweet

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

Alan Sweet

During my previous life, I was involved in product design and web site design.

Fibonacci and the Golden Ratio was especially important to see how we can use these in a layout. The big names, (Microsoft and Apple I believe), did studies into site layout design principles. The objective was to define certain principles that could be followed to generate sites (also in my case, products) that were attractive and pleasing to the eye.

In both cases, I recall that they discovered that some principles already existed; Fibonacci and the Golden Ratio. If the church you attended was designed by some one who also followed similar design rules, then you may have discovered some of their guiding principles.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#3

Curious

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

as to how you arrived at/assigned the numerical values that form the basis of your 1123 . . etm?

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#4

Re: Curious

Barry Irby

When I was a kid, I sat there in utter boredom, forced to attend, I had noticed that the pickets in the rail were not identical. At that time it did not occur to me that they were not made by a machine that would automatically turned out Identical spindles. In eighth grade I took shop and turned a lamp. The shop teacher made me turn it several times. I learned it was fairly easy to turn similar ones but somewhat harder to make them appear Identical if they were side by side and inches apart. Back in church I realized they were similar and hand made. I wondered if they were turned by different people or by the same person, perhaps on different days. At first I thought they were just scrambled up but then I noticed there were basically five different spindles and they were set out in a repeating order. There was an A, B, CC, DDD, EEEEE, sequence repeated four times. I asked the minister about it, but he was new and had no idea what I was talking about. I need to go back and get some history of the church. I don't know who old it is, but its a very nice old church and it has actual Tiffany stained glass windows. A very nice church for a small town.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#5

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

Sergio

Yes, which part of the rail was in that series. The Partenon was made with proportions tied to the golden ratio and the Fibonacci series approximate that number.

I also guess that since the golden ratio appeals to the eyes and gives a sense of calm, even artisans without knowledge of that (I strongly doubt that an artisan of the past did not know the golden number) could make things so proportionately that necessarily approximate the Fibonacci/golden number.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#6

Steven Antonucci

replacement that i turned for a friend's church

Steven Antonucci

He brought me three railings and none of them were the same, so I asked for a picture of the railing, and that was when I realised that the elements scaled to meet the change in stair spacing.

It isn't a mistake. These guys think these things out. Replacing their original work requires a little detective work some times.

Steve

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#7

Re: Curious

RCH

I'd be very interested to see a picture of this rail. And real Tiffany stained glass windows as well! I've done lot of stained glass work, though little in recent years.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#8

Re: Curious

Barry Irby

I will have to ask. I don't get there very often and I was at a funeral, so it was not appropriate to take pictures. I don't know what their policy is with pictures.

The windows are fabulous. Amazing for a church in a town of 2500 people.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#9

My guess is that it was intentional

Mike Foster

The Fibonacci series crops up in places you would not expect. That pattern is just too unique for it to have come about by chance. So I'm trying to imagine what you saw. Was the spacing of spindles the pattern, the elements in the spindles? Just curious as I can't seem to visualize what you saw. I'd like to see a picture as well.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#10

Fibonacci?

charlie belden

I believe that things made up of Fibonacci Series are appealing - because they are familiar - because they appear in our NATURAL surroundings often. Look at how trees branch and how the leaves are laid out. For plants that require their leaves surface area to get the most sunlight, avoiding one leaf shadowing one below it is a good Darwinian solution. More sunlight - more photosynthesis - more "food" for the plant - the plant survives - grows - reproduces.

I have a feeling that humans are born with an instinctual preference for certain shapes and forms and to distinguish them from similar shapes and forms. If you're hungry and looking around for something edible - being able to distinguish an apple from a "road apple" probably is a handy ability ; )

So - if it has to do with nutrient rich sources (food: fuel to keep going) - or perpetuating the species (reproduction / sex) - it helps fullfil The Prime Directives

1. Continue to live as long as possible, or at least long enough to fulfill the other Prime Directive

2. Reproduce

There's a reason French Curves are pleasing to the eye - you find them everywhere on a woman ; ) Advertising agencies have known this for a long time - SEX SELLS.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#11

Re: Fibonacci?

Sergio

You see the Acropolis with the Partenon in Athens which, as I said was done according to the golden proportions and you become ecstatic, enchanted by the pure beauty of the thing. The entire thing. I spent hours just looking and looking. One of the real marvels of humankind. But never though of sex or reproduction in those hours, just pure beauty. Timeless.

Re: Turning and Fibonacci?

#12

Re: My guess is that it was intentional

Barry Irby

The turnings were similar but different. Some of the vase shaped sections appeared more long and slender, some appeared sorter and slightly more fat, sort of like the difference in a woman's calf with and without the high heals. Some beads appeared wider, some coves more Vee shaped. The thing that made it interesting was that the differences were very subtle but noticeable to a Trained eye, or a turner's eye. Its as if they ordered these several different times and the came from different production runs. OTOH, I pointed out to two other people and they couldn't see what I was talking about.