Parting Tool?
Tom
As I get ready to order some new tools I was wondering what size parting tool to start off with? My old,old, old! Craftsmen set had a 1/8" tool. As I am getting back into it I was wondering if 1/8" would be a good starter.
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Parting Tool?
Tom
As I get ready to order some new tools I was wondering what size parting tool to start off with? My old,old, old! Craftsmen set had a 1/8" tool. As I am getting back into it I was wondering if 1/8" would be a good starter.
Thanks!
That 1/8" width is a typical size.......
JamieDonaldson
....for most average sized turning use. If you're turning smaller projects you can add a smaller width as needed, but those are specialty tools.
Re: Parting Tool?
Mike Stafford
Tom, you didn't say but most of the 1/8" Craftsman parting tools were actually 3/32" and are diamond shaped. Some are High Speed Steel and some are not.
If the tool you have blues easily when you sharpen it the steel may only be carbon steel. It is still a good tool but if you get it too hot while sharpening it will not hold an edge for long.
I love the my Craftsman diamond shaped parting tools. A few years ago when Sears discontinued their turning tools I went around and bought all the HSS parting tools I could find. Now I have a bucket full.
Re: Amen!
Dennis in Southern Oregon
I too started out with one of the old Craftsman 3/32 diamond parting tools and used it until it wore to a nub. I looked for a long time before I found a 3/32 HSS PT to replace it. It is my go to tool for small items and is almost worn out now. Guess I will have to start searching again.
Dennis
same here... no reason to buy another
Re: Parting Tool?
Michael Gibson
I had the same craftsman diamond parting tool as well, mine had reached the point where l needed a new one. I read several posts which praised Doug Thompsons new parting tool and as I was going to be at a symposium where he was going to be l decided to give one of his a try. Not being diamond shape l was a little hesitant but was very surprised how good it was. Michael.
I'll second that.......
Jesper, Denmark
.....but I still have an old Crown flatsided one too. Useful when a wider cut is needed.
I'll third that...
Don Leydens
There is nothing wrong at all with the Craftsman parting tool, but I have since really come to enjoy using Doug's parting tool. Holds an edge for a long time.
I'll 4th it if you can do that
John Lucas
I finally parted with my Craftsman tool and am using the Thompson. I do miss having the narrower kerf but I really like my Thompson. In fact my older sorby diamond parting tool rarely gets used.
I do use my $2.50 off brand 1/4" wide flat carbon steel parting tool because it simply works better for turning the tenons on my mirror handles. I use a 3/8" wrench as a measuring gauge and it's hair wider than the thompson parting tool. I should probably just grind the wrench down narrower but just haven't done it yet.
Speaking of a wrench....
Barry Irby
John, Have you sharpened the wrench? I ahd a project where I needed about fifty tenons all at 3/8". I ground back one jaw o a old cheap wrench and then sharpened it like a scraper. Cut the tenon close by eye and the slider thww wrench onto it and shave it down. Worked great, very consistent. If you haven't done it, you should with as many mirrors as you make.
Re: Speaking of a wrench....
John Lucas
Barry I did but didn't like it. You have to be really concientious about pulling up on the dull side of the wrench or is it simply keeps on cutting and makes the tenon undersize. I got used to using dial calipers and a parting tools for production of parts needing lots of different tenons and it just carries over to the mirrors except I use the wrench for it.
Hmm, I did not have that problem....
Barry Irby
I wonder what I did differently from you. I ground the cutting Jaw back more that half the diameter of the tenon and then sharpened it. I tried just sharpening one jaw , but I could not get it to work consistently. Shortening the jaw made all the difference. You are right though, as I recall I had to pull up the long jaw and then shove it forward. A very little practice and Bob's you uncle.
thin vrs thick
Ralph Lindberg
I can honestly see the need for two, a thick one for heavy cuts and a thin one for things like parting the lid off a box/bowl.
With thin ones there are two styles, your typical thin chunk of HSS with a handle, these are often just cut from a larger piece of stock.and
Then there is the machined ones, with these the cutter is actually slightly wider then the upper part (the parting tool is used wide-side down). This allows the cutter to leave enough kerf for the remainder of the blade, without having to do a relief cut, or risking a catch during a deep part.
We (DW and I) had been sharing one narrow kerf parting tool for a couple years now, with us both needing it at the same time now and again.
So, when we were returning home from an all-day class we stopped at Dave's home (D-Way), to drop of a box of his turnings he accidentally left at the previous months club meeting. While we were there I bought us an anniversary present, a D-Way thin parting tool.
Dave says this tool produces the most "waste" steel of any of his tools, since it has to be milled down from a larger piece of stock.
But we both love it.... 
Re: thin vrs thick
John Lucas
Ralph You are so right. I have parting tools from about 3/32 up to 1/4" and occasionally would find a 1/2" very useful if I had it. fortunately thin parting tools are easy to come buy. I have one I made from a paring knife, One made from an industrial hacksaw blade, and one made from a old butcher knife.
I'm working on a design to build one from metal working HSS cutoff tools. I made a special holder for it.
Jimmy Clewes says you don't need a diamond parting tool. A freshly sharpened flat tool like the thompson will cut straight in because the burr is larger than the blade. I've been playing with that and it does work I just don't always want to freshly sharpen my blade just before a cut so the Jury's still out on that one. I do like my diamond parting tool for deep cuts but you do have to take care and sharpen it so the widest part of the tool is where the sharp point is.
Re: Hmm, I did not have that problem....
Michael Gibson
John l also use a wrench to cut tenons and as long as l pull up against the dull side l do not have a problem. What l like most using the wrench is if you use say a 3/8 wrench it is a perfect fit after drilling with a 3/8 bit.
Michael
Re: thin vrs thick
Bill Howatt
I have a 1/16" thick Firmager tool I bought from LV years ago. Anything exotic about the Firmager cutting edge is long gone as I just sharpen it like a parting tool and it is my favorite parting tool even if I don't need a thin kerf such as for a box lid. I do use the wider diamond-shape tool for things like chuck tenons.
I find that it reduces tearout on the bottom of the workpiece compared to the regular diamond parting tool although I"ll admit maybe more attention to sharpening might alleviate some of that but I feel, being narrower, it is grabbing less of the fiber when it is cutting.
Bill
Re: Hmm, I did not have that problem....
Barry Irby
That is exactly my experience. I thought a 3/8" wrench was slightly over sized, but I have not bothered to measure one accurately, Whatever they measure, I get the exact fit I wanted.