Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Lidded Boxes with Finials

Posts

Lidded Boxes with Finials

#1

Lidded Boxes with Finials

charlie belden

Turning lidded boxes and finials for them is a lot of fun, doesn't require much other than a scroll chuck, a skew, maybe a spingle gouge and a parting tool and a chunk of DRY wood (or several chunks of dry wood). And you can make them as simple or as complicated as you want.

OK, so there are only two parts to make, a third if you want to add a finial.

The lid has to fit the box and these two parts need to be aligned. The lid can fit INSIDE the top rim of the box or on TOP of the box. Either way you have to decide on how snug they fit together.

Now turners tend to shoot for a Pop Fit (when you pull the top of the box it should make a popping sound). This may impress other turners - but THAT requires using two hands to pull the lid off. And that means you can't have what you want to put IN the box - in one of your hands. Conversely, if you want to get something OUT of the box, you need one hand to pull the lid off and one hand to hold the box - leaving no hand to take whatever it is you want to get OUT of the box out.

So, from a User's perspective, a Pop Fit is inconveneint. A looser fit, that allows just the top to be removed - with one hand - makes more sense. Of course that may mean that someone will lift the box up to look at it more closely - and drop the box, and the content of the box, onto the floor. If the floor is concrete, tile or Italian marble, or even a hardwood floor, one or both of the parts of the box may get dinged - and you have to find all the stuff that fell out and bounced off to who knows where (usually they'll end up under something heavy and with little clearance under it).

Then there's the issue of Wood Movement. A Pop Fit when there's high humidity can become a loose fit when the air is drier, A Pop Fit when it's dry becomes, essentially, one piece of wood, rather than a box with a removable lid. Wood is, after all, hygroscopic and thus swells or shrinks with changes in humidity.

The other thing about finialed lidded boxes is that the finial, for aesthetic reasons primarily, is usually very pointy - the sharper the point the better - from an aesthetic perspective. BUT - picking up something that has a sharp point on it can make dents or holes in your skin. And if you have to wrestle the top onto the box and squeeze and / or twist the two together - a delicate, aesthetically pleasing finial - can be snapped off - or broken if the lid and finial are dropped on the floor (see above).

SO - my questions are:

Do you

Go with a Pop Fit when you turn a lidded box, and risk it being basically one piece of wood when the wood expands"

or

Leave a little slop and have it get looser as the humidity goes way down, increasing the likelyhood that the lid will FALL OFF when someone picks it up to look at it?

When it comes to the finial, do you

Go with the delicate, pointy topped, aesthetic finial?

or

Go with some semi aesthetic blunted finial?

IF you include a finial for your lidded box(es)

Do you prefer a Stuck On finial, with a bead or some other detail on the bottom of the finial where it meets the lid of the box?

or

Do you prefer to BLEND the finial and lid together so you get continuous flowing curves?

Re: Lidded Boxes with Finials

#2

Re: Lidded Boxes with Finials

Sergio

One thing I can say: if you want to sell the piece the lid must be easy to remove with one hand. I learned this lesson the hard way: beautiful piece but does not open easily, you have to turn the lid in order to remove it.

For the rest I have too little experience.

Re: Lidded Boxes with Finials

#3

The pop fit lid for boxes is really.....

JamieDonaldson

...just an exercise for turners to impress other turners, not practical or acceptable for civilian use. I am not a fan of impossibly thin and fragile finials, as stated in my examples in the current American Woodturner Journal. Since these finials are often used as handles, I'm more inclined to "turn for the market" and give them some strength to avoid breakage.

Re: Lidded Boxes with Finials

#4

Re: The pop fit lid for boxes is really.....

phillip Medghalchi

Charlie, very interesting qsn.. I just started to do finials and all of that went through my head. I don't have all the answer, however, few days back I turned my first one with sucess and I decided that if it was going to be used as a jewelry box then it could not have very skinny top finial. I think in the process of design one should ask him/herself that what the final purpose of that piece going to be and design accordingly. If it's going to be used over and over again then skinny finial wouldn't be practical. Or in case of soem of the very nice pieces i have seen here on line, the designer need to state the intention shall the piece need to be sold or gifted, so receipient will know how to handle the piece.

In the case of tight pop fit, I guess it's more for showing off and to impres other turners. Down here, in s. Texas right now all the wooden items around us fit lose like it has never been a good design, but yo come down here in April all the way to Sept., and you will use all the complimentary words in the book and call the designer all those names for not knowing what the heck he did. One should consider the wood movement in the design of the piece.