Hello, I' thinking of buying a carving vise for same detailing on bowls and perhaps some carving on wood. I would like it to be removable and I would prefer to work on a bench rather than on the banjo of the lathe. I'm considering the one that Packard sells. Anybody with experience on this vise or other recommendations?
Sergio - Woodcut has the ProMount - it works well for me. Got an adapter for my chucks and set it up for vacuum chucking which works well for working bowls - easy to move them around...
Sergio - I have been using a carving vise from Bestwood Tools mounted on a bench for the past 4 or 5 years, and it works very well. I mounted the bench adapter to a piece of 1/2 thick steel plate, and then attach this to the benchtop with bolts and threaded inserts so the carving stand can be installed or removed in a few seconds as needed. It works great for my purposes. Rob
Sergio, I have the Bosch vice and there are two things I particularly like about it: it adjusts in all directions with a single lever - which is often very nice. It shifts easily from the bench top to the banjo if you wish; There is a bench-mount it fits into so all you have to do is loosen a couple of Allen screws, slide it out, and take it to the lathe.
It is the only one I have used so I have no comparison, I am sure others are excellent as well.
I'm with Rob. I bought the first Bestwoodtools when they started making them. I love it. Sometimes the 2 levers do get to be confusing but other times it's a blessing. For repetitive cuts I like to be able to tilt it to an angle that works well and then loosen the other lever and simply rotate it each time without the tilt ever changing. However sometimes it can be a pain in that you find yourself looking for that rotating lever. On the plus side when you release the tilting lever you know it only goes up and down, not all over the place so it's easier to hold onto.
The single lever concept is good like Trent Bosch's. The downside of that one is that when you release the lever you better be holding on because it goes anywhere. The plus side of course is that it's very quick and does go everywhere.
I think what I'd like to see is one that is foot controlled so you use both hands to hold it when tilting. I believe Trent has a pneumatic one that he uses at home.
I would use my carpenter's bench, about 18 x18 x 42" long, with carpet on top.
I would sit straddle it, or a portion of a corner, then clamp the turning between my legs or knees. Sometimes with a boat cushion under the work, sometimes under my butt to adjust for size.
It is keeps the work right in front, up close, and quick to rotate. It is also very friendly to the surfaces, as you start getting closer to the finishing stage.