Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

bowl gouge shapes

Posts

bowl gouge shapes

#1

bowl gouge shapes

Dave L

Another question. What is the difference between the vee shaped bowl gouge and the u shaped gouge.

what is the advantage of one over the other? Is there a specific use of one over the other. I have never used the vee shape and was just curious.

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#2

Steven Antonucci

Very hard to explain it all...

steven antonucci

The general answer is that "it depends". On lots of things.

Generally, I think the U shaped flutes tend to clear chips better, but it depends on how you cut, and the size of the chip you are making. V shaped flutes have a tighter radius at the nose, and thusly make smaller chips if cutting on the nose. If you look at me using a bowl gouge, it is more like to be a V shape than U shape...but different manufactures may call their shapes V or U based upon whatever they feel like? I don't think there is a standard.

Steve

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#3

Re: bowl gouge shapes

robo hippy

There are many variations, even ones with the same name. I prefer more open fluted gouges because I hold my gouges more level, and tend to finish cut with the nose. A V gouge has a very small sweet spot on the nose, the Thompson V and U gouges have a much larger sweet spot. I have one of the Glaser V gouges and don't like it at all, but that is my style. I would think that they could work fine with a slightly more swept back design, and shear cutting with the wing. It would be more of a pull cut than a push cut. Just my opinion, but I am different. I prefer to use scrapers for all my bowl roughing. Go to You Tube and type in robo hippy.

robo hippy

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Right!!

Lyle Jamieson

There is no standard. You can buy the same brand name bowl gouge you have seen or had before and the flute might be different. Drives me crazy while I'm out teaching that there is so many different tools. I use my bowl gouge to do everything so I want a parabolic flute. David Ellsworth put this on the map decades ago.

The "U" shaped flute makes it tricky to scrape and sheer scrape with the bowl gouge. The "V" shape gets a little pointy when you sweep the wings back like I do. The parabolic flute has a more friendly or larger sweet spot at the tip for bevel supported push cuts.

I will announce the availability of a new and better bowl gouge in the marketplace menu, soon. As soon as Doug Thompson gets the production run to me. I am proud of saying "Made in USA".

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#5

Re: bowl gouge shapes

John Lucas

I'm a fan of the Thompson V gouge. The more pointy tip lets me reach in places easier than a more blunt tip. I like how the wings cut.

The thicker upper wall gives a nice shape to the edge when you grind the wings back. This is a little thicker angle on the wing so it holds an edge better. I have a U gouge and the wing gets really thin if sharpened with the wing ground back. I like this for some pull cuts because it cuts very clean due to the sharper angle but doesn't hold an edge as long.

The tip of the V shape gouges is smaller and beginners have trouble keeping it from getting pointy. It just takes more patience when grinding the tip. The U has a much more rounded point that is easier to sharpen.

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#6

Re: bowl gouge shapes

robo hippy

Dang it Lyle, just when I thought I had all the tools I needed/wanted. I will probably have to try one out. Maybe I need to get Doug to do a robo hippy signature scraper....

Doug's V gouge is way more open than the Glaser V.

robo hippy

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#7

I am that beginner.. I guess

mjonesrdg

I bought a deep "V" 3/8' bowl gouge something like 12 or 14 years ago...sharpening gave me fits and I have used a wet jet 10" modified set up with the Wolverine jig for years and it still gives me fits. I now have it shaped with one wing longer than the other and use it occasionally, but it is certainly is not my "go-to" gouge.

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#8

Re: I am that beginner.. I guess *LINK*

John Lucas

If you have one wing longer than the other it's a sharpening problem and not the gouge shape. Same is true for people having funny shapes on the nose of the gouge. My video on correcting sharpening problems should help.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9G16ylEZHQ

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#9

The Thompson V flute profile is more "open"...

JamieDonaldson

...than some other brands of V flutes, and I like it just as well as my older Sorby gouges. The Thompson V cutting tip is larger and more efficient than V flutes on other V gouges I have and now seldom use.

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#10

Bill Blasic

Re: bowl gouge shapes

Bill Blasic

I prefer the Thompson V (My go to is the 5/8 V) over the U. For me the U is more aggressive and I have more control with the V. With the V I can put long wings on the tool but if you try that with the U the tool doesn't want to cut. If I do pick up a U it is for the transition from the side of a bowl through the bottom but I have not needed to do that for a long time. Some folks have told me the exact opposite (V is more aggressive). I believe it is all about the individual in what and how they use a tool. I have been using of late the new Thompson 5/8 Deep V and I am liking it.

Bill

Re: bowl gouge shapes

#11

Lyle Jamieson

we always need another tool


Re: bowl gouge shapes

#12

Re: bowl gouge shapes

robo hippy

Interesting comment Bill. I switch back and forth a lot between the Thompson V and U. For sure the V is not nearly as steep as the Glaser V. If you are finding one to be more aggressive than the other, it probably has more to do with technique than it does the tool. Mostly how you hold it, and how heavy your foot is on the gas pedal. In a more scraping mode, they can remove a lot very fast. I prefer the U for the more broad nose because I keep my flutes at 45 to 90 degrees rolled onto the side, and the U had a bigger sweet spot than the V. This is a bevel rubbing cut, and the handle slightly dropped. I don't use a swept back gouge much any more, and if I do, I still cut more with the nose than the wings. I never use gouge wings for shear scrapes. I find a scraper works much better for me.

robo hippy