So I would like to upgrade to better lathe tools. Most of my stuff is 40 year old Craftsmen. They are quite short and not of the best quality.
I know that this is opening a can of worms but what brand? I have 1 Sorby and it seems quite nice. I was also wondering if it makes $ sense to buy just the tooling and make my own handles. If so what brand and is there a supplier you might recommend?
I like Hunter tools and make my own handles. These could be the last you'll ever need to buy. They hold their edge very well and you don't take much off with each sharpening.
Well I'm a fan of both Hunter and Thompsons but I use my Thompsons for 90 percent of the work I do and the Hunters and few odds and end older tools for the rest.
I have and like Thompson and I also have a lot of others from Benjamin's Best to Henry Taylor to P&N and some more.
Thompson definitely has an edge that lasts longer, IMO. All the others are high-speed steel without any additional treatment and I suspect around the same hardness. I see very little difference in the length of time an edge lasts but let's face it, with all the variables its not easy to be accurate.
You can look at some of the exotic alloy tools too, Oneway makes some, IIRC.
You might like the flute shape on one vs the other which is something else to consider.
In my opinion, TLT is one of the best "bangs for the buck" on the market today! This is the best way to get high-quality powder-metal steel (CPM 10V; 10% vanadium that really holds an edge) at an affordable price.
What the others have already said about these tools is absolutely true.
Another source for quality tools is D-Way Tools - I also like Dave's specialty tools as well, especially his beading tools, tear-drop tool, etc. (he uses a slightly different steel, but also quality to be sure!)
As was already noted, many of these tools come un-handled, so you may need to turn some handles, or buy one of the replaceable tool handles which are now made by many different vendors.
Many of the turning tools produced in or near Sheffield, England (Sorby, Crown, Hamlet, etc.) are also of good quality, but are somewhat more expensive (import/transportation costs, retailing, etc.), and while some of these might be powder metal allows ("PM") or cryogenically-treated, most of these are "generic" high speed steel, mostly M2. All of these hold an edge well, but not nearly as well as 10V steel, in my experience.
Good luck with your tool-buying decisions - there are many of us tool junkies on here with lots of experience, opinions, and stories of what to buy and what NOT to buy. Don't be afraid of asking questions!
For standard tools like gouges and scrapers you can't go wrong with Doug Thompson tools. I really like his handles as well but making your own is easy if you choose.
As others have said, Hunter and D-way make some nice specialty tools if you have those needs.
Flute shape can be very important and should be considered. I find some flute profiles clog more easily than others, but that can be due in part to the shape of the edge you grind, how you use the tool, and the type(s) of wood you turn. As with so many things, if you can try various types before you buy, it could save you money.
Again, a vote for Thompson and Hunter tools -- I have several of each. I haven't yet bought any D-Way tools but the beading tools are high on my list.
They have replaceable carbide inserts, and unless you have some sophisticated equipment, are pretty much unsharpenable.... Just replace the insert and you're back in business....
They can't be sharpened. I tried. However they hold an edge far longer than the other inserts that I've tried. Way longer than the EZwoodtools that I have. Mike has these made to his specifications. He sold carbide cutters as a profession before he retired so he really knows the stuff.
I have a collection of Sorby, Crown and miscellaneous others, but have stocked up on Thompson Lathe tools recently.
I like the shape and long useful profiles of the Crown. I have some very early Crown Powdered metal gouges, which had the bad tendency to chip, till I wore them down an inch or so. I now use the Crowns for roughing, and they no longer chip.
I have never gotten on wel with Sorby - chrome flaking off (why chrome them in the first place???) and the flutes seem prone to plugging. seems to me that Sorby are concentrating on lots of specialized tols, but miss the basic quality.
Since I started buying Thompson tools a few years back, I have never looked back. The steel is just the best and the profiles work very well. His scrapers and skews are thicker than most others, which adds to stability. You can pick the profile you particularly like - and making your own handles keep the cost down.
Since taking a few Thompson tools to a local gathering of turners here in Denmark, we have made several joint purchases to keep the shipping costs down. Since I screwed-up and lost a gouge, promised to a friend, I had to buy him another one - so to keep the shipping costs down, I guessed at what people might be wanting, and added 11 other tools to the one I really had to have. They arrived here a few days ago - and are all spoken for.
It just seems that once people get to try them, they want more. On top of that, Doug Thompson is very easy to deal with, does what he says he is going to do, and treat people as people, not just sources of income.
I'll go with Thompson any day. I love his tools and his handles. Doug's handles have helped me keep turning I have damage in both thumb joints and the rounded corners on his square handles let me grip the tool without getting cramps in my thumbs. Doug's tools do stay sharper longer and a nicer guy would be hard to find. I've been using Doug's tools for around 3 years now and I'm lucky enough to be able to call Doug a good friend,I only live about 40 minutes from his shop so it makes it easier for me to get tools and I have 18 I believe at last count. I have tools from most all the manufacturers but my Thompson tools are all I use now.
Contrary to all the others here, I would advocate that you shop for tools based on how you use them and how they work. I have a huge variety of brands, but I purchased them for their characteristics - not their label.
So, what are my biases (just to get them out of the way)? I am largely a Stuart Batty turning follower, and a John Jordan hollower kind of guy.
Since most people focus on gouges, I'll talk about my spindle and my bowl gouges. I'll mention skews and parting tools as well.
For bowl gouges, the shape of the flute is most important to me. To start with, most of my bowl gouges are 1/2" bars. I am partial to the flute shape of the Sorby bowl gouge. I buy these handled or unhandled (whatever is on sale) and rehandle them to my taste (mostly Trent Bosch handles). To be fair, I have several 1/2" bowl gouges, but the Sorby is the workhorse. I have Thompson, Glaser, Crown, Taylor, and Hamlet. For me, Sorby wins. I use the Glaser a lot as a shear scraper. I have a second 1/2" Sorby as a bottom-feeder.
Between the Sorby and Glaser, they cover about 90% of my bowl gouge use.
I also have a 5/8" Sorby and 5/8" Glaser that get a little use as well.
For Spindle gouges, the most important thing to remember is that the bottom of the flute on a properly designed spindle gouge cuts through the center of the steel bar. I like Sorby and Hamlet gouges, but mostly use a 3/8" Hamlet for this.
For skews, I like square edges with the sharp edges filed smooth. For rolling beads, the pivot you get with a square edge is perfect to direct the point.
For parting tools, I do not like the diamond tools. The facets on these tools can be non-symmetrical meaning that the cutting tip will not span the full width of the tool. This leads to binding. A simple rectangular tool is the best way to go. Part into the cut, back the tool out and move over to an overlapping cut and then cut deeper. In the end, you have a 3/16" cut either way.
You will never go wrong with a Thompson Lathe Tool. American made steel that is second to none at an affordable price. A long lasting edge that keeps you turning instead of sharpening. An owner that you can talk to and who will give you the straight scoop. My favorite happens to be the 5/8 V which I use for a good 80 to 90% of my turning. Lastly a guarantee that is the best you will ever see (Look it up on the website). And yes I used to help Doug sell but only because I felt his tools are the best out there and when I talked about them I was telling you the truth. Try one, you'll love it!
I like Thompson Tools. For spindle and bowl turnings. I like Parker 3/8" spindle gouges. If you grind off the bottom of a Parker 3/8" Spindle gouge it is the best (in my biased opinion) for finial work. You can get a great edge on them. But, for rest of my spindle work I like Thompson.
I love all my Thompson tools. I use primarily spindle and detail gouges in the type of work I do and I have multiple Thompson gouges in the sizes that I use ground to different shapes. I make my own shorter wooden handles and love to use these tools as they always make the job easier because they stay sharp for a long time between sharpenings.
I also have some Glaser spindle and detail gouges and they are very nice tools but I find them to be too cold to handle in my unheated shop. I have also become accustomed to using my shorter handled Thompsons in front of my body so when I pick up the longer handled Glaser gouges they feel awkward. Nevertheless the Glasers are very fine tools.
Buying from Doug makes me feel like I am buying from that hometown store we are encouraged to buy from. I certainly will never keep Doug in business with the amount I purchase but I can extol the virtues of the tools and the man who makes them.