Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Clearly, we are doing it wrong

Posts

Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#1

Steven Antonucci

Clearly, we are doing it wrong

steven antonucci


No words...

S

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

Steve Kubien

Please tell me this creature has not reproduced.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#3

Sounds like Matt Foley,

Dick Coers

Inspirational Speaker. Address; A van down by the river.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

Keith Tompkins

I'm sure we'll be seeing this guy at the 2015 National Symposium as a featured demonstrator...WOW..why didn't I think of that!!! :D

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#5

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

charlie belden

Wonder how many sets of bearings he goes through a month (or maybe week).

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#6

Yup!

Geoff Whaling

Wonder if Mr Thompson sells them rotary turning tools? Got to get me a pair of universal motor support clamps. ;-)

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#7

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

John Lucas

Saw this done many years ago at Berea Kentucky. They were turning miniature bowling pins for a skittles game they make and sell. He turned and sanded the pins in 30 to 45 seconds.

It has the same draw backs as duplicators in that there are some cuts it won't do, such as a square shouldered tenon and square sided beads. However for most other shapes it works well.

there are lots of other ways to trace the pattern but what's he's done works pretty well.

Naturally CNC will be affordable for the home shop before too long and it will probably do the cuts I just mentioned. In fact it might be able to add 3D carvings to the spindle and all while sitting in your living room.

Kind of like the difference between hand carving and power carving. Hand carving doesn't produce any noise and no dust and is relaxing. Using a router is noisy, produces huge amounts of dust and requires a fancy jig. I'd rather take a bowl gouge to green wood and not make the noise or dust.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Roll Up The Rim.....

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Clearly the Tim Horton's cup in the background is fuelling his inspiration... caffeine poisoning is evident, wonder if he won anything on the Roll Up The Rim cup?

eh

Jim

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#9

Steven Antonucci

How do I make a lumpy stick?

steven antonucci

I'm guessing that there was a pretty rough finish on that lumpy stick, and at $20-40 per router bit, that's about as much as you could spend to make a lumpy stick? A Sears roughing gouge would probably take all of a minute to make it, and I suspect that you could get a better finish with one too?

I can just imagine the walls of his shop lined with all the various lumpy stick templates and broken router bits. YouTube recommended the video to me. YouTube made me laugh.

S

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#10

Re: How do I make a lumpy stick?

John Lucas

Steve you would be surprised at the finish quality. A lot depends on how big of a cut you take each pass but done properly with the right bit it leaves a good finish. As you may know I have been using routers for 35 years and done a lot of different things with them. With the bit he's using you should get a pretty good finish if you take light cuts as you finish it.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#11

Steven Antonucci

Even cutting in the wrong direction?


Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#12

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

phillip Medghalchi

The guy looks like he is on ADERALL over dose. and the lathe?

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#13

Really guys!!

ron bauer

I thought better of this community than what I have seen in most of these posts. Here is a guy showing his method of work. Does it deviate from what you do? it sure does and that is what makes it interesting. Is your lathe bigger than his?does it have more bells and whistles? Did yours cost more? Probably. Is he excited about what he is showing? yup. To just start taking shots at the guy because he is differant is the equivalent of school yard bullying. I thought we were about embracing diversity. Personnaly I like to see differant ways of doing things and if I had to make a hundred spindles I very probably would consider incorporating some of his methodology. Just because he is not a frequent contributor to this community does not make him less of a turner. I will probably be blackballed for posting this but I can't stand on the sidelines any longer. And yes he can make square beads if he starts with square billets just like any of you would need to do if turning in the "traditional" manner.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#14

Re: Really guys!!

John Lucas

Ron I hope I wasn't picking on him. I'm impressed with his setup. The square beads I was talking about is square sided and a square corner at the bottom. Same with a tenon coming up to a square shoulder. I don't believe a round bit can cut a square corner. I've done work like this with my router and also used a copy attachment which won't do this kind of cut either. You would have to orient the cutter a different way to do that sort of cut.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#15

Re: Really guys!!

phillip Medghalchi

Ron, I was saying that he is too hyper nothing about his method. There is so many ways to skin the cat. Waht I was worried about was that he was jumping here and there a lot. if it works for him then by all means. Nothing bad about his way. Heck if we got one of those guys that used to turn in 50's they would say we are all too spoiled to ahve elctronic varainle speed lathes now. and all the facny chucks. Remember that guy in one of those third world country who wa turning between using his toes and hands? (on the youtube)heck he makes his living that way.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#16

Ellis Walentine

Fair enough

Ellis Walentine

You make some good points, Ron. Sometimes humor is unnecessarily and/or inadvertently sophomoric or cruel. Sensitivities are the hardest thing to legislate and adjudicate. Our history and our modus operandi here is to err on the side of permissiveness, and let folks represent themselves in the way they see fit, and let the chips fall as they may; though we won't tolerate comtemptuous or gratuitous flaming of individuals.

In this case, the video in question is pretty humorous and amateurish, but the concept is anything but. Duplicating lathes and gunstock lathes have been around for hundreds of years, and today's CNC lathes operate in similar fashion. Personally, as a designer first (technician second), I like to keep an open mind about methods of work relative to the desired outcome. I've done plenty of unorthodox techniques over the years that would probably elicit the same kinds of responses from any given crowd of woodworkers.

You will never be "blackballed" on WoodCentral for expressing a heartfelt opinion.

Ellis

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#17

Re: Really guys!!

Geoff Whaling

Ron, to be honest my comment was trying to be light hearted about a turning solution that I actually see as having fairly serious safety hazards. I appologize for the inferences drawn from it.

He may well be doing things differently but his methods are very dangerous.

For the life of me I cannot see the need to run the lathe untill the ridiculuously dangerous blank ( a split log) is at least trimmed to some sort of balance and inspected for hazardous shakes and splits. The turner could easily have used the lathe indexing (if fitted I guess) to hold the blank stationary while running trim cuts with the router to bring it into balance if he wished to do it on the lathe. Once balanced the lathe could then be run BUT at a far slower speed. That sort of speed is clearly unnecessary to drive the cutting action - the router does that for him. The lathe becomes a means to generate basic circular motion of the blank.

Clearly the lathe and stand is not up to the out of balance loads experienced in this clip. I would hope that even inexperienced turners would have concerns about that level of vibration. Then there are a host of other safety issues, power switch on the floor behind the lathe, relying upon C clamps to fix the motor, excessive vibration, blank rotation direction, unguarded belts that he bends down in front of to access the power switch (very serious entanglement hazard) ....

Unfortunately a serious accident waiting to happen!

One good thing he was protecting his hearing. But not using protection for his eyes or face.

How do we reach out to these guys to give them some basic assistance?

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#18

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

Don Orr

I'm curious about the floating device holding the router. I can't say I would do things the way he does, but it's interesting how people work out problems.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#19

OK! OK! You got me, I confess......

Barry Irby

At least five years ago and long before seeing this video I decided to try something like this. I was tired of taking the beating roughing bowl blanks and tried to do it with my big 3hp router. I put the biggest bit I had in it along with a sturdy guide bushing. Envisioned ways of holding the router in some sort of mount, but all of them were too complicated to build for a test run so I decided to wing it. (If I drank beer, this would be the "Here, hold my beer moment.") I put the tool rest as close as I could, propped the router on the rest, turned it on, Had the lathe set as slow as it would go, and turned it on. That was the sensation the snail had when stepped on by the turtle. I don't know what happened, it was all so fast. Knocked the router away. Left a big divot in my tool rest, ruined the router bit, ruined the guide bushing, and I will Never be able to wear those shorts again.

Don't try this at home.

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#20

Steven Antonucci

unfortunately, not everyone gets a gold star...

steven antonucci

While the Internet and YouTube has given everyone a pulpit to show what they can do, when I see stuff like this, I cringe wondering who might view it and try to replicate what he is doing? There is so much wrong in this video, and so many dangerous techniques that he doesn't get an "attaboy!"

Some have been pointed out, and it is easy to pile on a bunch more. His motor is being held on by a C-clamp. The router is not designed for that type of load. Have you ever found metal in a log? What happens if he does? Why doesn't he have some kind of guard above the router bit?

If you look at how most copy router lathes work, they are either running very slowly or fully automated. The slow ones are used to do details like flutes or twists. The production ones do not have a guy 10 inches from an exploding router bit when he hits the live center in the tail stock...

S

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#21

Steven Antonucci

Thanks for posting

steven antonucci

my point

Steve

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#22

Ellis Walentine

Thanks

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for explaining the problems with the guy's approach more fully. That works better than trashing him outright without benefit of explanation, though he is deserving of it. And, you're absolutely right: there's a lot wrong with this picture -- no belt guards, motor held onto a floppy mount with C-clamps, no face protection, reaching over to operate the switch -- on and on. The guy definitely appears to be going for a Darwin award.

I was wondering about the router bit idea. For whatever reason, he was able to make some pretty aggressive cuts without blowing up his router rig or breaking any bits, even on that piece of rough firewood. Seemingly, he has done a lot of spindles with this technique and may know more than we do about its limits. Maybe there's a way to question him through a comment on that YouTube page.

Ellis

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#23

Steven Antonucci

Safety isn't about the one time it worked

steven antonucci

but the one time it didn't work.

I looked back at my original comment (No words), and my "Lumpy Stick" comment. I don't question his RIGHT to post the video. I just don't think it is very responsible.

There was the very popular video of the two Canadian guys turning on a minivan with a sharpened pipe. You could claim parody, or comedy...but what happens if someone gets hurt trying it? Turning is dangerous enough without doing something like this?

If you want to attract attention, you should be comfortable with the fact that some of the attention will be negative. It is unavoidable. There are certainly constructive ways to communicate negative thoughts positively, but not everyone is open to criticism. The problem with sugar coating a mess like this is that it would legitimize it to someone as "fix just one little thing"... and possibly prevent them from just learning the proper use of a roughing gouge!

S

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#24

Reminds me of my favorite Jack Nicholson line...

Keith Newton

From the movie, "Going South" I think.

" Damn, I dont' believe I'd a told dat".he he

Re: Clearly, we are doing it wrong

#25

Owning a video camera doesn't automatically make a

Keith Newton

Expert.

Some time a little while back, I thought I would see what sort of video was on the net for cutting full sheets of plywood on a Table Saw. Through the years, I've seen so many carpenters who go a whole lifetime making it look awkward and more time consuming that is necessary. Many of them, I've tried to show them a few things, but old habits are hard to tear out of them, the older they get.

Anyway, some of the videos that popped up first were really just awful. One guy was trying to rip about 4" off a full sheet, using, probably old sears underpowered, never lubricated saw on too small, too long cord, with a dull blade. And for a catch table, he had an upside down wheel-barrow, which was not centered well under the sheet, nor aligned with the fence.

It made my head hurt to watch. Why would someone who obviously doesn't know what they are doing, think they should share it with the WORLD.

Another fellow, knew what caused a kickback, so was demonstrating it with a push stick, but came within an inch of cutting all his fingers off. I'm pretty sure he was shaken, but went on with the show. He never got around to showing how not to have a kickback, by doing it properly, and probably didn't really know.

If his goal was to instill fear in novice users, I'm sure he succeeded at that.