Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

A response from Dr. Spalt....

Posts

A response from Dr. Spalt....

#1

A response from Dr. Spalt....

Barry Irby

I wrote to Dr. Sara Robinson (Dr. Spalt) mentioned in a post recently by Ralph asking her about the effects of spalting wood and the fungi one wood workers and the effect of rot fungi and whatever fungi that might be found on fecal matter in crawl spaces (I'm a Home Inspector and spend more than my fair share of time in dark dank crawl spaces where there is often mouse poop)

Her answer:

It's not the fungi you should be worried about, at least not the decay ones. Anything growing on wood and causing a fruiting body is a basidiomycete, and of no danger to you whatsoever. Even the molds that are growing on the surface of the wood are not much of a concern. They can cause allergic reactions in some people (just like a cat or dog might), but taking an antihistamine before doing an inspection would take care of that.

I would be infinitely concerned, however, about the fecal matter, and the fungi growing on that. A very VERY small percentage of fungi that grow on poo (or on soil with fecal matter) can have spores that affect the respiratory system of humans. I would suggest not doing inspections without a NIOSH 95 respirator (or higher, a 99 would be fantastic, but can be pricey - maybe business expense to deduct off your taxes?). The concern is compounded as you are a woodworker, and I'm guessing have not, for the majority of your woodworking career, utilized any type of respiratory protection. Wood dust is a major carcinogen as well as lung irritant. Years of exposure will have damaged your lungs and respiratory system, whether or not you have any symptoms right now. This could make you more sensitive to fungi as a whole, especially those (poo fungi), which have a very small chance of infecting your lungs.

Basically, take care of yourself from now on. Don't cut wood without your NIOSH respirator, and don't do inspections without one either. Your great-grandkids will thank you.

Sara C. Robinson

Assistant Professor, Anatomy of Renewable Materials

Department of Wood Science and Engineering

Oregon State University

119 Richardson Hall

Corvallis, OR 97331

I am having a hard time accepting how dangerous wood dust apparently is and wrote back to her, thanking her and asked again about the wood dust. She stressed it was a cumulative effect and that many lifelong wood workers don't show symptoms until in their sixty's. I was struck by the perceptive appearance of her comments, but it may just be that I fit the pattern. Many of us here are long time wood workers, never bothered with masks or other PPE, did not have dust collection, or Air Cleaners and are or approaching our sixty's. She sent a link to a PDF and I am posting it here. I have not read it, but I will.

http://ntp.niehs.nih.gov/ntp/roc/twelfth/profiles/WoodDust.pdf

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

#2

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

Ralph Lindberg

Barry

I wasn't concerned (about wood-dust) for years and years, then I started paying attention and noting how many of the "old timers" I knew that were stopping wood-working due to various lung issue.

Yup, a lot of them were also smokers, but not all.

So I decided that a powered hood was cheaper then a lung transplant and bought one.

Then my wife got interested in wood-working, and shortly afterward diagnosed with a genetic issue that was impairing her breathing.

So we bought a 2nd powered hood

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

#3

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

Skip Beardsley

Barry,

Which did you buy and do you like it. I am aware of being more sensitive to sanding dust when turning even though I have a dust collection port right by the lathe.

Skip

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

#4

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

Tony - Memphis

Good information - thanks! I guess I'm lucky that I was concerned about inhaling wood dust from day one. I've never bypassed wearing a mask or glasses. Something I'm very strict about. It blows my mind the number of folks that don't take any precaution. I was, however, stupid enough to smoke when I was young...no need to compound that mistake. I wear a mask even just in case - any time there might be airborne particles - glasses too..like cutting grass, working on brakes, etc.

Tony

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

#5

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

Bernie Rose

Barry,

I read the whole thing, and it appears to me that with the best of protection the odds of a carcinogenic event are comparable to driving home at 2:00 Am on January second after a New Years Eve party. Most of us will make it safely, but some won't.

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

#6

Re: A response from Dr. Spalt....

Ralph Lindberg

Skip, I'll chime in

We bought Trend Air-Shields, both the same model so the chargers, batteries, etc were all interchangeable.

IMO the Mercedes of them is the 3M AirStream.