Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

still playing with sharpening

Posts

still playing with sharpening

#1

still playing with sharpening

John Lucas

As some of you have read I set up 3 sharpening systems to play with. 180 grit CBN wheel, 1" strip sander, and a Tormek. I still haven't set the Tormek up to use my jigs yet but I've been playing with the strip sander and using 320 grit belt. It definitely cuts cleaner than the 180 grit CBN. I was turning finials for Christmas ornaments yesterday and turned this top finial out of Walnut. I used my small Sorby continental gouge (actually it's a mini Sorby roughing gouge that I reground to resemble the larger Continental gouge grind) I have it sharpened at about 45 degree bevel. Using the 320 grit belt I got this finish.

The photo doesn't show it well enough. It was almost burnished. Except for 2 tiny areas where there is totally side grain showing I could have just applied finish. 400 grit actually dulled the surface but did blend all the areas. I had to sand to 100 grit to resemble the finish off the tool. Now I do believe some of that is burnishing from the polished bevel of the tool however I did try my best not to do that so it's probably a combination of really clean cutting and burnishing.

the 320 belt removes metal very fast so you have to be careful or you'll grind away your tool. All it takes is a very light touch. It leaves a satin bevel with no striations. I'm going to use the 600 belt next which will leave an almost mirror finish

I've been using it to sharpen my spindle roughing gouge which is also sharpened at about 40 degrees. It seems to make it hold an edge longer although if you were actually roughing a lot of work an edge with that sharp of an angle might chip. For doing table legs and such I use my bigger roughing gouge that has an angle of about 50 degrees which handles those forces better.

After the holidays I'll start using some of the finer belts and hopefully get the Tormek jigs built and working so I can compare that tool.

Re: still playing with sharpening

#2

Re: still playing with sharpening

robo hippy

Interesting John. Jimmy Clewes made an interesting comment about burnishing. He does not like a rubbed bevel finish before sanding or applying finish. His comment was that the different densities of wood make for uneven sanding and uneven finish penetration. He shear scrapes all of his bowls. I have been experimenting with that and have found that seems to be correct. When finished with turning a bowl, there are always little lines left. You can't feel them, but you can see them. They have to come out, and if I sand them out, it seems to take longer. If I shear scrape them out, sanding seems to take less time.

I did try sharpening my gouges on a Tormek, and really couldn't feel or see any performance difference when compared to the CBN wheels.

robo hippy

Re: still playing with sharpening

#3

Re: still playing with sharpening

ron bauer

Lately I have been sharpening with a 1" belt. Regardlesss of the grit I find I have better tool control from the resultant flat bevel vs the concave that comes off any wheel. You could get the same effect from grinding on the side of the wheel which of course you are not supposed to do. I would like to run the belt in reverse so the grit is running away from the edge rather than in to it. Who knows...

Re: still playing with sharpening

#4

Re: still playing with sharpening

John Lucas

I agree about the burnishing not taking the finish well but this seems to take a good finish so I don't think it's very burnished if at all. That's just purely a guess based on how glossy the wood looks. I find a little sanding seems to make it take dye's and finishes quite well.

Re: still playing with sharpening

#5

Re: still playing with sharpening

John Lucas

Ron I don't find that true. About a year ago I did a lot of experimenting with concave, flat, and convex grinds. I didn't fine one superior to the other except in how you sharpen them. Handling them seemed about the same although I did have more trouble turning beads with a convex edge skew vs the flat or concave (which is really just a very small flat after you hone it)

Re: still playing with sharpening

#6

Several years ago I had the opportunity....

JamieDonaldson

....to use 2 dedicated belt sharpeners than ran in opposite directions, and were fitted with the same grit abrasive. I don't recall the brands, but found that a belt that runs into the cutting edge rounded it slightly, enough to give a less truly sharp edge when compared to the belt that ran away from the cutting edge. Other variables such as belt speed, tension, space between belt and platten, all gave inconsistent results compared to my wheel grinders. The edge from the belt that ran away gave a larger burr, and after consideration I decided that I wasn't interested in either unit, and would continue with my slow grinder, which has now been significantly improved with CBN wheels.

Re: still playing with sharpening

#7

Alan Zenreich

Re: Several years ago I had the opportunity....

Alan Zenreich

Jamie, your experience with belt direction is interesting. However as far as I know, virtually all knife maker belt grinders (e.g., my Bader III) drive the belt towards the workpiece. So my guess is that the folks who strive for really sharp steel have a different experience than yours.

Re: still playing with sharpening

#8

Re: Several years ago I had the opportunity....

John Lucas

Ditto what Alan said. However I did reverse the motor so the belt runs up. The platten touches the belt so there isn't a gap on mine. Because of the higher grit it definitely gives a sharper edge than the CBN wheel or grinding wheel. 180 grit and 100 grit respectively.

Now I'm still trying to learn is there any real advantage to the sharper edge for turning. There's no doubt it's true for carving but your not running wood past the edge in Miles per hours

Turning small dry pieces of wood I can definitely see the advantage. It takes less pressure to control the tool. It will start cutting taking off incredibly small bites so you can really refine the shape. You can start sanding with much finer grits which not only saves time and sandpaper it keeps the fine details better.

Jury is still out on turning greed wood because I have haven't quite figured out how to do a good test and don't have the Tormek set up yet to properly grind my gouges.