Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

need coloring advice

Posts

need coloring advice

#1

need coloring advice

GaryG in MD

OK, here's the deal.

It's probably too late, but I thought I'd ask...

I turned a nice maple bowl.

I thought I wanted to keep it lighter in color and not yellow it with an oil finish.

So I put on several coats of Minwax Water-Based Poly.

Now it looks kind of dull and plain and a kindn of "dishwater" color.

Never again. I wish I had just used oil.

So now what. I'm not happy with it, and I need to do something.

Is it too late to add some color or some form of darkening over the top of the WBP?

Will anything stick to it if I "rough" it up to some level such as, say, 600?

Am I taking a chance of just making a worse mess? Yes, of course I am.

What can I do with some reasonable probability of success?

I'd like some answers from people who have actually tried some sort of accent or color or alternate finish over the top of WBP.

TIA, GG

Re: need coloring advice

#2

Re: need coloring advice

John Lucas

It's been my experience water based poly yellows less than oil in fact the old stuff left a sort of blue cast that was t yellow enough for most woodworkers.

It will be a fair amount of work sanding it down but shouldn't be a problem.

Re: need coloring advice

#3

Re: need coloring advice

Dale Gillaspy

What John said. You can sand it down, but don't just scuff it at 600. You need to get down to bare wood. I'd start at 150 and work through the grits again.

Re: need coloring advice

#4

There will be enough finish .....

JamieDonaldson

...penetration that minor sanding and expecting any color penetration will be futile, and create a blotchy mess. I wouldn't attempt to redo this piece, and consider it a learning experience for the future, unless you're willing to apply paint! >(

Re: need coloring advice

#5

thanks, Jamie...

GaryG in MD

That was my fear.

Blotchy would be even worse than blah. ...GG

Re: need coloring advice

#6

John, Dale...

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your thoughts, but I think Jamie is right -- I wouldn't have much left if I sanded it far enough down to get rid of all evidence of the finish, and if I didn't, it would be blotchy. I guess I'm going to just have to accept it for what it is. ...GG

Re: need coloring advice

#7

Re: John, Dale...

Karen F.

Maybe this is a carving possibility! It could be a design opportunity.

Re: need coloring advice

#8

What kind of color?

Dick Coers

Nothing says you can't dust on some acrylic paint with an air brush. Maybe even try some alcohol based dye, applied the same way. It's just not going to soak into the wood, but you can add color.

Re: need coloring advice

#9

Re: need coloring advice

phillip Medghalchi

Gary, what ever you do don't through it away. I have left my pieces that at the time I was not happy with :( alone and out of the way. Then came back to it as I learned some more techniques and honed my knowledge, and reshaped and redesigned it with much better success. Sometimes when you get to that point it's best to walk away form the trouble and let some time pass. I am sure you will come back to it with a beter answer in few days or few month. If wose comes to worse cut in half and then collage it with the other accidental pieces and make a wall hanging art piece out of it. then you can call it new work. :b

Re: need coloring advice

#10

Joe Fleming

Re: A couple of choices

Joe Fleming

Gary,

My first choice is to leave it as it is. A second choice is to airbrush some dye. You will need to sand the finish (600 will work). You cannot wipe the dye on, but light airbrushing will work. Just to no over apply the material or it will run. Once it dries, spray lacquer over the top. Light coats to seal the color, then you can use heavier coats. Sand and polish the lacquer.

A third choice might be gel stain, but eliminating wiping or brush marks will be difficult.

For both of these, make a couple of samples and try it before application. Finish the samples like the bowl, then go at it.

Having said all of that, that is a lot of work for iffy improvements. Did I say leave it as is? I think Jamie is right.

Joe

Re: need coloring advice

#11

Karen, Dick, Phillip, and Joe,

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your thoughts and advice.

All good.

I think I'll take Phillip's and Joe's approach for now and "sleep on it", for an indefinite period.

It's not a bad bowl; I rather like the form -- wide, beaded rim, heavily undercut.

It's just the (lack of) color that's bugging me.

The valuable lesson I've learned is that I like the bland, nondescript color of maple even less than oil-yellowed maple. I'll certainly keep that in mind for the future. ...GG

Re: need coloring advice

#12

Re: Karen, Dick, Phillip, and Joe,

John Lucas

Gary Take a small piece of scrap of the same wood if you have it. Apply finish, let it dry and then sand it down and try your other finish over it. that way you could see what happens without jeopardizing your bowl. I often do that when I want to play with a new finish I haven't used and need to try something unusual for a project that is reaching the finishing stage. No reason to risk the real project if you don't have to.

Re: need coloring advice

#13

Re: Karen, Dick, Phillip, and Joe,

phillip Medghalchi

Gary send me a PM I have an idea you may want to try.

Re: need coloring advice

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Karen, Dick, Phillip, and Joe,

Brad Vietje

Gary,

If you store it for later, you may not tackle it for a number of years, so I'd suggest finding a way to label it so you can remember what has already been done to it.

I've pulled out some oldies but not-so-goodies, but couldn't remember for sure what finish had already been applied.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: need coloring advice

#15

Re: There will be enough finish .....

Lloyd in Mississauga

Jamie is quite correct. There is a bit of the water base that seems to hold tight and you really do not see it until you apply the oil, and you end up with white areas where the oil can not get past the left over water base finish.

I have had this issue with more than a few pieces that were sort of complete and then changed my mind for similar reasons. I always figured I had sanded enough, but nope.....

I kind of like the air brush idea and will likely try that one the next one.

Re: need coloring advice

#16

excellent suggestion


Re: need coloring advice

#17

that is so true!