So a few days ago I had a large blank fracture. (There was a weak sap line in the cherry as it turned out) Thankfully the fractured piece missed missed me but destroyed a flourescent shop light!
So I am thinking about a helmet. A repirator one would be nice but my wallet is thin. Are there any dust/helmets out there that work OK and don't break the bank?
It will break the bank initially but in the long run, in my opinion, well worth it. Comfortable with good face, lung, and head protection. You can save some cash by getting it without the battery and charger and doing the Li battery retrofit described previously.
You did ask for a DUST helmet, but the context was about the danger of an IMPACT from a piece of wood going ballistic. These are two VERY different critters. Please send a private message to Mr. Steven Antonucci if you need to know more...
If you search the archives for discussions about "helmets", "crash helmets", "riot helmets", "hockey helmets" and such, you will find lots of lively reading from the past 6 months or so.
My recollection of the Reader's Digest version of the whole she-bang is that there really IS no great solution yet that gives great protection to your lungs as well as the face and skull connected to them. The well-known brands are good for DUST, but only so-so for impacts, and not specifically designed or tested for impact protection at all.
Steve had some great ideas, like commissioning a crash helmet manufacturer to work with wood turners to design a protective crash helmet that could also keep the gunk out of your lungs (again, if I remember correctly).
I'd like to read of any solutions that meet both criteria -- at this point, I don't know of any
Adrien knows what the helmet is good for and what it isn't good for.
I have no issues with its use in light weight situations or as a dust helmet. Both cases, it will help in an accident. I pointed Adrien at Alan's video for the battery conversion because it is a great upgrade to that system.
Adrien knows better than anyone here what can happen in a high energy collision. It was his accident that I reported.
Lauren and I will not be able to attend the NJ Woodturners club meeting this month (1/27). We are demoing at the Bucks county club that evening. This weekend (1/11) we are demoing at the Long Island Woodturners club. Busy month!
do you have a source for a comparable Litium Ion battery since the Tekkeon is discontinued. I cannot find any that are both 2.1 AMP and 5 volt. 1.2 amp yes, 3 amp, sometimes ... What do you, the expert, suggest?
I have no desire to start this whole discussion again but I think we should be careful with our message when someone (maybe a newbie) asks for safety advice.
In my opinion, the Airstream unit is a viable piece of personal protective equipment for turning. It offers excellent air filtration, as well as ANSI rated eye and head protection. As has been discussed in this forum several times, it will not stop an 80 pound blank dismounting a lathe but it sure will soften the blow.
I do not think we should down play the advantages of this or other PPE because it will not provide complete protection from a worst case incident. This is the wrong message. As I have written in the past, all PPE choices should be part of overall hazard assesment for the task at hand.
I think the Airstream is one of the better options out there for the turning I do. The primary down side is the absurd cost.
I think we should never discourage someone from using one of the best options available, but I think we need to be ABSOLUTELY clear that while these air filtering helmets will provide some level of protection, they have not been tested or rated as impact helmets.
Take home message: they will certainly help, but they should not be relied upon to protect your noggin -- they are simply not designed for that. Any other message is simply dishonest -- or false advertizing -- and could lead to a severe injury if ones expectations are not in line with that reality. To be safe, you still need to keep away from the firing line, and take a number of other precautions, and even so, accidents can still happen.
It's OK to tell someone these units may be the best compromise currently available, but it is NOT OK to lead someone to think this is a crash helmet that will prevent head injuries -- that simply is not true.
Indeed, use the best option available & campaign for a better awareness and understanding of what the standards marks actually mean. I am not a supporter of riot gear style helmets as we should never be experiencing that level of impact - ever! Far better to learn to assess and reduce risk and use sensible safety gear & PPE.
Testing against the relevent standards for both eye, impact and dust filtration is self managed by the manufacturer and overseen by the standards authority. I don't believe any govt authority actuall checks compliance with the standard. If a product carries the "approval" or "certification" stamp the manufacturer is claiming that the product meets the minimum standard as specified in the relevant standard and must be able to justify the claim legally as it will eventually be tested in a court in our increasingly litigious society.
The older Purelite / Trends did meet low (medium?) impact standards depending upon the relevant standard. Not sure about the newer ones will have to check.