Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Banjo Question...sorta'

Posts

Banjo Question...sorta'

#1

Keith Tompkins

Banjo Question...sorta'

Keith Tompkins

The banjo post, and the recent "creativity" thread on WOW has got me thinking...how much can skill, talent, or creativity be credited to genetics, and how much to plain old perseverance and hard work? I think we all have our strong points and weak points, but is there any substitute for natural ability? Can it be attributed to nature or nuture?

What do you think?

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#2

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

john Veerkamp

Yes.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#3

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

matt overton

I think there needs to be some initial "nature", but inquizativeness and environment have lots to do with it. I have found myself seeking creative avenues such as collaboratives and courses to allow me to be open to grow. Sharing with like minds is a big key to being creative IMHO.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#4

Steven Antonucci

no matter how much I played, I never dunked

steven antonucci

To some extent, you can assume that there needs to be something there to grow into... cannot create something from nothing.

Nurturing helps us connect with the inner talents we possess...and also points out the things we will never be any good at no matter what our hearts desire. Sometimes, giving up is probably the right answer...even if it seems like the wrong thing to do.

I may be able to be better at drawing or music, but I will never be GOOD at either. They just aren't in me...

S

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#5

Re: Learning Creativity

Steve Criscenzo

I think it has to start with nature and some “natural born” talent but with perseverance I hope we can “learn” things like creativity.

I cannot sing a lick, can’t carry a tune and don’t even try to sing even alone in the shower. I think that you have to be born with some talent to develop a good singing voice. However, I have a friend who is a voice coach and he insists that he can teach anyone to sing. He says he has never had a failure so maybe there is a parallel with artistic creativity.

I am an engineer and tend to use logical and linear thinking. I can quickly learn turning skills from reading, or watching a demo. I struggle however with creativity and with creating pleasing form. I am actively trying to nurture my "creative" side. I seek advice and opinion from my more artistic friends and attend sessions such as the one on “creativity” offered by Keith Tompkins at the Greensboro symposium. I have also started keeping a sketch/idea notebook to plan out ideas prior to stepping up to the lathe and often take pictures of pleasing forms for later study. Time will tell if I am successful. (or maybe I will just learn to sing).

Steve

P.S. There is a great series on creativity on “Ted Talks”.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#6

Creativity challenge for ya.

Ray - Middletown, IN

I recently completed a MOOC on Creativity, Innovation, and Change and without getting into whether they are good or not one of the first challenges was to make the tallest freestanding tower you can from a single 8 1/2 x 11 sheet of paper. Not a contest but an exercise in creative thinking. Try and fail, try and fail over and over until you reach some conclusion. Use many approaches (and a lot of paper that will be well suited for fire starting)

Ray

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#7

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

Sergio

Really interesting that education, exposure to certain craft or art etc has not been mentioned...

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

Lyle Jamieson

Its all learnable. I quote Frank Sudol often, "You have to do 1000 bowls to get good at it, and I don't mean 999!!"

Some it will take 1000, some will take 30 but if you stand at the lathe long enough it will come. I'm a good example that it does not take talent. My first bowls looked like dog dishes. I had to learn the technical skills and I had to learn design elements of shape and scale.

As Phil Robertson says, " I'm a C+ man, half of us are smarter then me, but I'm smarter then the rest of you, I'm in a pretty good place here". But I had to learn it. If I can do it anybody can do it.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

Keith Tompkins

Lyle, you certainly have a point. You are correct, nearly anyone can learn to turn a bowl. Many will get pretty good at it. However, the work you are known for is far beyond "turning a bowl". Not many would even attempt to attempt to duplicate your multi-axis hollow forms...let alone come up with the idea. Even the equipment you use to create your signature work didn't exist until you fabricated the first one. So, I believe you are a good example of someone with a high level of natural creative ability.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Learning Creativity

Keith Tompkins

HI Steve, Glad you made it to my demo! I've found that spending time with other creative type people leads to a certain "synergy"...often two people will come up with an idea that neither would have individually. Do you think the scrapbook is helping? :)

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Thanks

Lyle Jamieson

I still hold to the belief it only takes desire and anybody can do "it". Not any one element of the sculptures I do is difficult, but there are a lot of things happening all on one piece before its done. I can have a week planning time before I even touch the piece of wood or lathe. I know...not everyone can hit an hundred MPH fastball but most of us could be pretty good baseball players if we wanted to pay the price to learn and practice it.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#12

Exposure

Craig Daymon

I would think a key element to creativity is exposure to a diverse range of work, not necessarily restricted to the specific field of interest. Cross pollination of ideas has spurred more than few new developments. Even though many will argue that there is "nothing new under the sun", there actually is, or at the very least, new ways to look at / think about things. Sure, you may see elements derived from other places, but the composite result may be truly unique...least for a short while.

If you only ever show your turnings to your mother, odds are no matter how poorly finished or turned, you will be told it is wonderful. Sometimes, a mediocre job even gets passed off as having that "rustic" look that means it was hand done. In some cases, that can be done to great effect, but to anyone seeking to improve, should not be used as an excuse to continue doing mediocre work.

Seek out honest criticism where people are willing to describe what it is that they see wrong with a piece. You don't necessarily have to agree, but that can be part of the conversation as well. If you can justify your design decisions, you can give legitimacy to the approach.

With respect to turning, look at historic turnings, look at pottery, sculpture, glass blowing, river rocks, NASA planetary images, flowers, clouds, anything with a shape, especially if elements are round.

Part of exposure is willingness to open your eyes (and ears) to what is already around you with a willingness to understand and look at it from all sides.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#13

Re: Exposure

Bernie Rose

Where in this spectrum is there a place for those of us who are happy to achieve mediocrity ?

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#14

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Exposure

Lyle Jamieson

Good point...Most turners are not making a living at turning. If you decide to settle for a partly finished piece or pay attention to details to the "N-th" degree, you are still a success. Its all about the fun. Enjoy the time you have at the lathe. Follow the fun, no matter where it leads you.

Re: Banjo Question...sorta'

#15

Re: Exposure

Craig Daymon

I think mediocrity is a sad way to approach anything you enjoy. To me, it does not mean that you are striving to be a "professional", or even have any interest in selling things. What I am talking about is simply to strive to do the best you can at the present time and try to do it a little better the next time.

Maybe that's simply getting a fair curve on your bowl. (I say, "simply", but getting a fair curve is something I struggle with.) Maybe it's making a hollowform without blowing through the side or bottom. Maybe the first time you succeed you leave the walls 1/2" thick, which is pretty thick. Do you then sit back and only make hollowforms with thick walls?

When you buy a new tools, do you assume it will magically allow you to turn better pieces or do you put effort into getting a good result from that tool? How do you find how to do it better? Why do you bother to read the posts here in the turning section?

Maybe you don't want to attend a symposium or pay to see Lyle demonstrate. Maybe you don't belong to the local turning group because you don't want to pay the membership. Maybe you never show your work to anyone, you just make it because it seemed cheaper than buying dishes and you don't mind splinters in your spaghetti.

Sorry, but I just find it hard to believe that anyone that in any way strives to learn more about turning (or next to anything) strives to be mediocre. This isn't something you're doing to get a passing grade to get out of high school. You chose to do it.

This has nothing to do with striving to make a living doing it. Selling things is not in and of itself a measure of quality or making something deserving of praise. There are plenty of snuggies/slankets sold, but I don't expect to see one hanging on the walls of the Guggeheim.