Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Broken bowl gouge

Posts

Broken bowl gouge

#1

Broken bowl gouge

james jacomb

Yikes! I finally got around to using my new bowl gouge I bought several years ago and during my session I noticed that the farrell was broken and the handle is split. My rest was at most 2.5" from the bottom and much closer on the sides. Not sure what happened I don't recall any unusual events, I took the time yesterday to watch several tutorials on the computer concerning the correct use of a bowl gouge. Any suggestions.


Re: Broken bowl gouge

#2

Alan Sweet

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Alan Sweet

IF CA was used when the shaft was inserted and the ferrule was installed after the shaft and before the CA was setup, it is possible that the CA expanded enough to weaken an already weak ferrule.. I know that drilling a hole say 3/8" and installing a 3/8 shaft AND putting CA or epoxy into the hole can weaken the wood if the adhesive expands.IF the fit is tight.

It does look (to me) like you had expansion and a weak ferrule.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#3

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Paul Singer

I would use this opportunity to make my own handle. Just ditch the one that is on it now. Many instructions around for making handles. Primarily just find a blank of your liking (Ash, Cherry, Walnut) are a few of my favorites and turn a handle of you size you prefer then make a collar out of copper pipe or brass fittings. Glue it all together with epoxy and you have as good as or better handle than you can buy.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Mike Stafford

I will go out on a limb and guess that this was a Sorby tool. I have had the ferrules split just like that on a couple of tools. The material from which the ferrule was made which I assume was brass is very thin and split on tools subjected to no stresses. I have not had any of my handles to split however.

As some others have said now is the time to turn your own handle. Have some ferrule material handy and use it to size the tenon upon which it will sit. A tight fit is essential and a dab or two of epoxy will not hurt. Copper pipe nipples cut to the appropriate length will work just fine or you can buy ferrules from Craft Supplies and Lee Valley in various sizes.

2 1/2" is not an excessive amount of overhang for a 1/2" bowl gouge but if possible it is good to reduce that by turning the tool rest so that it is inside the bowl being turned to reduce the overhang even further.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#5

Making Tool Handles

Doc Green

Here are three articles that explain how to make a wooden tool handle:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/maketoolhandle.html

The third article shows how to make a "wrapped" ferrule using string and epoxy. This avoids having to do any metalwork, and the resulting ferrule will be plenty strong. (Personal preference: use epoxy to coat the wrapped string instead of CA. I don't like CA in this application, for no particular reason.)

Making your own handle is no big deal. Have fun! ~Doc

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Dick Hines

Make your handle out of an aluminum bar. Very east to do. You can use your chuck and wood lathe to drill the hole for the gouge.

I have not made handles out of wood for years.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Brad Vietje

Now THERE'S a fellow with a heated shop! :b

I'm expecting a low temp of +5 degrees F by morning, and turning in the winter with wooden handles is tough enough. I don't even try if it's below about 10 degrees, but do fine if above freezing. Aluminum handles ? Now that's COLD!

Can't wait till I have a heated space for turning, but not yet. :\

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#8

Wood not dry when handle made?


Re: Broken bowl gouge

#9

Re: Broken bowl gouge

jim bnreeden

Brad - Pipe insulation!

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Mike Stafford

I don't even look out the window at my shop when it is below 40 degrees.

I have zero tolerance for the cold anymore. Go South old man.....

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#11

Re: Broken bowl gouge

jim bnreeden

Can't even spell my own name - breeden!

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#12

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Sergio

Yes, a strong wooden handle may be the solution. I stopped using copper of brass ferrules when I started using the Oneway thread-lock ones. They have a tapered thread that takes care of the contraction or expansion of the wood and in my opinion are absolutely fantastic. The taper is easy to make with their inexpensive template.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#13

Re: Broken bowl gouge

robo hippy

I have always thought that the dent in the ferrule, especially when the brass is that thin, makes a weak point. Of course, that is where your's broke. The dent is along the side grain line which is how the wood would split with an axe. I get heavy sections of brass pipe, 1 1/4 inside diameter, and 1/8 inch thick, and 1 inch long. The fit is very tight, but they do loosen up a bit in the summer, which is my dry season. The twine and glue method works fairly well. Get some Tite Bond in the crack, then wrap the wood as tightly as you possible can. This makes a pretty good joint. Not sure I would totally trust it for my heavy handed style of turning, well roughing any way, but fine for finish cuts.

robo hippy

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#14

Re: Broken bowl gouge

james jacomb

Thanks for all the help! This is a Henry Taylor tool from craft supplies with all its beauty I never expected it to crack. Maybe I'll use some persimmon for a new handle I like making spoons out of it and the fruit makes a nice pudding too! Never had this happen with my other tools which I have used for 37 years, go figure...

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#15

Fix or Replace

Bill Howatt

My guess is the "crimping" of the ferrule caused the handle's straight grain to split and the hole in the ferrule combined with stresses of turning with a cracked handle split the thin brass.

If I were to repair it I would remove the ferrule, pry the split apart a bit and coat the split interior with epoxy. I would coat the tool shaft with epoxy and reassemble. Don't use too much epoxy on the shaft.

I would then replace the ferrule with a tight fitting piece of copper pipe or LV ferrule. I have forgone the metal ferrule and have replaced it with fiberglass and epoxy on the end of the handle. I always epoxy my tools in and this gives the handle extra strength since it is being "held together" even where the tool is, not just at the sides. I've never had to remove a tool but I think a bit of heat on the shaft will break the epoxy bond if necessary.

Or you can just start from scratch and make a new handle to fit any ferrule material you have or design you want - probably no more work than a repair job.

Bill

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Dick Hines

I wrap the handles with golf club wrap. Makes them soft and warm.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#17

Re: Fix or Replace

Geoff Whaling

I'm going against the flow - the ferrule was cracked at manufacture when they stamped that idiotic punch mark. You just didn't see it.

Then while turning you have stressed the handle with the typical use & typical tool overhang but there was no support from the cracked ferrule. It has just opened up more with each use.

Sorby use cheap rubbish ferrules then punch a hole in them too! The ferrule on the Henry Taylor looks the same to me. The so called brass in them is very very grainy when you examine them closely. We see a lot of those ferrules cracked on tools here in Far North Queensland.

I use copper capillary fittings (Yorkshire) & cut them in half for lighter tools. I purchase good quality brass ferrules for hardworking tool handles - bowl gouges, heavy scrapers etc.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#18

Re: Fix or Replace

Geoff Whaling

Note that the crack in the timber also aligns with the punch indentation! It is also in the area of tightest grain. Cost cutting and poor manufacturing practices that may create a potentially very hazardous situation. Thankfully you are uninjured.

Try the manufacturer for a replacement handle.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#19

bicycle handlebar tape is also great.

John Lucas

It provides a layer of cushion as well as the warmth. I hate a cold shop and unfortunately mine is all winter.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#20

shrinkage occurs  from a Seinfeld episode

John Lucas

The reason they punch the ferrules is that wood shrinks and the ferrules get loose and fall off. The punch mark is deep enough to grab the wood even if the wood shrinks. It will get a little loose but won't fall off. Then in the summer when the wood swells it locks itself in place.

I have had ferrules fall off when the wood shrunk too much but never had one break. They are awfully thin however.

I make my own ferrules from threaded brass nuts you buy for connnecting copper pipe. They are hex shaped but you can turn those down to round if you like using standard wood turning tools and techniques. The good thing about these is you turn the wood just a hair larger than the threads and then force the nut on with a wrench. This creates it's own threads in the wood and will never loosen.

I have also fastened regular round ferrules onto the wood by drilling from the side a 1/8" hole inserting a piece of metal with epoxy. Cut it off and file it even with the ferrule and you have a very positive lock. I have used brass brazing rod, nails, and copper wire for the pins. I drill the hole about 1/4" deep and slightly sharpen the pin. Apply epoxy and drive the rod into the hole.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#21

Potential hazard from cheap manufacturing ......

Geoff Whaling

I understand why they do it. Its cheap!

As this experience shows, a combination of small factors - an archaic cheap work practice; poor quality "brass" material in the ferrules, poor quality assurance / inspection, and a turner thinking "I will get around to fixing it."

Defective materials & poor work practices during manufacturing are the major contributor to a dangerous hazard - the split handle. Potential outcomes from this hazard range from replacing the handle, right up to a potential death.

There have been several deaths of wood turners in the past five years or so where the cause is "unknown" or overly simplified as "the wood exploded" a contributing factor could be the turner loosing control of the tool! A split handle or ferrule will eventually fail, leading to loss of control.

Many of these ferrules are split before they reach the customer. Now if the manufacturer spent maybe one or two percent of the cost of the handled tool on a decent ferrule and used some flexible adhesive the ferrule wouldn't fall off with the natural timber movement and the outdated practice of punching of the ferrule would not be necessary or would it contribute to splitting the handle & ferrule. The work practice of stamping/punching the handle may have been acceptable with a quality brass ferrule but it isn't with el-cheapo "brass".

It is a dangerous practice to continue to turn with a split ferrule - you may get away with it for a while, but it will catch up with you eventually. A good quality ferrule is less than a couple of bucks - retail!

As a result of this I went & rechecked the ferrules on my large scrapers from the same manufacturer. Same hazard, a crack in the ferrule & you guessed it beside the punch mark. A few tools now have new handles & other handles now have new ferrules.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#22

Are you sure of the manufacturer

Geoff Whaling

Are you sure of the manufacturer, does not look like a Henry Taylor tool handle to me.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#23

Re: Are you sure of the manufacturer

james jacomb

Yep, I bought it from Craft Supplies. It is their "Artisan Series" made by Henry Taylor. It was brand new till I used it that day, anyway I learned what I needed to know that it's not uncommon to happen and like anything now days you must be vigilant about your safety

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#24

Re: Potential hazard from cheap manufacturing ....

Dick Coers

"They" don't do it because it's cheap, "they" do it because woodturners want cheap tools. High end tool companies use collets, steel adaptors, steel handles, etc. The consumer sets what sells. If noone bought the tool sets at Harbor Freight, they wouldn't have them on the shelves. Dollar menus at fast food joints, cheap woodturning tools, same thing.

Re: Broken bowl gouge

#25

"Caveat emptor" has little bearing ...

Geoff Whaling

Dick, you make good points - "they" includes the customer. Sure there are high quality high end tools, but there is also plenty of overpriced tooling with potential safety issues / hazards out there.

"Caveat emptor" has little bearing under Australian consumer law, and no doubt in many other countries. The designer, manufacturer and the supplier has a duty, an obligation, to supply "safe" products which include hobbyist’s tools. The designer and manufacturer, one would trust, have considerable expertise in the strength of materials and understand the stresses the hand tools and other tooling they manufacture are subjected too.

On the other hand the majority of consumers of wood turning tools do not understand those issues and will try to maximise their purchasing power. A minority of manufacturers I believe take advantage of the fact that the market is largely uninformed in these matters and is not likely to challenge them with materials/product testing, and that consumer safety authorities are not resourced to be all that interested either. This partly explains how so many rubbish light gauge tubular steel bed lathes destined for land fill are sold to unsuspecting consumers by mainstream hardware chains.

Woodturning consumers are not a highly organised group and are not active reporting hazardous occurrences. So many safety issues fly under the radar.

There are of course plenty of good manufacturers who listen to their customer’s feedback, address the matters raised in a timely manner, refine their products and educate / inform their valued customers. Unfortunately "they" are being overwhelmed by mediocre, cheap and potentially unsafe tooling.