Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Old McNaughton knives

Posts

Old McNaughton knives

#1

Old McNaughton knives

ron bauer

Does anyone have old McNaughton corning knives (the large ones) that you have sharpened beyond last use and are collecting dust in the corner because you just can't bring yourself to throw them? I intend to turn them over, re-tip the "bottom", and try coring from the headstock end rather than the traditional tailstock method. I recently did just that on a large maple burl with the straight knife and it worked quite well. I re-tip my traditional knives with round carbide cutters which work quite well. I would do the same on these. I will be happy to compensate a reasonable amount for the knives and cover all packing and shipping. Thanks. Ron.

Re: Old McNaughton knives

#2

Re:  Old McNaughton knives

Barry Irby

The direct answer is No, I am still using mine. A "friend" borrowed them and ruined them by grinding the top surface. Mike Hunter saw my lament here on Wood Central and offered to re tip them. He used diamond shaped cutters and they work quite well. It would be interesting to compare them to your round cutters.

Back to your problem. I don't think there is anything fancy about the steel in my blades. Another friend and I re-bent them. Mine came very poorly shaped and only one in the set would cut like it was supposed to. After reshaping them they are much better. The shape is fairly simple after you understand it. There is a straight part with the cut for the handle, The curve that MUST be a segment of a circle and the tip. The tip should be in a straight line with the straight part. I think anyone that can put tips on should be able to bend the steel from flat bar stock.

It also makes sense to me to come at this from the headstock side.

Re: Old McNaughton knives

#3

Re:  Old McNaughton knives

ron bauer

Barry, Thanks for your thoughts and comments. I have a couple alternatives that I can try. Will have to wait till I finish a large set of book shelves for my daughter. Ron.

Re: Old McNaughton knives

#4

Re:  Old McNaughton knives

robo hippy

McNaughton used to make blades for coring from the headstock end. I don't know if they have any left or not. They weren't too popular. It does make sense though. A rounded carbide cutter might work fine, but sharpening isn't easy to do. Mike Hunter retipped a blade for me once upon a time. It worked fine.

robo hippy