Need some info: I was given a real nice piece of Tamarack. It came from Idaho. It is from a downed tree; been drying about 5 years, appears to be solid and no soft spots. It measures about 48" X 24" [round]. I've never turned this wood; does anybody have experience with this tree. Before I put the band saw to it; thought I would ask if it's worth the effort. Isn't this tree in the Fir family?
I did have a piece of it once. It is a conifer of some type, and I didn't really care for it. I did make a bowl for the people who had the tree, but didn't do any more.
It isn't a fir but a member of the larch family and is also known as American Larch or Eastern Larch.
Unlike evergreens which it looks like in the summer it sheds it needles in the fall.
I have cut some down but never turned it because it appears similar to evergreen softwoods and I have read it has the alternating hard-soft growth rings which makes even sanding difficult. It supposedly has a high silica content which will dull tools a bit faster than expected.
It isn't considered a high value wood and there is really only one way of finding out if you like turning it or the finished product. I think it has a decent grain.
If the wood is from Idaho, and that diameter, it is western larch, Larix occidentalis, and sometimes commonly (and mistakenly) called tamarack. Eastern larch is most often called tamarack, seldom gets larger than fence posts, grows slowly, and in northern Alberta and points east is a good indicator of muskeg soils. Wood properties of western larch and Douglas-fir are very similar, and I am told that even experts cannot distinguish between them as lumber without a magnifying glass, hence the lumber designation fir-larch at the lumber yard. Slow growing fir and larch have very close growth rings, so the differential in hardness between spring and summer wood is not noticeable. I cut larch all the time with a cross-cut saw (lumberjack type) and a good piece with tight grain is a joy to saw. I have turned spectacular pieces out of both larch and Douglas-fir. I am not aware that the wood is higher in silica than other species. When I file saws that have cut larch I see no effects of silica, as opposed to filing saws that have cut quaking aspen or cottonwood when high silica effects show on the cutting edges. A fair few pieces of wood burned in our stove have been cut by hand with a crosscut saw, so my observations come with plenty of sweat equity.
I'd certainly defer to Bos' experience with the western species.
Here in New England, we have Tamarack trees (Larix laricina, and thus true Larch family members) that are up to about 18" - 20" in diameter, and commonly used where a rot resistant wood is needed. These are great for outdoor furniture or framing up a pavilion or outdoor structure. The stuff we have does have a tendency to twist as it dries -- maybe it tends to grow in windy places (?). We planted 4 of them about 8 years ago that are doing fine.
I have never turned any slow growth samples with closely spaced growth rings, but it sometimes does grow in large pure stands, so I would expect wood from these trees might have more densely spaced rings. We have a lot more water available than some of the drier locations in the west, so our trees will tend to grow faster. I would expect slower growth in the western species growing in the drier areas east of the Rockies.
The stuff I have used has been fast growth, rather coarse wood that was no particular joy to turn. I tried a few spindles & bowls and a hollow form. Not my favorite wood for turning, but a favorite for timber framing and a beautiful tree in the fall. Since there was such a difference in hardness between early and late growth, I experimented with a wire wheel and scorching with a propane torch, which did result in some interesting results well worth more experimentation. Would probably be a great wood to sandblast, too.
Like Bill Howatt says, you won't know until you try it, and it might be some of the really good fine grain stuff that Bos has used.
I haven't turned any Tamarack or Larch as fresh cut as yours---but here in MN, my Grandpa cut beaver flooded Tamarack in the winter of 1920-21, squared it on three sides with a broad axe and built a home that summer for my Grandma and my mother, born in March. The family grew to 8 children and the home was lived in until 1950 when the new house was built. The old log home was then used as a garage/shop. The roof was not kept in good repair and the building had to be removed in 2006. The logs were about 10 inches in diameter---12-14 inches before they were squared. I salvaged some of the logs that were in good shape and have turned bowls about 6-7 inches in diameter, candle holders, Christmas ornaments, tops, and wands that I have given to my surviving Aunts, and interested cousins, as mementos of Grandpa and Grandma's work.
The wood has a wonderful grain and is very aromatic. It is very hard and very brittle---but is is kind of old! It has sanded well, although since it is so hard, I have had to sharpen the tools frequently, and the pieces haven't needed much sanding. I have used Behlen's Woodturner's Finish on most of the pieces.
I don't know how our MN Tamarack or Larch would compare to the Western Larch, but because of the history and interest of the relatives, this was a worthwhile project.
My intent was to include a photo---but it disappeared along with the message.... John Rubash
Tamarack, or Tamarisk (Salt-Cedar) ? Tamarisk has fine fir / cedar like needles, and is a pest here in the western desert, primarily found in arroyos. Can suck up 100 gallons a water a day. It was originally introduced to prevent soil erosion. When it catches fire it will explode just like a pine. Makes beautiful turnings.
is the Algonquin voice for the eastern kind. As Brad points out, it's very rot resistant and twists and checks when it dries. It grows in wet places. Ellis mentioned another use for it, ship's knees were made often from hackmatack. Around here there is a ship totally made from hackmatack.
I'm always promoting the use of old wood, or trees from the old home-places.
I'd like to add that the roots were a favorite source for lashing material where needed, like bark canoes, back before Walmart and Amazon.
We don't have it down here in our area, so I just use Slippery Elm root, whenever I need some. Makes a good cough medication too, according to Granny Clampit. Who would know better than her? She grew up down here before heading out to Beverly Hills. Smirk