Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Why Upright? (and Stabile)

Posts

Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#1

Why Upright? (and Stabile)

charlie belden

With bowls, plates, vases, hollow forms, lidded boxes, etc,there is an obvious Top and Bottom. The Bottom is, with the exception of "rockings bowls", flat - defining the horizontal plane and thus "what's up".

Then there's the Femisphere, which has no Up or Down, it's orientation AND location change if you touch it (or bump the surface it's on). Femispheres are inherently unstabile and tend to woddle around in somewhat unpredictable directions. Round bottomed pieces seldom will sit "upright" - usually coming to rest at their own balance point.

Now technically, Femispheres are NOT turned multi axis pieces since all the actual turing is done on only one axis, the turning split apart (on a "paper joint") - and one part rotated 90 degrees to the other on the flat faces.

True multi axis "spindle" forms almost always have at least one end of the blank left on the piece - to provide a foot for it to stand on. And that foot makes them stabile.

But - What If - you turned away "the foot" - and let the multi axis "sprindle turned" piece find it's own UP. - whch will probably be in some postion resting on its "side" - though multi axis pieces often don't have sides, but rather, they may have faces and edges. And because they have intersecting curves, once on their "side", they can roll in unpredictable ways, simiilar to how a Femisphere behaves.

Here's and example of an unstabile simple multi axis piece - two rounded bottom and top pestles (thing morter and pestle) - smooshed together - at a slight angle to each other. The form, on it's side would be very unstabile, rolling and rocking easily.


IF - it were placed in another inherinlty unstabile form - like a rocking bowl . . .


Lot's of interesting possibilities for Dynamic . Kinetci pieces.

Have YOU played with unstabile pieces or combinations of pieces?

If so, care to share what you found that was interesting?

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#2

Here are a few.... *LINK*

mjonesrdg

http://www.woodturningcenter.org/2006/Motion/gallery.html


motion gallery

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#3

Re: Here are a few....

charlie belden

I found his work quite a while back and his work is an excellent example of dynamic pieces that done by someone with a very refined sense of aesthetics - and if you study his work - a great deal of turning skill.

Thanks for sharing that link. He has done videos of a few of his pieces In Motion. You really have see one In Action to fully appreciate what he does.

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#4

Ellis Walentine

Rocking vessel

Ellis Walentine

I turned a rocking vessel once out of Black acacia. No matter how you set it on a flat surface, it rocks itself back to upright. It is essentially an onion-shaped bowl with a rounded (no foot) bottom. I left a lot of thickness in the bottom, so that has the effect of pulling the bottom downward as it rocks, slowly, like a pendulum, to upright. It is always a show stopper. I wish I had a video to show you. Maybe I can get that together....

Ellis

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#5

"Hyper Egg"  *LINK*

charlie belden

There is a type of form that has what kayakers call low primary stability and high secondary stability. When you're getting into the kayak it rocks side to side really easily. But when you're in and seated, it wants to remain upright - and you really have to lean to the side a lot to get it to rock OVER. I think it's called a "hyper ellipsoid".

I did a lidded box using the idea - and added a "ball joint" finial to it. You can lay the thing on its side and it will right itself and rock back and forth. Because of the finial's ball joint connection to the box - and the fact that it has a counter weight hidden inside the box, the finial tries to remain vertical regardless of how vertical the box is - or isn't. Fun to play with - and confusing to look at when it moves - because the finial stays upright. I should have done a video of it in action - but I think I've given it away.

http://www.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/Articulation/CBsuperEggWarticulFinial.jpg


more details about the piece

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#6

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

Peter Rand

Charlie - just thinking but not tried it - but won't your MA spindle find a three-point stable stance, two ends and someplace in the middle circle??

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

#7

Re: Why Upright? (and Stabile)

charlie belden

Peter:

Yes it will come to rest - as even a perfect sphere will - until there's a breeze, bump, touch - or out here in California - a "tremor". The idea is to encourage interaction between "viewer" and piece, making the human a Participant rather than a passive Viewer. If physical contact is to be prohibited, an unobtrusive device, such as your capacitor pulsed small electric motor rotating a turntable, or a shallow bowl, the multi axis is on or in, couldl make it move.

Viewing and Watching can be very different experiences. You View an upright and stabile piece. You Watch a piece that moves, especially if it moves in unpedictable ways.

Here's a great example of a dynamic piece oriented in an unexpected way - and behaving in a very unexpected way. It was a piece made to meet a Club Challenge - "Footed". Most folks turned a bowl that had a "foot". Kent Mosely stretched the term "foot" to include "leg" - and added a title "Bowl Legged" to take the interest level up a bit. The piece is run to WATCH and PLAY with.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7TJImw-0d54