Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Tool Rest Question

Posts

Tool Rest Question

#1

Tool Rest Question

Tom

The other day while looking in the Articles Section I came across one article about making a tool rest. The author used bar stock and then epoxied drill rod to the edge with 5 minute epoxy making a fillet on each side. The welded the bar to a round cylinder for the post.

What do you guys think?

Re: Tool Rest Question

#2

Re: Tool Rest Question

John Lucas

I would just use drill rod for the whole thing. Buy a section of drill rod that fits your banjo. You'll probably have to buy 3 feet. Cut off the length you want and then weld it on.

If you already have the flat bar stock then it's not a bad idea to weld or glue the drill rod to the top. Drill rod is usually harder than flat stock so it won't dent as easily.

Re: Tool Rest Question

#3

Lyle Jamieson

another opinion

Lyle Jamieson

I don't like round tool rests because they force the support away from the surface before you even start an overhang.

I make my tool rests with cold rolled flat stock. I do not use drill rod or any other hardened material. I can easily file and clean up any damage to my soft tool rest. I want the tool rest softer then my tools. I do not want a hardened tool rest damaging my tools. Boring bars, parting tools skews etc. are susceptible to dimpling, getting dinged up from the tool rest. Any tool that gets bumps in it will not slide along the tool rest easily and smoothly.

Re: Tool Rest Question

#4

Wooden Tool Rest - Seriously

Doc Green

I made a small, thin-profile tool rest out of wood and music wire. Step-by-step instructions here:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/toolrest.html

I know this tool rest would not be strong enough for general turning, but for small items like globe-type tree ornaments and finials, it works like a charm.

~Doc

Re: Tool Rest Question

#5

Re: Tool Rest Question

Bill Jacksonville, NC

When drill rod spot welded to my tool rest came off call manufacturer. Had a choice between new tool rest or epoxy it back on. So bought the brand of black epoxy recommended mixed well and waited 24 hours before using. More of a job cleaning old tool surface than actual glue up,

Still have that epoxy just cannot find it today. Made that repair year or two back, maybe someone will post product name.

Re: Tool Rest Question

#6

Re: Tool Rest Question

Dwight Rutherford

Was it JB Weld? Have used for many years, always works!

Re: Tool Rest Question

#7

Re: Tool Rest Question

robo hippy

I prefer the drill rod on my tool rests. Main reason is that the tools slide so easily over the rest. Much less resistance than any other metal, no matter how smooth you sand it or how much wax you put on it. There is no maintenance required. One of my older Robust straight rests fell on the floor a while back, and landed on the drill rod which popped off. I got some JB Weld, set a bead on the rest, put the drill rod back on, used blue tape to hold it on, and then let it cure. Took the tape off, and took it to a wire wheel that I keep on one of my grinders. Good as new, except I didn't paint the JB Weld black.

I do not like the round bar stock for tool rests. I have a couple that are 1 inch diameter, and they just feel wrong.

If you have welding skills, some 3/8 thick bar stock, maybe 1 to 1 1/2 inch wide would work. I don't know for sure, but drill rod can be difficult to weld, and bend. My only real metal skills are sharpening and grinding.

robo hippy

Re: Tool Rest Question

#8

drill rod unhardened is not hard on tools

John Lucas

When you buy drill rod it comes annealed. It is pretty hard as is and will take a lot of abuse without dinging. I have never had a problem with it damaging tools. You can harden it of course if you wanted to but would need a good oven to do anything more than a couple of inches.

Re: Tool Rest Question

#9

Re: Tool Rest Question

ron bauer

I believe that drill rod has at least three hardening methods. It comes to you in a fully workable condition, not hardened. It is called either of O-1 (oil hardened), A-1 (air hardened) or W-1 (water hardened). I use O-1. Most people do not have the capability of hardening the rods because of the need for high temps for long periods and then tempering after to get toughness. There are many shapes of bar stock of the same material, such as O-1. You will get the same workability and surface from the bars as you do the rods. You probably will not be hardening a piece as large as a tool rest anyway. IMHO. Ron.

Re: Tool Rest Question

#10

Re: Safety Concern

Steve Criscenzo

I am all for fabricating my own fixtures and jigs. I have made many of my own. I do worry however about homemade tool rests. There is considerable torque on the ends of tool rests, particularly as they get longer. The consequences of a failure could be severe. I do not weld myself but I have investigated a number of mechanical failures of equipment, several of them occurred due to failed welds. Welds are ofen the weak link in the system and proper welding is a learned skill.

When I read about folks welding a vertical round bar to a horizontal round bar, I get concerned. This is a tough connection even for an experienced welder and some folks may not truly appreciate the forces at work on a tool rest. I know some folks have the tools and experience to fabricate whatever you may need. If so, have at it. For those who are unsure about your machining skills or the evaluation of stresses on equipment, I recommend that you consider purchasing rather than fabricating this important piece of equipment.

Steve

Re: Tool Rest Question

#11

Approximate hardness

Dale Miner

O-1, the most cost effective drill rod in the annealed state is approximately 190 to 210 brinell. That is equivalant to approximately 15 Rockwell C.

Cold rolled steel (1018 ) is approximately 120 brinell, or a bit softer than annealed drill rod. Hot rolled steel is more variable than cold rolled, but averages about the same hardness.

O-1 can be hardened to nearly 65 Rockwell C by heating above the trasformation temperature ( 1500f )and quenching in oil. This will result in the maximum hardness possible and the maximum brittleness. Usually, tooling is tempered back from max hardness to reduce the brittleness and make the tooling workable. Tempering temperatures vary depending on the application. For cutting tools, tempering to about 55 to 62 Rockwell C is done.

It is possible to purchase Pre Hardened drill rod, and usually the drill rod will be furnished at about 35 to 40 Rockwell C. At this hardness level, it is possible to machine with dififculty compared to annealed drill rod. At this hardness level, use for cutting tools is not practical, but is often used for forming tools.

Most HSS woodturning tools are somewhere in the range of 60 to 62 Rockwell C, much harder that annealed drill rod and still harder than prehard drill rod. Tooling with a hardness of 62 Rockwell can cut material with a hardness of 40 Rockwell, but with a shortened edge life compared to cutting material with a 200 Brinell hardness.

Re: Tool Rest Question

#12

Steven Antonucci

No welding necessary *LINK*

steven antonucci

I bought something like these, and now I can source whatever material I need to make the horizontal component from the local scrap yard for $5 and under.

My first piece was a 1" steel rod from a school bus door. I drilled a hole in it, and tapped it to fit the threading on the post. 20 minutes work, and I was done.

Steve


Modular