Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

Posts

More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

#1

More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

charlie belden

Multi Axis turning can seem so confusing and appear to be somewhat unredictable - a Hit Or Miss Thing - sometimes the results can be interesting, sometimes they can be - well let's just say "not quite so good".

Two turners I know who are doing terrific Between Centers multi axis pieces are Barbara Dill, usiing her Structured Approach, and Peter Rand, who works more intuitively. Both do primarily abstract multi axis pieces. though Barbara's "Tea Set" series and her amazing Harmony piece are a little less abstract.

The engineer in me puts me somewhere between these two approaches to multi axis turning, leaning more towards the Sturctured Approach. To try and understand the fundamental concepts of multi axis turning that Barbara introduced with her articles, papers and demonstration, I've been working on using Google's free SketchUp virtual 3D program to crreate virtual 3D models to illustrate fundamental concepts of MAT (Multi Axis Turning). With the understanding of the fundamental concepts of MAT, I wanted to develop a means of using SketchUp to virtually DESIGN multi axis pieces. And from the resulting design, I wanted to have

Where the centers on each end of a between centers should be

What the profile on each axis should be

What the results should look like for each step of the turning process and ve able to print that out and take to the lathe to create the piece

I've been able to do all that - first with a multi axis piece I did that conveys the look of my oldest grand daughter Kaitlin. at age 6 - and then with a series of multi axis pieces inspired by a Masai herdsman.

Now I've taken an idea of a multi axis piece that Peter Rand has done which is part of a set of six pieces he titled "Gathering".


In the view on the left, I saw a Maltese Falcon, which led me to this side view image of a Maltese Falcon.


And from that image, which I imported into SketchUp, I developed a virtual 3D model of a Three Parallel Axes, Two Profiles abstract Maltese Falcon.

First, a color coded version to show which surfaces of the piece was created by each axis. Note that the Blue and Green profiles are identical, their axes merely offset from each other.


The colors are kind of distracting, so here's a gray scale version of the same piece, same views


I put together two videos attempting to show how the piece was DESIGNED in SketchUp and uploaded them to YouTube

Here's the first attempt video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sP3Sh9AA00E

I then tried to simplify things and did another video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyeoz9i5SiI

SketchUp is a powerful design tool, though it does have a learning curve to climb. I'm working on ways to flatten that learning curve a bit to make it easier for turners to use.

Anyway, comments, questions, suggestions for making things clearer, etc. are hereby solicited.

Re: More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

#2

Re: More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

Hal Taylor

Fascinating Charlie, but well above my pay grade. I've tried Sketchup, and as you say, there's a step learning curve. Your videos aptly demonstrate the power of Sketchup. Now if you can get it down to my level...

Re: More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

#3

Re: More Designing Multi Axis Pieces in Virtual 3D

charlie belden

Hal:

I've been working on just that - for about a year - on and off.

The challenge is that the process of using SketchUp for designing involves not only working in 2D which is relatively easy to learn, but also working with virtual 3D, and illustrating virtual 3D stuff in just 2D - and in still images and illustrations. What's needed for how to use SketchUp to design virtual multi axis pieces is a video tutorial of the process - with Voice Over explaining what is being shown in the video. SketchUp does have the ability to create animations that can be captured as a "movie". And there are plenty of video editing apps that can be used to assemble edited video clips. I'm using Apple's free QuickTime app to do screen captures of SketchUp animations and Apple's iMovie to edit and assemble clips, and to insert titles and captions. iMovie also makes it easy to upload the finished video to YouTube.

What I HAVEN"T worked out yet is adding Voice Over. Voice Over will also require writing a script to be read at the appropriate time during the video.

Doing a decent video tutorial on how to use SketchUp to design and virtually turn pieces requires climbing multiple app learning curves.

Add to the learning curves pile - the fun and games of multi axis turning.

Maybe I should start much simpler

How to draw a profile using the LINE, CIRCLE, ARC and ERASER tools

How to COPY PARALLEL an outside profile to create an inside profile

How to virtually turn a 2D profile into a virtual 3D Piece.

Stay tuned.