Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Lathe Selection

Posts

Lathe Selection

#1

Lathe Selection

Ken Romines

I need some advice before I make a Christmas selection.

I am selling some of my older equipment to raise money and make room for a new lathe. I will sell my FrankenDelta (12x36) to make room for its replacement. (The FrankenDelta is built from parts and includes a one horse 3 phase Delta saw motor with a Teco speed control.) I have a Penn State lathe that I really enjoy and usually use for pens and smaller items.

There is not a lot of money difference between these three lathes so what I would appreciate is your comments on overall control, belt changes, accuracy and company support, etc. I noticed that Greg Hagen had a new Jet and everybody has read the reports on the Delta. I haven't heard a lot about the General and didn't know about it until Ellis posted the General ad today.

Delta 46-460

General Maxi Lathe VF 14x17

Jet 1221VS 12x21

Which should it be?

Thanks

Ken

Re: Lathe Selection

#2

Re: Lathe Selection

Chuck Bjorgen

I bought the Delta 46-460 with bed extension about three years ago. Very satisfied with it although the stories about failing switches concerns me. If I were making the choice today it would be the Jet 12", which was not available when I bought the Delta.

Re: Lathe Selection

#3

Re: Lathe Selection

Jerry Klug

I would like to move up from my Jet 1014VS to the 1221VS as I have asked a number of turners that have used this lathe and all recommend it. Currently they are allowing sale discounts for Black Friday so with the lower price and more features, it seems a good time to buy.

Re: Lathe Selection

#4

Re: Lathe Selection

Greg Haugen

Ken, here's an important question. Do you have service centers nearby for any of the lathes? The best lathes out there can have issues and if you don't have service.....well you know. Locally, for me, the dealer is a service center for all 3 brands. Delta's lathe is a decent lathe, there has been some issues with the newer ones (Delta has changed hands a couple of times in recent years) and some places have stopped carrying the brand altogether. General is another decent brand. I've had General lathes in past. They've been good machines. The new Jet is an incredibly machine. The casting is heavy duty, the speed control on the VS model is excellent, it has a locking spindle (not just a spring loaded lock), and even though the stand isn't as inexpensive as other stands for midi lathe, it's the heavier duty than any other that I've seen. There are components, the upper and lower components, are cast iron not just bolted and welded steel. I rarely change belt positions on it since it has a nice range in all three positions but when I do, the mechanics of it are simple, fast, and easy. To say the lathe is quiet is an understatement too. I really like my Jet.

Between the three lathes, Delta makes me nervous with the customer service issues (even if you found one of the older-2 years or more-lathes you'd still have to deal with the current customer service). General is a decent company, nothing bad can be said about them. I do believe there's a warehouse in the USA now so getting components and parts isn't an issue like before with going over the border and shipping. The Jet lathe is rock solid, a nice machine, and Jet is readily available from a lot of places. It is probably the most expensive of the three though but it's a nice machine.

Where are you located? Are you able to try them out at someone's shop?

But as I said, before you make a decision check on service options for all of the brands.

Re: Lathe Selection

#5

Service centers don't help if they can't get parts

Dick Coers

Go with the Jet. It took me over 8 months to get a rebate from Delta and I swear it was only because I left some nasty comments on their Facebook page. Parts supplies are supposed to be better, but I would have to see it to believe it.

Re: Lathe Selection

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Another vote for the Jet

Jack Guzman from Maine

I got the 1221vs when it was brand new and once I got busy on it I bought the extension bed and sold my Grizzly beast. That is a nice machine.---Jack

Re: Lathe Selection

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: Another vote for the Jet

Bill Blasic

What I did is I looked at the Jet 1221 and at $1150 for lathe and stand I opted to go to the 1642 for another $700. You can always turn smaller on a big lathe but you can't turn bigger on a small lathe. 4 times the weight, sliding head and the ability to turn bigger well worth the extra bucks.

Bill

Re: Lathe Selection

#8

The Jet is running a sale until Monday.

Greg Haugen

The 1642 is on sale for $2000 until Monday but then goes back to $2345. The 1221vs and stand are also on sale for $950, until Monday. The sale is 15% off. Woodcraft's website is showing the sale and the prices.

Re: Lathe Selection

#9

Stand is 50% off with 1221VS

Dick Coers

Don't know how that figures into the price, or if you can get 15% off on the lathe and then half off the stand, too confusing for me!

Re: Lathe Selection

#10

Lyle Jamieson

1642

Lyle Jamieson

The 1642 is a huge jump in quality and strength for a small price to pay. The change from one inch spindle and bearings to 1 1/4 spindle and stronger bearings is huge. Get it now so you dint have to upgrade later. Its a lot more fun on the bigger lathe.

Re: Lathe Selection

#11

Re: 1642

John Lucas

I agree. Beg, borrow, or just save up and step up to the 1642. It is a fantastic lathe. I have the Delta. It's a good machine but like the others have said I'm a little leary of parts availability unless the company shows us more stability. The new Jet midi is a really nice lathe but when the 1642 weights probably 4 times as much. The weight of a lathe makes a huge difference in enjoyment. It is simply much more stable especially with out of balance pieces. I was fortunate to step up to the Powermatic which is another step above the 1642. I frequently get to demonstrate on the Jet 1642 at different clubs and it's a wonderful lathe.

Re: Lathe Selection

#12

Re: Lathe Selection

John Veerkamp

I had that Delta lathe with the older 110V controller. The controller had problems at about 6 years. It was a Baldor controller and there was an authorized Baldor shop close that was able to fix it much more reasonably than Delts authorized shop. I eventually upgraded to a PM and sold the Delta. It was a good solid lathe that serviced me well.

Re: Lathe Selection

#13

Re: Lathe Selection

Ken Romines

Gentleman,

I really appreciate the information on lathe selection. The jury is still out (i.e., I still have the money in my pocket) and if I go with the midi size lathe the Jet will be the answer. However, after a 300 mile conversation with my financial adviser (my wife) I will take a long hard look at the Jet 1642. Like several said, the jump money wise is not that much.

We live in Lubbock, TX and there is not a lot of suppliers for this type of equipment. But I will spend some time in Dallas around Christmas and I will do some serious checking there. We also have a club meeting next Saturday and I will ask some favors there to take a look at different lathes. I guess if I would put together a demo for the club I could use their 3520!

I don't want to make a mistake buying too small since I am eligible to retire and then I get to spend a lot of time in my shop, "playing."

Thanks again,

Ken