Variable speed?
Tom
My older Rockwell lathe has 4 pulleys in the head and 4 on the motor. What would be involved in converting to a variable speed?
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Variable speed?
Tom
My older Rockwell lathe has 4 pulleys in the head and 4 on the motor. What would be involved in converting to a variable speed?
Thanks!
Re: Variable speed?
John Lucas
It's a choice between DC variable speed or an AC 3 phase motor with a variable frequency drive. Either way you need a new motor and controller. In a nutshell. DC loses a lot of power when you turn the speed down so you have to change pulleys more frequently. However installation is a breeze. AC variable frequency drives don't loose as much power at low speeds so you seldom have to change pulleys. Installation requires a little more electrical skill and you may have to change some of the factory program settings which can be a little confusing
Prices have come down a lot on VFD s so the cost is similar on both
Re: Variable speed?
Tom
Do you have to change pulleys with a variable speed?
Re: Variable speed?
Josh bowman
No pulley change unless you want to. I VS' d my metal lathe with a 3/4 he 3 ph motor and Tech controller for about $200. Not to hard if you can install the motor in ok.
Re: Variable speed?
robo hippy
Well, you may want to consider buying a lathe that has variable speed already on it. It might be easier. The newer brushless DC motors are much better than the older ones, and do keep the torque at lower speeds. I am not an electrical engineer so can't really advise you much beyond that. Once you have variable speed you will wonder how you got along without it. My lathe (Robust) has 3 speed ranges. The low speed range I use for huge pieces, and for sanding. The mid range, which is where it is 90% of the time is mostly for bowl turning. I seldom use the high speed range. If I turned a lot of spindles, I would use it more often.
robo hippy
Re: Variable speed?
John Lucas
Depends on the size of turning and the horsepower of the motor. Well also the size of the pulleys. You certainly don't change anywhere near as often and once you've chosen the correct pulley maybe not at all. When I had a DC motor I usually roughed on one pulley and finished on another. With the AC drives as long as I pick the right push I don't have to change.
Re: Variable speed?
Bill Howatt
No simple answer because it depends on how big (the swing) your lathe is and what you tend to turn.
If you are turning large, wet out-of-balance blanks then you want a slow speed say even around 300 RPM. By having a low-speed pulley ratio you can keep the motor speed up in a more favorable torque area and also since it is likely a totally enclosed, fan-cooled (TEFC) motor the fan will turn faster for better cooling.
On most lathes this low-speed range will not allow for high-speed spinning, say 3000-3500RPM, such as you might want with a thin spindle so being able to move to a higher speed range is advantageous. An important fact in cutting is to consider the ft/min rate of the work going by the cutting edge which for a small diameter means a higher rotation speed.
I have a 20" General with electronic VFD and it has 4 speed ranges. Somewhat overkill but it likely is because they marketed a manual 4-speed lathe and it was easy to use the existing parts with a VFD. Lots of lathes have 2 ranges and some 3 and some only 1. Apart from perhaps the special motor on the Nova DVR, I think having 1 is not ideal.
Bill
Re: Remove Hut Crystal Coat finish
Dennis in Southern Oregon
It is analogous to driving a car with a four speed transmission. You could get by with using only one gear selection, but it would seriously compromise driving flexibility. I have a large Oneway with 2 HP VS motor and three speed ranges and although it spends most of its time in the middle range, I would not dream of giving up the other two speed ranges.
Dennis
Oops
Dennis in Southern Oregon
Again the curse of the sticky Subject line. For some reason the site remembers ancient postings and applies them to new postings.
Dennis
Re: Variable speed?
walta
If your Rockwell lathe has 10 or 12 inch swing I would not spend my money adding variable speed.
Very soon after you do this you will want a bigger lathe and it will come with variable speed.
I say save your pennies for a bigger lathe.
Walta