Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

West System epoxy

Posts

West System epoxy

#1

West System epoxy

phillip Medghalchi

Can someone provide the info. as how to use this product in our trade. I went to their site (west system epoxy)and waht I saw was the directions for use in marine application. I can not find directions as how we as woodturners apply this wood to stablize a punky wood. In another thread Brad Viejo mentioned this and I think I have heard it b4 from somewhere els. Also Steven hatcher also uses it in his stablizing for his spalted big leaf maple pieces for his turnings. I have a spalted Pecan that I made a bowl out of and then used some Polycryl on the rest of it to stablize it, but that product did not deliver what is promised, and last night I had a blow out due to the weakness of the punky wood( i am fine and broken piece did not hit me. I was not in the direct line of fire as some of you may be concerned. I know better. and, this was not that red cedar bowl mentioned in my last thread either(that one is stil fine)( I try to post a picture of what the piece looks like later when I can take a pic. of it). ( The reason for my inquiry is that I have three big logs of this pecan and do not want to throw it away, and like to crate more stuff from it). I'd apprecaite any help or instructions you can provide.

Re: West System epoxy

#2

barry rockwell

Re: West System epoxy

Barry Rockwell

Phillip, I have had very good luck over the years using West Systems to stabilize wood both in the marine environment and with woodturning. First, mix the West Systems Epoxy per the Manufacturers instructions. I would advise using the "slow" catalyst as opposed to the "fast" catalyst. Mix 1 part epoxy mixture with 1 part MEK (Methyl Ethyl Ketone) creating a solution that is quite a bit thinner than water. Care must be taken as MEK is very volatile and the fumes aren't good for you. Put the piece of wood you are going to treat in some sort of plastic container, then proceed to pour the solution over it, preferably into the end grain. Continue for as long as your patience lasts, or until the piece absorbs no more solution, or until the epoxy begins to gel (probably too long). If the piece is small enough it can just be immersed in the solution for awhile. It's my opinion that this whole procedure, and until the epoxy has been set up for 24-48 hours, should be done out of doors because of all the fumes. Good luck.

Re: West System epoxy

#3

Re: West System epoxy

Jim Breeden

So having never used MEK, can it replace the hardner in the mix?

Re: West System epoxy

#4

Re: West System epoxy

phillip Medghalchi

Barry, first thank you for your reply. My qsn. then would be that I have managed to core out this bowl to about 1/2 thickness and it blew up wich I am going to epoxy it back to gether (since the piecesa are large enough to do it)and then where the joints are I am going to enhance them with some saw dust of another wood for the contrasting color and give it some design effect. next I will put the bowl in soem appropraite container to hold it and pour the mixture over it?

And, also, when I was on the West System's web site I understand that you have to get their hardner which comes in different no.s and also they have fillers too. So this MEK that you are referring to is in addition to these hardners or a substitution for them?

Lastly, I have rest of this lof in a half cut format and it's goos 24" -26" across the grain and about 30" long, so if I proceed to cut a blank out of it which can not be larger than 16" 9lathe capcity) now i dunk my whole blank without any tooling as a disk in this solution? or I have to proceed to rough turn it to the shape and then come back and dunk it in the solution.?

I apprecite if you can clarify this for me?

Re: West System epoxy

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: West System epoxy

Brad Vietje

HI Phillip,

I got your e-mail too late to call you tonight, so I'll try for tomorrow.

I've used West System Epoxy for boat repairs, and for filling cracks and holding things together (like a very strong glue), though not in the past 2 years. I have never used it with Methyl-Ethyl Ketone (MEK) to make a low-viscosity wood hardener, so I have no experience there. I have used Minwax Wood Hardener, but I'm not a big fan, since that stuff is really toxic; sounds like the MEK mix is pretty bad for you, too.

The West System stuff can be pretty expensive. You get a volume of epoxy resin (#105), and a smaller quantity of hardener, which you select based on working time, or use #207 for clear. These components come with a pump that replaces the cap on the can, which is used to measure the correct ratio to get the stuff to harden correctly. The wrong ratio won't just take too long, or harden too fast -- in some cases it will remain gooey and never harden, so the ratio needs to be be measured pretty precisely. Some people have experimented with tinting the mix, or using glitter or other substances, too.

While West System epoxy is not the only good option, it is tried and true and very rugged stuff. However, it may cost significantly more than the wood is worth, if you have good sources of wood. If you NEED to save blanks that have value to you (making gifts from an historically important tree, for example), it can be a very good option. If instead, you need to find better sources of cheap or free wood so you can throw away stuff that is punky, that is a whole 'nuther conversation.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: West System epoxy

#6

barry rockwell

Re: West System epoxy

Barry Rockwell

To answer the first question, the MEK is not a substitute for the hardener (catalyst) but only an agent to thin the already catalyzed resin to a viscosity thinner than water to make it easier for the punky wood to absorb it. I have never used this method on large chunks of wood, only smaller damaged "dry rot" areas in marine use and medium to small rough turned pieces of wood. The expense would be prohibitive for immersing larger chunks or turnings because there would be a considerable amount of waste. Pouring the solution over and into a roughed out piece would seem the best solution. MEK is a pretty powerful solvent so I have no idea what effect it would have on CA glue or any other kind of glue. A small experiment would probably be a good first step in that case. Hope this helps.

Re: West System epoxy

#7

Re: West System epoxy

John Lucas

Brad nailed it. Sometimes you have to throw in the towel and say why am I wasting my time on this piece of wood. Not to mention the expense. Epoxy is expensive. Last time I bought some it was about $80 for a quart of epoxy hardener and new pumps.

I have done a lot of the repairs your talking about. They do work but in reality the time it takes to mix up the epoxy let it dry,turn it, fill in all the voids or bubbles that appear, turn it again, fill in a few more bubbles, turn it again, Heck I could have roughed out 3 or 4 bowls or maybe turned one or two to completion out of good wood.

Granted it's hard to let go of a piece and sometimes saving it is actually worth it, or you learn some valuable technique.

So even though I've done all you are talking about I lean now much more toward John Jordan's admonition, Life is too short to turn crappy wood.

You have to ask yourself is this piece of wood so special that it's worth the effort and expense to save it. That's the bottom line.

Re: West System epoxy

#8

To complicate this even further...

Barry Irby

I would have thought someone would have suggested using a vacuum tank to force the solution into the wood. Some sort of sturdy container, pour in the liquid, submerge the bowl, seal and suck out the air. Wait for the bubbles to stop. I have never done it and don't think I would try it, for all the reasons John Lucas and John Jordan (by attribution) mentioned. This would require an expensive set up and probably even more epoxy. I have a vacuum pump and don't think I want to suck MEK and epoxy fumes through it. The MEK might boil. and there is absolutely no reason the blank might not explode again.

John J is right, life is too short to turn crappy wood. And, turning crappy wood can shorten your life.

Re: West System epoxy

#10

Cactus Juice Stabilizer *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

I haven't tried this stuff yet but it might be what you need. There are a bunch of Youtube videos showing how to use it.


Cactus Juice Stabilizer

Re: West System epoxy

#11

barry rockwell

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

Barry Rockwell

I've got to say that I totally agree with all the comments by others about the value of crappy wood. It's been a long time since I've tried to salvage or repair a piece of wood. The time wasted would be better spent looking for quality timber. Even with my stock of rough turned pieces, as soon as a defect appears it goes to the firewood pile or to someone who wants to take the time to baby it along. The process I described definitely works, but as others have said, you've got to ask yourself if it's worth the money and time.

Re: West System epoxy

#12

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

John Lucas

I sat through the demo in Texas and it's impressive stuff. Probably not very practical for bowls due to the expense but he sure had some beautiful pen blanks.

Re: West System epoxy

#13

Polyall 2000 *LINK*

Bill Howatt

Some of our club members highly recommend Polyall 2000 for stabilizing punky wood. I have used it only once just recently on a maple bowl that had a lot of spalting and some spots were very soft.

It is very thin so it soaks in well and you must be careful to mix only a little bit since it hardens in just a couple of minutes. It sure fixed my soft area problem. Can't say it smelled real great.

Bill


Polyall 2000 Site

Re: West System epoxy

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

Brad Vietje

That may be a very reasonable middle ground.

When I started turning, I would go to great lengths to "save" pieces of wood because they seemed hard to come by. But I live in a Garden of Eden as far as sourcing local wood goes, and often I get good stuff for free. In my location, I can get -- literally -- tons of perfectly good hardwood (Sugar Maple, Red Maple, Yellow Birch, Black Cherry, Apple, White Ash, etc., etc...) I have good friends that are consulting foresters, loggers, and guys that sell firewood for a living. After about 6 months of looking around, and keeping my eyes and ears open, I had more wood than I could use, and I got a LOT more selective about what I was willing to save. If it has cracks, I either burn it, or split it along the checks, and turn smaller items from between the cracks.

For the past 12 years or so, I end up having to get rid of excess wood that I'll never have a chance to turn.

I realize that not everyone is lucky enough to be surrounded by forests and foresters, so the wood supply game can be radically different if you have very few trees, or need to buy turning wood and have it shipped to you -- that is expensive. I'll happily help people anywhere near me find wood, if they'd like, but with the recent problems with Emerald Ash Borer, shipping untreated wood is a real no-no, so I won't be shipping any fresh wood around the country.

I'd still make an effort to save an heirloom or rare piece of wood, but I can find a LOT of White Ash around here, and they're all going to bite the big one when the EAB beetles move in over the next few years... :\

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: West System epoxy

#15

Ric Taylor

Re: West System epoxy

Ric Taylor

Barry,

Are you saying that after mixing the resin and hardener together, you then mix in the MEK before it sets up?

Can you give some idea of how much MEK you mix in to how much of the resin/hardener mix?

Thanks,

Ric

Re: West System epoxy

#16

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

John Leonard

I have tried it on bowls and it worked ok on a small bowl, i.e. 3' diamenter. But not worth a hoot on 4" diamenter and larger. It takes a lot of the C. J. to cover a 7-1/2 inch and 3" high bowl and the C.J. is $90 a gallon and it will take most of a gallon to cover that size bowl.

Re: West System epoxy

#17

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

phillip Medghalchi

Stuart, I konw Curtis Seabec(owner of Cactus juice)I have been to his shop and i have seen it at work, however, it's only good for small stuff like penbalnks, otherwise we discussed it that it would be too coslty to do it for balnks alike 16" in Diam. Plus to make tha chamber that size to accomodate the balnk cost lots of money.

Re: West System epoxy

#18

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

phillip Medghalchi

Brad, so I can not bribe to send me soem huh? :D

Re: West System epoxy

#19

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

phillip Medghalchi

John, exactly that.

Re: West System epoxy

#20

Re: West System epoxy

phillip Medghalchi

To every one I appreciate your replies and insites. They are valuble lessons. however, if you guys can spare soem of your good wood, I;ll be happy to pay for the shipping to me and i can send you guys Mesquite that will not grow in your area. Ask John lUcas I think he got soem last time he was in TX it's a very nice and forgiving wood to tuen and heck you don't have to spend ar and a leg to reapir it. I cna slo send you guys the mesquite chips for BBQing if any one interested. If you haven't had any mesquite BBQ, you have missed out a lot. :b

Re: West System epoxy

#21

barry rockwell

Re: West System epoxy

Barry Rockwell

Ric,

I've always used one part catalyzed resin to one part MEK.

Re: West System epoxy

#22

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

Stuart Johnson

Would a setup to use it on larger items be more of a beginning cost rather than on going? The cost for a container and a couple gallons of juice would be high but from that point on couldn't you just top off the amount used? Of course for some reason you would want to turn many pieces of junky wood.

Re: West System epoxy

#23

Re: Cactus Juice Stabilizer

phillip Medghalchi

Stuart, very valid point I think I forgot to ask him about this scenario. He doesn't pick up the ohone that often so i try to send him an email to see if he would respond to that

Re: West System epoxy

#24

Re: West System epoxy

Roy Girolami

All this talk of MEK got me worried. This is bad stuff. You need some heavy duty protective equipment and definitely goggles when you are around it. I remember a letter back in the FWW black and white days where a woodworker said he was using MEK and splashed some accidentally in his eye. Lost his eye. So if you are going to use it, be very careful.

Roy

Re: West System epoxy

#25

Re: West System epoxy

phillip Medghalchi

Roy no worries. I am not going to mes with it. it sounds too risky trying to preserve something that is not too valuable. Thanks for the heads up.