Potential hazard from cheap manufacturing ......
Geoff Whaling
I understand why they do it. Its cheap!
As this experience shows, a combination of small factors - an archaic cheap work practice; poor quality "brass" material in the ferrules, poor quality assurance / inspection, and a turner thinking "I will get around to fixing it."
Defective materials & poor work practices during manufacturing are the major contributor to a dangerous hazard - the split handle. Potential outcomes from this hazard range from replacing the handle, right up to a potential death.
There have been several deaths of wood turners in the past five years or so where the cause is "unknown" or overly simplified as "the wood exploded" a contributing factor could be the turner loosing control of the tool! A split handle or ferrule will eventually fail, leading to loss of control.
Many of these ferrules are split before they reach the customer. Now if the manufacturer spent maybe one or two percent of the cost of the handled tool on a decent ferrule and used some flexible adhesive the ferrule wouldn't fall off with the natural timber movement and the outdated practice of punching of the ferrule would not be necessary or would it contribute to splitting the handle & ferrule. The work practice of stamping/punching the handle may have been acceptable with a quality brass ferrule but it isn't with el-cheapo "brass".
It is a dangerous practice to continue to turn with a split ferrule - you may get away with it for a while, but it will catch up with you eventually. A good quality ferrule is less than a couple of bucks - retail!
As a result of this I went & rechecked the ferrules on my large scrapers from the same manufacturer. Same hazard, a crack in the ferrule & you guessed it beside the punch mark. A few tools now have new handles & other handles now have new ferrules.