Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

handle comparison

Posts

handle comparison

#1

handle comparison

Dave L

Anyone have an opinion----good or bad---on the Thompson handles versus the Bennet handles?

Re: handle comparison

#2

Steven Antonucci

Never heard of the Bennett handle?

steven antonucci

So, I googled them...

My personal opinion is that I would not want to use a foam gripped handle because I tend to use the handle on my gouges as impromptu mallets. If you have ever seen me turn, I've likely driven a spur center in with a wooden handle in front of you. I'd tear up the foam in no time.

I only have one Thompson handle, and I feel terribly guilty whacking stuff with it, but I still do. Since it is loaded with lead shot, it works very well. However, most of my handles are just turned out of wood, simply because it is easy enough to do, and basically free.

Perhaps the single most important consideration that everyone overlooks is that hands are different sizes. I like smaller handles, and I have small hands. In general, I also don't want all of my tools with the same handles, otherwise it takes forever to find them in the rack.

.02

Steve

Re: handle comparison

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: handle comparison

Lyle Jamieson

I have and use the Thompson handles. I like a lighter handle so I take the shot weight out.

Re: handle comparison

#4

Re: handle comparison

John Lucas

The Bennet handles look interesting. I wonder how long the foam holds up. I've had foam similar in appearance to that go bad on other tools but what he's using might be excellent. Can't tell from the photo.

In the winter that might be a good handle. My Thompson's get a little cold but only when you pick them up. After you hold one for a minute or so your hands warm it up.

Re: handle comparison

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: handle comparison

Lyle Jamieson

I am going to try an idea I heard recently. The suggestion was to use Lacrosse Stick wrap on the handles.

Re: handle comparison

#6

Re: handle comparison

John Jordan

My handles look/feel like foam, but its rubber and indestructible-I'll replace them for life, but don't think I have ever done so. I, too, use them for whacking locking handles etc. Your hands aren't hammers.

John

Re: handle comparison

#7

Re: handle comparison

Matt

I prefer the Bennett. The Thompson was a little large for me, although it was for a 3/4 bowl gouge compared to my bennett on a 1/2 bowl gouge (bennett only goes to 5/8"). I feel that I do not have to grip it as hard as wood handles or the thompson. I've only had the Bennett for a few months so I do not know the longevity of the grip. I liked the grip enough to buy two more. Although I'm still waiting on delivery. Matt

Re: handle comparison

#8

Re: handle comparison

DKWalser

"... I wonder how long the foam holds up. I've had foam similar in appearance to that go bad on other tools but what he's using might be excellent. Can't tell from the photo. ..."

I use, and like, the Serious Camlock handle. It is covered with a similar in appearance black rubber foam. It's proven to be very durable. I've had it for about three years. The Arizona heat eats up most rubber products, but not this handle. Like John, I can't tell from the photo whether the foam used by Bennett is of the same quality.

Re: handle comparison

#9

Re: handle comparison

John Lucas

Many years ago Mark Gardner told us he was having Carpal tunnel syndrome and his doctor said to use larger tool handles. I like a large but not too large handle. Most normal size tools come with a decent sized handle, the Thompson handles are good I think.

Many of the smaller tools come with handles that are too small in my opinion. My ornament hollowing tools I currently have are too small so I need to make some new ones. You have to grip too hard and you should be relaxed when you turn.

I think the rubber handles like John J's and Johannes tools are excellent.

Re: handle comparison

#10

Harry Robinette

Re: handle comparison

Harry Robinette

I've been using Thompson tools and handles for a few years now.I have nerve damage in the backs of my thumbs and found the square round corners on the Thompson let's me hold the tools for a lot longer time.

I can turn for hour's again instead of 20 minutes then rest and massage my thumbs for 10 minutes. My Doc said it's because you grip the square/round corners differently then a round handle. Has helped me allot.

Re: handle comparison

#11

Re: handle comparison

John Scheideman

I love my Thompson tools and he makes a very nice handle (I have one). I also have a Bennett. I have to say that my favorite handle is Michelson's. It just fits your hand perfectly, feels very nice, and does not roll off the lathe when you set it down. It is also very easy to take the gouge out for sharpening. I have two of them and love them.

John

Re: handle comparison

#12

Bill Blasic

Re: handle comparison

Bill Blasic

Doug Thompson made foam handles, aluminum foam covered with his nose cone like on his non foam handles. I know he has some left I just don't know what sizes. Ask him.

Bill

P.S. This is the time of year that my 5/8 V is in the foam handle, close to zero here this AM.

Re: handle comparison

#13

Also a fan of the Michelsen 3 lobe handle

Dick Coers

now that I have a confident way to sharpen the gouge. I have the old style with the glue in tools. Haven't tried the new style.