Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

The power of crowd sourcing

Posts

The power of crowd sourcing

#1

The power of crowd sourcing

Geoff Whaling

Cracked ferrules on tool handles.

I am requesting the help of Wood Central contributors / readers and their contacts to assess how many instances there are of cracked ferrules on any brand of purchased handled wood turning tools. I'm very interested in instances where the cracking is present on brand new tools or tools that have had very little or no use since purchase and have been stored well.

I know of several very reliable instances where the tools from prominent manufacturers were purchased with the crack present. In my instance the crack has developed since purchase, and not from use, with the tool being stored in a very dry fully enclosed garage / workshop. If anything I would have expected the ferrule to become loose from timber shrinkage rather than expand sufficiently to crack the tool ferrule. That of course depends upon the manufacturing & destination environments and the tool handle timbers original moisture content etc.

In my instance I have contacted the manufacturer and have had a very prompt reply. They have been very responsive pointing out their "tools carry a life-time guarantee so anyone who has a split ferrule should contact us and we will replace the handle free of charge."

“Please remember we produce tens of thousands of wooden handled tools and the percentage of tools that are reported with a split ferrule is extremely small.”

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#2

Steven Antonucci

I've never seen one?

steven antonucci

Not only have I never seen one, but I make my own handles, and I have never had one split... perhaps it is the use of copper fittings that are thicker?

In some cases, I don't even bother with a ferrule. They are a PITA if you make your own handles, as the wood is often still green and shrinks, and then your ferrule is loose...

S

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

Rob Wallace

Geoff:

I have been a turning tool junkie for well over 19 years and have purchased dozens of commercially produced turning tools of all kinds (many Sorby, some Hamlet, Packard, Crown, etc.) and have never had a cracked ferrule (although some of them were not the prettiest pieces of metal I've seen).

I would tend to agree with the manufacturer's statement that this phenomenon is likely rather rare.

Rob

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#4

Not so

Geoff Whaling

I think it is largely unreported. I know of many instances here in Australia, maybe northern hemisphere tool handles can't handle Aussie conditions but that is doubtful. Will see how many come out of the wood work won't we.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#5

Brad Vietje

None Here

Brad Vietje

Great idea -- will help determine if a wider problem in fact exists.

I have made a number of tool handles, with copper pipe coupling or brass compression fitting ferrules, which makes a nice little turning project.

In defense of Sorby, I had an "accident" with one of their tool handles that probably should have broken the ferrule, but she survived in great shape, even though the handle itself cracked. The ferrule did just what it was designed to do, and prevented a more catastrophic failure (or injury).

BTW: Back when I was young & stupid, and teaching myself to use a skew, I learned that 1" skews do not land like a throwing axe even when you're all alone in a big barn, and aiming at an "empty" box 15' away that just happens to look exactly like the box next to it packed tightly with Rock Maple, Black Locust and Mesquite turning blanks :\... oops; maybe it was my aim? (DAMHIKT)

Safe spinning,

an older & wiser

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#6

Re: I've never seen one?

John Lucas

I've gone through a lot of tools in the last 20 years. I've never seen it yet. I have had a couple get loose but never had one with a defective or cracked ferrule

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#7

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

robo hippy

I have one tool that has a cracked wood handle. The ferrule survived. It was part of a set of "Artisan" tools from Craft Supplies. A small scraper, 1/4 by 3/4, and a friend was using it. He turned away from the bowl as he was removing the tool from inside the bowl, and it caught the bowl while it was not on the tool rest. Careless mistake. It slammed down onto the tool rest. Failure was, in my opinion, due to inserting a flat tang into a round hole. When ever I make a scraper handle now, I make a sandwich style handle. I use a center piece the same thickness as the scraper tang, then cut the proper shape out for the tang, then sandwich bread (well wood actually) on either side of the meat, then turn the handle. I do have one Raffen signature spear point scraper (Craft Supplies) that has a crack in the ferrule, and the crack is right off the dent they put in it. Can't remember what made it crack. I still use it though, as is, but I did convert it to a negative rake scraper. I should replace the ferrule, and make a new handle, but it is a tool I seldom use. I guess the only way to get around the shrinkage issue would be to use stabilized wood. That would be outrageously expensive. Maybe the metal type handles, but with scrapers, we would still be left with a square peg in a round hole.

robo hippy

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#8

Steven Antonucci

burn in the tang in the round hole

Steven Antonucci

Simple and solid.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#9

Re: burn in the tang in the round hole

John Lucas

I agree with Steve. Just make a round hole smaller than the flat sides of the tang, heat it almost red hot and drive it in the wood. It makes a perfect fit, no glue is needed. I do this even with my round tools. I just drill a hole a little too small and then push it in after heating the end. It is very solid.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#10

Burning in a tang in the round hole...

JamieDonaldson

...in a handle is an old old practice, with both good and bad possibilities. If the reheating of the tang is allowed to work too far up the shaft of a hardened tool, the working hardness of that tool is lost thru the process of annealing, and that's the bad part. The good is that a tool shaft has reduced tendancy to break under stress, if the hardening of the desired cutting tool part of the metal shaft has not extended into the tang.. ;)

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#11

None here either.

Don Orr

Some ferrules have become loose over the years but no failures. A little epoxy and slip the ferrule back on and no worries.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#12

Re: Burning in a tang in the round hole...

John Lucas

You would have to let it sit for a long time at the high heat temperature to take the temper out of a blade. However if your worried about that simply put a pair of vice grips near the end of the blade and they will absorb the heat.

If your steel is HSS you can't ruin it with heat this way so don't worry about that.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#13

About 10% here

Geoff Whaling

I've been through our tools with purchased handles and arround 10% have cracked ferrules. I often purchased pairs of tools for my son & myself and strangely it is the ones that we do not use & have set aside with two prominent brands involved. Ferrules for 1/4" spindle gouge, 1/2" bowl gouge & large radiused scrapers have cracked, all very near the punch mark. Some tools were purchased when the local dealer was having difficulty and set aside for "ron".

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#14

Re: About 10% here

steve worcester

I have definitely seen cracked wooden handles, but up until recently, with the inter webs, seen only 1 cracked ferrule. Since the ferrule is generally copper, and it is really resilient, it just doesn't happen. Sure, maybe one in 1000 , but that would hardly be regularly even in the low volume woodturning tools are made.

If it did happen, it is an anomaly. Dare I say, a bad batch of copper. Just never seen it.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#15

Re: About 10% here

John Jordan

If the handle shrinks, the hole becomes smaller/tighter, NOT looser/larger. WOOD 101. :)

I'm with Steve, I've seen a LOT of gouges, and I don't recall seeing a ferrule/handle crack. I'm sure there are some, but I can't see a big it being a big problem.

John

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#16

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

Geoff Whaling

Here is a photo of three tools with cracked ferrules that have had very light use before being stored away in their original plastic sleves in a warm dry environment. They do crack, at least in Oz.


Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#17

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

John Jordan

Those are all yours, Geoff? That's enough to make one think all handles are cracked, no doubt. Still, I see 100's of gouges a year, and I don't recall seeing this, but by your example its a large percentage.

Let us know when you figger it out. :)

John

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#18

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

Geoff Whaling

John yes they are mine and as you can see almost pristine. I have thrown out others over the years. I do not purchase handled if at all possible now but most of these were purchased earlier when like all new turners we were guided & relied heavily upon the advice of others.

The heavy scraper was used perhaps once or twice, the other two have never seen a tool rest or a lathe. They have not cracked through misuse or abuse - just from being in storage in good conditions. We do get seasonal moisture variations but changes in moisture content should not do this to sound ferrules.

I don't know how I can go about this without posting images that identify brands as some are just iconic. Its not about witch hunts. I have no intention nor desire to harm brands. Its about improving safety for wood turners.

I have come across plenty like this with turners continuing to use them oblivious to the potential hazards and risks of using them in that condition.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with the tool steels - they are fantastic well made tools. Unfortunately the handles have a few issues.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#19

Brad Vietje

Freakish Ferrule Failure Phenomenon ?

Brad Vietje

Makes me wonder if your tool handles absorbed enough moisture to swell.... The hydraulic pressure could do it, but if those ferrules were thicker/stronger I don't think they would break.

I have not seen this, and for about 8 months out of 12 Northern Vermont is a pretty moist place. No doubt John would have seen this in TN, and all the turners in more humid locations would have quite a few problems if this were a general phenomenon.

Are you storing the tools in an unusual environment ? Next to a dryer vent ? I'd say you represent a pretty significant spike in ferrule failures -- maybe a fiendishly freakish ferrule failure fenomenon... or even a phiendshly phreakish pherrule phailure phenomenon ! WHEW -- say that 10 times phast ;)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

-22F to +36F in just over 24 hours.... hmm...

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#20

Re: Freakish Ferrule Failure Phenomenon ?

Geoff Whaling

Brad, Nothing like that, in tool totes in a cupboard in an enclosed garage that has very good ventilation. Another turner posted a photo on my post on the Aussie wood work forums with 5 handles with cracks. They appear to be from a standard set. Nothing freakish just more common than people believe.

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

#21

Re: The power of crowd sourcing

Jorge

Geof,

Looking at those cracks, makes me think they were made when they punched that dimple. Had nothing to do with the wood.