Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Sorby Tools?

Posts

Sorby Tools?

#1

Sorby Tools?

Tom

On a previous post I asked about lathe chisel recommendations. You all responded and I thank you.

I was wondering about Sorby Tools. Are they something to consider? I know I had asked about unhandled tools but thought I would explore these.

Thanks!

Re: Sorby Tools?

#2

Sorby Tools

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Nothing wrong with Sorby turning tools, Packard Wood works just started selling some unhandled. Check website for details.

Think Sorby turning tools Still go on sale once or twice a year, check favorite vendor. Packard & Craft Supplies offer percentage off if buy more than one tool at a time. Check catalog or web site for details.

Re: Sorby Tools?

#3

Re: Sorby Tools?

Dick Coers

I don't understand your question Tom. Something to consider? What are your concerns?

Re: Sorby Tools?

#4

Re: Sorby Tools?

bmckearney

I highly recommend Sorby turning tools. I have been turning for many years and have tools from lots of different vendors, including Sorby, Glaser, Oneway, and Crown. I still prefer my Sorby tools in many cases.

The Glaser Hitec is a beautiful tool and I love the handle - stongly recommended, but at much higher price point as compared to Sorby.

I have a Oneway double ended bowl gouge with a Oneway handle - it's nice and since it is ground on both ends, kind of gives you twice the bang for your buck and you can do different grinds on each end.

Years ago I tried a Crown Pro PM bowl gouge - it's nice, but never been blown away by it.

And then there are the dozen or so various Sorby gouges - various sizes of spindle gouges, bowl gouges, roughing gouge and parting tools. They take a nice sharp edge very easily (I sharpen with a Tormek) and hold their edges reasonably well. I would highly recommend them and have nothing bad to say about them.

As a matter of fact, I just got a Sorby diamond parting tool for Christmas and I'm very happy with it.

A word of caution - I've tried bowl gouges from several vendors that were labelled as the same size. I've found that there are slight differences in the flute grind that makes them feel/behave differently. I've compared the tools side by side and can't make out any distinct difference in flute shapes, but have noticed differences in use.

By the way, I read the previous thread about tool recommendations - haven't yet tried any Thompson tools so have no opinion as of yet. Based on what others have to say, I'm interested. But I wouldn't take all of those recommendations as a negative against Sorby.

Re: Sorby Tools?

#5

Re: Sorby Tools?

mjonesrdg

Back around the turn of the century (yr 2000) Sorby put out a hollowing "kit", and called it the RS2000. I bought one. It came in a nice wooden box and it included a swan neck, a slicer, an extension, and a pistol grip fixture along with some goodies. It was (is) the poorest made, poorest machined, tool I have ever bought. Thumb screws that affix the extension or pistol grip require a wrench to tighten them down, the rubber handle covers slip on the shafts, the plating on the shafts are rough, and the ground flats (that receive the thumb screw) are poorly placed and are very shallow.

I'm sure that this tool kit was taken off the market for many reasons and many years ago....I'm sure that Sorby turning tools are of an excellent quality today, and that the RS 2000 was a single "mistake". However, with all the excellent USA made tools available, I never bought another Sorby and I cannot think of a good reason to purchase another in the future.

I did a "lazy withdrawal" thing once...pulling the swan neck tool out of a small opening...and got a catch that spun the grip up and whacked me good on the jaw. I know, I know, that's not Sorby's fault, but it remains the only tool that has ever hurt me.

I have often wondered if others have had similar experience????

Re: Sorby Tools?

#6

I stand corrected

mjonesrdg

I have learned that the RS 2000 is still being marketed today. Perhaps they have improved since I bought mine.

Re: Sorby Tools?

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Sorby Tools?

Jesper, Denmark

There is nothing basically wrong with Sorby. I have a few and many others. Except for tools I have ground specially for a particular purpose, I find that I always reach for the Thompson Lathe Tools first.

Check the replies you got to your question on the 24th - the same answers apply here.

Re: Sorby Tools?

#8

Joe Fleming

Re: Sorby Tools?

Joe Fleming

I like Sorby tools except for their hollowing tools. The swan neck shapes are wrong. Look at John Jordan or Trent Bosch tools. They are shaped correctly. Joe

Re: Sorby Tools?

#9

Re: Sorby Tools?

robo hippy

For basic turning tools, I prefer the Thompson or D Way. In part because you are buying from the people that are making them. Also, the steels that they use are much better than standard M2 high speed steel. Other than that, the flute design for gouges is the important part. I prefer more open flute design, which eliminates the V flutes, but Doug's V flute is pretty open, and I do like it. There is an opinion that the V 10 steel like Doug uses takes a better edge with the CBN wheels. I don't really know because that is all I have ever sharpened them on (8 plus years). Can't remember what it is like to use standard wheels. Given all the advantages of the CBN wheels, it is when, not if you are going to get them.

robo hippy