Do you measure MC?
ron bauer
The post on drying brings up a question I have had for a long time. Do you test moisture content (MC) before final turning? If so what is your target or preferred content? Lastly, what brand tester do you use? Ron.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Do you measure MC?
ron bauer
The post on drying brings up a question I have had for a long time. Do you test moisture content (MC) before final turning? If so what is your target or preferred content? Lastly, what brand tester do you use? Ron.
Re: Do you measure MC?
Ralph Lindberg
Due to the thickness of so much of our turning stock, the only way I know is weight.
Most of the meters really only work on the surface of the wood.
Re: Do you measure MC?
Bill Howatt
No. I'm rarely in need of turning something as soon as I can after roughing green. I date my green turnings and have done enough that I can make a pretty reasonable decision considering time, weight in my hands and the amount of warping.
I agree that weighing is the best method for determining dryness.
Bill
Re: Do you measure MC?
Barry Irby
I have or have had at least different moisture meters. I have never used on on a turning. Two of them were the "pin-less" type and two of them used pins. I agree with those above in that they are pretty useless for turnings. The pin-less ones need a flat surface and only read about 3/4" deep at best. The pin type leave little holes and only measure the surface moisture.
None of them are really accurate and are best used in a comparative sense. IE, read it now and then read it in a month and you have some idea that it has dropped, but neither reading actually gives you a reading of true MC.
Weigh them. And then weigh them again later. When they quit losing weight you will know they are dry enough. I usually just put a date on them and if they are "old enough" I turn them.
Re: Do you measure MC?
robo hippy
While I don't twice turn, if I did, I wouldn't use a meter. After a while, you can 'feel' when it is dry enough to finish turn. I wouldn't date or weigh them either. Just keep stacking some up, and let them sit. Keep the stacks in order, and then as you add new ones, rotate the old ones out.
robo hippy
Re: Do you measure MC?
ron bauer
Thanks for the comments. I have always used the date and wait (not weight) but wondered if there was a more scientific approach. You helped me save $80 - $100 on a moisture meter. Ron.
No. "Air Dried" None.
Re: Do you measure MC?
Bill Jacksonville, NC
Back when General Tools & Instruments LCD Moisture Meter sold for less than $10. at Lowes and was a darling of woodworking message boards bought one. Now they run $25 without sale tax. If all you want is a ball park number that inexpensive General tools meter willl work just fine.
Got along fine without a MM for years and still do. Will play around with mine every now and then. If you are buying turning blanks from different vendors might be nice to know MC when you get wood.
Re: Do you measure MC?
Dale Bonertz
I do, as Bill mentioned, just for a quick close measurement. It is interesting that so many think that moisture meters are only good for a surface reading. This may be true but with my experience on kiln dried blanks it is not true. I have cut many blanks in half and have found at most a 2% moisture difference from the surface area to the center of the blank. To be clear this is kiln dried and air dry may be different since it is not as controlled as kiln drying.
I read somewhere that you can finish turn anything under 18% without much issue of cracking. You may get more movement but cracking shouldn't be to much of an issue. Personally I would wait until 14% or less if you can get it that low in your climate. Some climates it is difficult to do unless at some point you bring them into your house to finish drying them since many home interiors are dryer than outside.
I have never weighed blanks but wouldn't the weight fluctuate with what the humidity is at the moment? Wood is constantly taking on and losing moisture so how much variance do you allow for when weighing?
Yes
mjonesrdg
I have a Wagner pin-less type and I use it all the time. I've learned a lot by using it and, while I can live without one, I wouldn't want to. I am not a production turner, and I can see why folks that are (production turners) might not take the time to "read" a rough turning or blank.
almost never
Steven Antonucci
Used to worry about it, but not so much these days.
S
Re: Yes
Bill Blasic
I also have the Wagner pinless and I too use it all the time.
Bill
Re: Do you measure MC?
John Lucas
I bought a moisture meter but find it mostly useless. I use it now only to get a ball park reading of waxed exotics I buy. Still I really use that info. I put them up on the shelf just like the others and weight a year before I use them. That corner of my garage looks almost like the big monk lumber booth from all I've bought at the last 6 or 8 symposiums