I thought I would start a discussion on bowl design. It's going to be very brief simply because I don't have that many bowls on hand and Richard Raffen has done a much better job than I will in his book. Just thought we could have some fun with it and maybe spur some ideas.
When turning the outside after you've decide on the shape you need to decide if you want to put any details on it to set it apart from other bowls. Here are a few examples.
Beads, One, two, or more and where do you put them.
Obviously this is only a small sample. You can add all sorts of designs in a band around a bowl. The main thing if you leave a raised band is not to over sand. In the first and 3rd shot you will notice that the band edges are soft. I power sanded these. Not good if you want crisp shoulders. Better to hand sand. The last bowl has some details routed into the band. You could burn, or carve, or texture, just let your mind wander. Look closely at how the size and placing of the band affects the bowl. Each one could be improved in my opinion.
Again there's a million ways to do it and I'm limited by space here. I'll write an better article to go in the articles pages when I have time.
The first bowl is a good example of what not to do. The lip is just a muddy mess. No edges to define it. Your eye doesn't know where to go. This is typical of an over sanded edge. Make an effort to define the edge. Curved in bowls I like the lip to curve in, wide open bowls I prefer to tilt the lip out. You can also create shadow lines on the inside our outside like the last 2 bowls.
First is to decide how big the foot should be and whether it should have a curved shoulder to blend into the bowl, or a sharp corner to sort of sit on the bowl.
The first of these is how I did my earliest bowls. Part it off and sand. Pretty plain and screams beginner. I like to reverse turn my bowls so the bottom shows some attention to detail and hopefully the customers will appreciate it.
The forever controversy. Rebates if done correctly won't look so much like you did it to avoid having to reverse turn the bowl. My friend Teresa Par does this extremely well as you'll see in the Walnut beaded bowl. Mine is a little more noticeable.
reverse turning the bowl with a tenon allows you to shape the foot anyway you want. You can add a rebate at this time if you want simply for design purpoeses or you can leave the tenon really long like this oriental style bowl. Reverse turning lets you make the foot any size you want from skinny little edges and really small to very large. You can also leave enough wood to carve feet.
The rebate in Teresa's beaded bowl fits nicely into the overall design. There is no doubt that she wanted it done this way - and not as a way to hide the chucking method.
The middle one is disappointing when turned over. Turners will question the reason for the rebate, but non-turners may just accept it.
The third one is kinda cute and different. I think it will grow on you as a design idea, but probably will not make it as a useful bowl.
Bowls are a funny item. I am always amazed by what the public likes vs. what I like. In great many cases, it comes down to what is practical.
Beads, for instance, may look great and show a turners skill, but it's just another place for food to get stuck and now you have to use your fingernail to scratch it out. I like beads on bowls, but I notice that they are harder to sell.
Sharp details are another example. Crisp is good if you are a turner, but the buying public doesn't really care. I break the edges on anything I am even considering selling.
On feet, the bigger, the better with selling. I had a bowl in the gallery that sat for 2 years. It had a round bottom, and gently rocked when you put it down. In talking to the woman that ran the gallery, we identified this as the likely source for its "unsellableness". I took it back to shop to return the foot, and I swear to you that I removed no more than a 2" circle x 1/16" deep from the bottom. It sold in three weeks.
I appreciate that there are different strokes for different folks, but whenever I am making a bowl that will get a price tag, I make the simplest bowl I can. Vanilla is the number one selling flavor. If it is my bowl, it's probably got a bead and a round bottom.
Re: What I like vs. what sells vs. what is useful.
Brad Vietje
Good points, Steve!
I like to reverse turn the foot and add a little detail; partly because I don't want my name found on a dumpy bowl. Doesn't add much time or cost, and to me adds a clear statement that this may be a simple form, but it was not done by a beginner (just my ego calling, I suppose )
Steven wrote: "I break the edges on anything I am even considering selling." I agree when it comes to the rim and any raised details, simply because a sharp detail is so vulnerable to denting even before someone buys it. Bowls are something that customers want to pick up, and they don't always set them down w/out knocking into something else . They will also be "dented" very quickly if used at all by the customer, who could be quite disappointed.
Then we can go into finishing for sale, vs a juried event.... In lower-priced venues, glossy sells better. To a more discriminating clientele -- the sort who have hand-rubbed Cherry bookcases and bureaus in their home -- a more subdued finish just looks more professional and more realistic, if the item is intended for use, and not "just" for show, (IMHO). Items that are more art than craft -- in my mind that means for display vs. for actual use -- should get a finish that the maker feels is appropriate for the piece, and high gloss would be fine for a purely ornamental piece, such as a hanging ornament that is not handled. A display piece like a large turned platter made to be hung on a wall (thinking Mike Scott here) would probably still look better with a softer, non-glossy finish, so I would suggest that gloss finishes be used with great care, since they can make a piece look cheap and tacky, if not done just right. Decorative turnings that incorporate epoxy, bright colors, metallic foils, etc... often look great with a high-gloss finish, or even big bowls a la Giles Gilson.... No hard& fast rules, but I'd say be careful not to cheapen the value of a well-turned item with a finish that looks like it was dipped in plastic.
Just one fella's opinion, but let's hear from you on this. Here's my favorite quote about opinions: "Opinions are like belly buttons; everyone has one, but nobody really knows what to do with it"
I like whatever my customers buy. With respect to bowls, for the most part, it seems that small and simple is better. I will use my wife as an example, she has the pick of the litter and she chooses the smaller bowls, 6" or so and stacks them in the china cabinet. She uses them for nuts and candy whenever her girlfriends are here. Seldom, if ever, does she have a use for the larger bowls we have stacked in the closet.
When I used to sell bowls in a gallery, the smaller bowls sold, but I believe that was because they were souvenirs that fit easily in a suitcase and did not require special packing or shipping.
I like to finish turn the bottom of everything I turn. Invariably people pick up pieces and turn them over and look at the bottom and it only takes a minute or two to dress up that bottom and give them something pretty at which to look.
Clearly, for me, the last one is the best, and it doesn't take much extra time to add a nice surprise for anyone who looks.
It's also a nice little detail if the curve of the bowl can run right past the raised rim (foot), and continue to the center, so the foot looks like an applied ring. Bert Marsh was very good at this, and I think of him with almost every foot I detail like this.
meaning something prone to potentially disappoint in the future...even if it is the customer's fault. I may be wrong, but a glossy finish usually loses some of its shine through use from my experience, so I don't use them.
I want my finishes to be good enough to have someone recognize the beauty in the wood, but not to be so beautiful that they are afraid to throw a bag of chips in at a party or dress a salad. I always include instructions for care, lest someone complain that the bowl wasn't "dishwasher safe...?"
Most of the bowls I am selling are larger (14"+), but I don't think most people know how much salad a bowl that size will hold. I have a couple of very large bowls (18"+) and they look absolutely empty with two heads of greens in them.
Turned with a ring at the top. Locate the handles where the grain runs straight through, and then use a drawknife and spokeshave to cut away the ring to final form.
I rough out the handles with the bandsaw and then clean them up with sandpaper glued to sticks. It goes fast. To carve feet I use a coping saw followed by the sandpaper.
If you own a decent draw knife and a spokeshave, I think you'd be amazed at how quickly and easily the handles form. These took maybe 5 minutes, and required no sanding.
I have used my router table with a straight bit to cut feet. Just cut a foot on the bottom and then cut it down to three feet with the router. (Three points always sit nicely and do not rock, even if the bowl warps.)
Steve I have all those tools and more and dont hesitate to use them. I don't teach them because most turners don't own them. Don't know how to post videos from my phone but go to you tube and type in Appalachian woodturner. You'll find a video some students did of me on my shaving horse and spring pole lathe
Great post, John. Of the first set of bowls, I like the third one, ambrosia maple. A beautiful piece. I like the bead on the first bowl, but I think it would look better without the foot.