Approximate hardness
Dale Miner
O-1, the most cost effective drill rod in the annealed state is approximately 190 to 210 brinell. That is equivalant to approximately 15 Rockwell C.
Cold rolled steel (1018 ) is approximately 120 brinell, or a bit softer than annealed drill rod. Hot rolled steel is more variable than cold rolled, but averages about the same hardness.
O-1 can be hardened to nearly 65 Rockwell C by heating above the trasformation temperature ( 1500f )and quenching in oil. This will result in the maximum hardness possible and the maximum brittleness. Usually, tooling is tempered back from max hardness to reduce the brittleness and make the tooling workable. Tempering temperatures vary depending on the application. For cutting tools, tempering to about 55 to 62 Rockwell C is done.
It is possible to purchase Pre Hardened drill rod, and usually the drill rod will be furnished at about 35 to 40 Rockwell C. At this hardness level, it is possible to machine with dififculty compared to annealed drill rod. At this hardness level, use for cutting tools is not practical, but is often used for forming tools.
Most HSS woodturning tools are somewhere in the range of 60 to 62 Rockwell C, much harder that annealed drill rod and still harder than prehard drill rod. Tooling with a hardness of 62 Rockwell can cut material with a hardness of 40 Rockwell, but with a shortened edge life compared to cutting material with a 200 Brinell hardness.